11 Worst Small SUVs to Buy if You Hate Spending Money on Maintenance

Small SUVs are in high demand right now, but consumers choosing the popular compact SUV segment, whether they are looking at a regular or a luxury model, should carefully consider their annual maintenance and repair costs.

Frequent maintenance issues could easily make these compact SUVs a nightmare for owners. Some compact SUV repairs are outrageously expensive, and frequent mechanic visits could even make it harder to save on car insurance.

According to RepairPal reports, annual repair costs for compact SUVs are $521, with luxury models costing $859. The following compact SUVs either surpass those totals, have staggering replacement costs, or are frequently hampered by maintenance issues.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Annual Repair Cost: $519

RepairPal reports that the Mitsubishi Outlander's annual repair costs are in line with those of the average compact SUV. But consumers should know that some of the Outlander's pricier repairs could easily drain their wallets.

Replacing this compact SUV's suspension shock or strut could cost up to $1,354, with its power steering control module costing as much as $1,995 to replace. Its rack and pinion replacement could cost as much as $2,140.

Annual Repair Cost: $520

The Jeep Cherokee's annual repair costs are almost exactly in line with its segment average, according to RepairPal.

However, owners have reported extensive, frequent issues with this compact SUV. These problems range from cracks in the Cherokee's exhaust manifold to ignition wire failure and engine oil leaks from valve covers, timing cover gaskets, and the oil pan. They have also reported the Cherokee facing emissions recalls due to catalytic converter failures.

Annual Repair Cost: $523

The Mazda Tribute's annual repair costs are average for its segment. However, Tribute owners have reported frequent issues with its engine misfiring and the vehicle stalling after a cold start.

Additionally, some of this small SUV's costly repairs could easily break the bank. Replacing the Tribute's control arm could cost as much as $1,336. A fuel tank replacement could set drivers back as much as $1,306.

Annual Repair Cost: $526

The Jeep Compass has annual repair costs that are typical for its vehicle segment, according to RepairPal. Sadly, owners have reported frequent issues with this compact SUV. They have reported problems with the engine failing to start, water leaks, unusual brake noise, and the engine overheating.

Annual Repair Cost: $548

Although the Nissan Juke's annual repair costs are only $27 more expensive than the average compact SUV's, some of its repairs are outrageously expensive.

Replacing the Juke's fuel pump could cost drivers up to $1,802. Replacing this compact SUV's head gasket is even more expensive, costing owners up to $3,233.

Annual Repair Cost: $600

According to RepairPal, the Ford Escape's annual repair costs are $79 more expensive than the average compact SUV's.

Ford Escape owners have reported alternator failure issues, causing the vehicle to lose power, inconsistencies with its heating and air conditioning system, and frequent ignition misfires.

Replacing this SUV's air conditioning proponents could cost owners up to $607, while replacing its starter to deal with those pesky ignition misfires could cost owners as much as $696.

Annual Repair Cost: $730

The Volkswagen Tiguan has annual repair costs that are $209 more expensive than those of the average compact SUV, according to RepairPal.

Consumers have reported frequent issues with carbon buildup in the Tiguan's TSI direct injection engine, which causes the vehicle to lose power.

Tiguan owners have also experienced "VW Subframe Clunk." A problem that results from stretched bolts in the vehicle's subframe. This causes the Tiguan to "clunk" while accelerating from a stop and could lead to problems with the vehicle's alignment.

Annual Repair Cost: $853

The Lincoln MKC's annual repair costs are right in line with its segment average, according to RepairPal.

However, owners have reported issues with the MKC's throttle body causing power issues, persistent infotainment screen freezing issues, and severe jerking while driving that led to the SUV's transmission needing to be replaced.

Plus, MKC owners in need of a fuel pump replacement could spend up to $1,238 fixing that issue.

Annual Repair Cost: $915

The BMW X1's annual repair costs eclipse its segment average by $56, according to RepairPal. But the cost of fixing issues with this luxury compact SUV's AC system easily obliterates that total.

Replacing the X1's AC condenser could cost as much as $1,332, while a new AC evaporator could have owners spending up to $2,800.

Annual Repair Cost: $1,034

According to RepairPal, the BMW X3's annual repair costs surpassed the luxury compact SUV segment average by a staggering $175.

The X3's most costly repair is an engine front cover gasket replacement that could drain up to $5,224 from owners' bank accounts. Replacing the X3's radiator is much less expensive, but could still cost owners a whopping $1,891.

Annual Repair Cost: $1,102

The Land Rover Range Rover Evoque's annual repair costs surpassed its segment average by a whopping $243, according to RepairPal,

Unsurprisingly, many of this luxury compact SUV's repair costs are outrageously expensive. Replacing its hybrid high-voltage battery costs up to $2,326. A CV joint replacement for the Evoque could cost owners as much as $1,492, while a new windshield wiper motor could set them back as much as $1,264.

Compact SUVs typically cost their owners around $521 per year in maintenance and repairs, which is significantly cheaper than the overall vehicle average of $652 a year, according to RepairPal.

But as the 11 vehicles on this list demonstrate, some of them could also be maintenance nightmares due to pesky, frequent issues and exorbitant replacement costs.

Drivers who are stuck with a compact SUV that's frequently hampered by maintenance problems could also have a hard time finding a cheaper auto insurance policy, costing them more money long-term.