News & Trending Shopping & Deals News

14 Costco Foods Shoppers Say Aren’t Worth the Hype

Looks can be deceiving, so we found the top buys to avoid and the best alternatives.

14 costco foods that look better than they taste
Updated Nov. 18, 2026
Fact check checkmark icon Fact checked
Google Logo Add Us On Google info

Do cute containers and pretty packaging influence your grocery purchases? Some popular products may look good from the outside, but that's where the promise ends.

Shoppers in the know have the best Costco hacks for finding deals on items that taste as good as they look.

So, if you're not sure which gourmet goodies and foodie finds are actually worth the cash, read on to learn more about which picks you should avoid and the affordable alternatives that customers rave about.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Kirkland Signature Smoked Pulled Pork

kirkland signature smoked pulled pork

Price: $13.99

The picture on Costco's store-brand pulled pork package makes it look like a mouthwatering meal. When one Costco subredditor asked whether the KS pulled pork or Del Real Carnitas are better, user 138Crimson_Ghost831 replied, "Carnitas for me. The pulled pork tastes like cured ham smothered in bag BBQ sauce."

Del Real's 2.5-pound pack costs $18.99 ($7.60 per pound), while the Kirkland pork costs $6.99 per pound. The added $0.61 per pound is worth it based on customer preference.

Prepared pulled pork can be a convenient shortcut for busy weeknight dinners, since it eliminates the time and effort of cooking and shredding a large cut of meat. It's also easy to serve in sandwiches, tacos, or alongside traditional barbecue sides.

Heavenly Dark Chocolate Oatmeal Hunks

heavenly dark chocolate oatmeal hunks

Price: $8.99

Dark chocolate and oatmeal combined into one organic snacking treat? The description sounds as good as these "hunks" look. But savvy shoppers aren't thrilled with the taste. Redditor Mypetdolphin posted, "I was really disappointed! Now I have 2 ½ bags that I won't eat."

Kirkland Signature's soft and chewy granola bars are only $9.99 for a 64-count box if you're looking for a low-cost chocolate-oat option.

The Kirkland alternative offers plenty of individual portions for lunchboxes, afternoon snacks, or keeping at your desk. Each 0.85-ounce bar contains 100 calories and is made with whole rolled oats and semisweet chocolate chips.

Snak Yard Sweet Potato Sticks

snak yard sweet potato sticks

Price: $11.99

The $11.99 bag of sweet potato sticks may look like a snacking sensation. But according to Redditor lazarus902, "SnakYard sweet potatoes…nope. 100 percent do not recommend. Weird texture and taste."

Swap this potato pick for another produce-packed snack like Solely Organic Fruit Jerky ($16.99).

The jerky comes in several flavors, including mango, pineapple, mango and chili, and banana with cacao. Depending on the variety, it contains just one or two organic fruit ingredients, with no added sugar, artificial flavors, or preservatives. It's a convenient pantry pick for families who want a naturally sweet snack with a short ingredient list.

Lilly B's Organic Bean, Rice, and Cheese Burritos

lilly bs organic bean rice and cheese burritos

Price: $11.99

This eight-count pack of organic burritos costs $11.99 — which seems like a lot for what Redditor Skyfather87 called "Plain and boring, pretty flavorless and tiny."

At $1.50 per burrito, this less-than-tasty frozen food is a miss. Instead, get more for your money and try El Monterey Burritos 30-count variety pack for $19.99 ($0.67 each).

The El Monterey alternative offers two flavors, with 15 bean and cheese burritos and 15 beef and bean burritos. They're individually packaged and microwaveable, making them convenient to grab for lunch or a quick dinner. You can stock up on a more filling option without paying nearly as much per burrito.

Kirkland Signature Take and Bake Pizzas

kirkland signature take and bake pizzas

Price: $12.99

Costco shoppers couldn't believe their eyes when the retailer introduced take-and-bake pizzas. But the expectations didn't match the reality of this refrigerated meal. Reddit user rainmeterhub noted, "They are just okay…in most areas, you can get a real pie for that price." So save your money and your taste buds, and hit up your local pizzeria instead.

The appeal of a take-and-bake pizza is easy to understand. You can bring home a ready-to-prepare dinner without dealing with dough, sauce, toppings, or a lengthy cleanup. But at this price, shoppers reasonably expect a pizza that tastes better than an average grocery-store option. Before putting one in your cart, compare the price with a local pizzeria's offerings, especially if you can get a freshly prepared pie for a similar amount.

Orion Bungo Choco Mochi

orion bungo choco mochi

Price: $12.49

You aren't alone if this box grabs your attention. One shopper wrote on Reddit, "These look freaking affordable." So what did customers who did more than just look at this have to say? Buyer Aemont commented, "They're okay but not a very pronounced flavor, a bit disappointed by how not-chewy the mochi filling is."

Mochi is a Japanese rice cake traditionally made with glutinous rice, giving it its distinctive chewy texture. Chocolate-filled versions add a sweet twist to the familiar treat, making them an appealing option for anyone who enjoys trying international snacks. But texture is a big part of the experience, and shoppers expecting a satisfyingly chewy center may be disappointed if the filling doesn't deliver.

LesserEvil Space Balls

lesser evil space balls

Price: $6.79

Snazzy packaging is one of the only pluses shoppers point out about this snack. Redditor umbabyum commented, "They taste like worse cheese balls. Really not gonna get them again. Utz are better." If your local store doesn't have Utz cheese balls, a 40-bag box of Pirate's Booty is another affordable alternative ($14.99).

The individually packaged Pirate's Booty option can be especially useful for families that want easy-to-pack snacks. The 40-bag box gives you plenty of portions for school lunches, road trips, or keeping in the pantry for afternoon cravings. It's also a convenient way to avoid opening a large bag and worrying about finishing it before the contents lose their crunch.

While the upfront price is higher than the Space Balls, dividing the cost across 40 bags makes it easier to plan your snack budget.

Kirkland Signature Garlic Butter Shrimp

kirkland signature garlic butter shrimp

Price: $15.99

The food photography on the box makes this look like a gourmet find. And while some shoppers do enjoy the taste, others are disappointed. Redditor Mohican83 wrote, "I do not suggest, unless you like flavorless shrimp."

Make your own seafood meal and try Kirkland Signature's Farm-Raised Raw Shrimp ($15.69 for two pounds) instead.

If you prefer to control the seasoning and flavor of your seafood, the plain raw shrimp is a better option. The peeled and deveined Kirkland shrimp comes in a resealable two-pound bag, with approximately 31 to 40 shrimp per pound. Use it for homemade shrimp scampi, pasta, tacos, or stir-fry without paying extra for a prepared sauce you might not enjoy.

Mush Overnight Oats

mush overnight oats

Price: $12.99

Overnight oats are a popular product, and this eight-count variety pack looks promising. Shopper winkraine didn't exactly praise this pick, "It has a weird taste. You might as well make your own. Takes one minute and is much tastier."

At $12.99, you're paying about $1.62 per serving for a breakfast you can easily prepare at home for less. While the convenience of having individual portions ready to grab is appealing, the taste may not justify the price.

Making overnight oats yourself also gives you more control over the ingredients, sweetness, and toppings. Add some rolled oats, milk, yogurt, and fresh fruit to a jar, refrigerate overnight, and you'll have an easy breakfast waiting in the morning. If you're trying to stretch your grocery budget, this is one Costco purchase you can probably skip.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.
Compare car insurance rates in Ohio
See if lower rates are available
Currently Insured?
Multiple Cars?
Homeowner
Age
map pin icon
By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Inland Market Maryland Style Crab Dip

inland market maryland style crab dip

Price: $9.99

An artsy graphic on this crab dip makes it look like a must-have foodie find. Some customers rave about the taste, while others have nothing good to say. Costco Redditor gvlakers complained, "I thought it was disgusting. Zero flavor."

La Terra Fina's Spinach, Artichoke, and Parmesan ($8.73) or Smoked Gouda and Peppers ($9.69) spreads are top options if you're willing to give a non-seafood dip a chance.

Both alternatives offer a flavorful upgrade and are versatile enough to serve with crackers, sliced vegetables, or toasted bread. They're also easy additions to a party spread or casual snack board. Rather than gamble on a crab dip that may leave your taste buds disappointed, put your grocery dollars toward one of these crowd-pleasing alternatives.

Don Lee Farms Crispy Chicken Tacos

don lee farms crispy chicken tacos

Price: $13.99

The 2.13-pound pack of crispy shredded chicken tacos looks absolutely amazing. That said, it has mixed reviews from Costco's shoppers. Redditor GardenGnomeOfEden wasn't impressed: "They were so greasy that they got the no-go from my family."

Crush your taco craving and save money. Swap this so-so selection for Don Miguel Mini Chicken and Cheese Tacos ($12.99 for 3.15 pounds).

That's more than a pound of extra food for a better value, making it a smarter pick for families or anyone who likes to keep easy meals on hand. The mini tacos are also convenient for quick lunches, game-day snacks, or appetizers when you don't feel like cooking from scratch. Why spend more on a greasy disappointment when you can get more tacos for your grocery budget?

Amylu Sesame Ginger Chicken Crumbles

amylu sesame ginger chicken crumbles

Price: $15.49

Sesame ginger paired with protein-rich prepared chicken may seem like a delicious deal you can't pass up. Like other Costco buys, this one has fans and haters.

Reddit user GolfMikeTango wrote, "I might be an outlier, but I returned one of the two packs of these because I could not get past the texture, and the smell reminded me of dog food."

While the flavor combination sounds appealing, questionable texture and an unpleasant smell can make this an expensive gamble. Prepared chicken is supposed to save you time and make meal prep easier, but that's not much of a bargain if you end up tossing it. Before adding this one to your cart, consider whether the convenience is worth the risk of spending money on a meal your family may not enjoy.


Kirkland Signature Muffins

kirkland signature blueberries and cream muffins

Price: $6.99

The warehouse club's beloved mega-sized muffins got a makeover — and customers are not happy. The updated eight-count may look delish, but as Redditor CaitlynZ14 puts it, "Why would they ruin a good thing."

For longtime Costco shoppers, changing a familiar bakery favorite can be a tough, especially if the new version doesn't live up to expectations.

Muffins are an easy breakfast option, afternoon snack, or quick treat to share with the family. If the updated recipe or portion size leaves you disappointed, you may be better off spending your bakery budget elsewhere. After all, just because Costco gives a popular product a makeover doesn't mean it's worth your money.

Kirkland Signature Chicken Bakes

kirkland signature chicken bakes

Price: $13.59

Costco's shoppers adore the Food Court's chicken bakes ($3.99). What do they think about the pre-packaged frozen version? "These are terrible. I bought a box and could not even finish it," according to Reddit user GrumpyInTheM0rning.

That's disappointing for shoppers hoping to recreate the food court favorite at home without making a special trip to Costco. Frozen meals should make life easier, not leave you wishing you'd skipped the purchase. If the packaged version doesn't deliver the same satisfying taste and texture, it may not be worth stocking your freezer.

Save your grocery dollars for the fresh food court version instead of gambling on a frozen imitation that could fall flat.

Bottom line

Eduardo Barraza/Adobe exterior view of a costco wholesale store

Avoid wasting your money on food that only looks good. Choosing items based on appearance only is a common mistake you don't need to make. Instead, use shopper reviews, nutrition labels, and your own research to make an informed decision.

Even though the picks on our list won't give you the most bang for your buck, Costco still has plenty of delicious deals. With some smart shopping, you can stretch your budget further at this warehouse club store.

Stick to products your household enjoys, compare unit prices, and keep an eye out for familiar favorites that offer plenty of food for the money. The goal isn't to fill your cart with the most products. It's to get the most value out of every dollar you spend.

Financebuzz awards badge
2026 Award Winner Best Overall Cash Back Credit Card
  • Low spend threshold for its welcome offer
  • Cell phone protection benefit (subject to a $25 deductible)
  • Apply Now
  • Apply Now to take advantage of this offer and learn more about product features, terms and conditions.
  • Earn a $100 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months.
  • Earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases.
  • 0% intro APR for 12 months from account opening on purchases and qualifying balance transfers. 18.74%, 24.74%, or 28.74% variable APR thereafter; balance transfers made within 120 days qualify for the intro rate and fee of 3% then a BT fee of up to 5%, min: $5.
  • $0 annual fee.
  • No categories to track or remember and cash rewards don’t expire as long as your account remains open.
  • Find tickets to top sports and entertainment events, book travel, make dinner reservations and more with your complimentary 24/7 Visa Signature® Concierge.
  • Up to $600 of cell phone protection against damage or theft. Subject to a $25 deductible.
Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card
5.0
info

on Wells Fargo's secure website

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

$100 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months

Annual Fee

$0

+

Why we like it


Financebuzz logo

Thanks for subscribing!

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.