11 Costco Items That Are Identical to Pottery Barn’s (For a Third of the Price)

Pottery Barn makes it easy to picture a home filled with soft textures, classic furniture, and finishing touches that pull everything together. Paying for that whole picture is another story, especially with holiday shopping and entertaining expenses coming up.

Fortunately, some Costco home finds echo the same decorating ideas for much less. Think sheer curtains, marble accent tables, decorative mirrors, and cozy throw blankets that match the furniture you already own. The materials and measurements aren't always identical, but comparing those details might help you decide where the savings are worth it. Here are the finds worth a closer look if you want to get more out of your Costco membership.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Price $39.99

Fresh curtains might be the easiest way to make the living room feel ready for company without replacing everything in it. Costco's Taylor & Moxie set includes four sheer panels with a light, textured appearance similar to Pottery Barn's Emery Linen Sheer Curtains. Each Costco panel measures 52 by 84 inches, compared with Pottery Barn's 50-by-84-inch option.

At $79 per panel (on sale from $99), four Pottery Barn curtains total $316, compared to $39.99 at Costco. The fabric differs slightly: Costco uses 95% polyester and 5% linen, while Pottery Barn's sheers are linen. Costco's machine-washable panels offer a practical alternative if the airy appearance matters more than the fiber content.

Price $99

A simple black frame goes with just about everything, which makes this mirror an easy update above an entryway table or a bedroom dresser. Costco's Parker Decorative Mirror has a slim iron frame with a black powder-coated finish and includes hanging hardware. It measures 23.5 by 35.5 inches and hangs vertically or horizontally.

Pottery Barn's Linden Rectangular Mirror in matte black costs $349 and measures 23 by 37 inches. Using the $99 Costco price, that leaves $250 for other updates around the house. The proportions are close, although Pottery Barn's frame is deeper, so they bring a similar clean look without being exact duplicates.

Price $23.99

Even a glass of iced tea feels a little more special in pretty glassware. Costco's Mesa set includes four clear, ribbed 20-ounce cups, each with a lid and reusable straw. Pottery Barn's Carousel collection offers a similar textured-glass look for $79 per set of four, compared with Costco's $23.99.

That is $55.01 less for the same number of drinking glasses, with accessories included. Choose Pottery Barn's clear highball style for the closest comparison, rather than its shorter cocktail glass. Costco's glasses are dishwasher-safe, but the lids and straws require hand-washing. Their taller shape and capacity also distinguish them from Pottery Barn's version.

Price $94.99

A new lamp might be all a tired end table needs before holiday guests arrive. Costco's Bellmore Table Lamp pairs a warm white, ribbed ceramic body with a concrete-gray base detail and an off-white fabric shade. Its neutral palette echoes Pottery Barn's $249 Miller Ceramic Tall Table Lamp, although the shapes and surface details differ.

Costco's lamp stands 30 inches tall, while the linked Pottery Barn model is approximately 25 inches. At $94.99, the Bellmore costs $154.01 less and includes a 9-watt LED bulb. Before placing it on a bedside table, check the 17-inch shade diameter to make sure there's room for your other essentials.

Price $124.99

If the room needs one decorative piece rather than several smaller accents, an ornate mirror might do the trick. Costco's Antique Gold Scroll Wall Mirror combines a narrow gold-colored frame with decorative scrollwork at the top. Pottery Barn's Fleur Mantel Arch Mirror in brass offers a similar traditional focal point for $399.

Costco's $124.99 price leaves a $274.01 difference, or about 69% savings. The Costco mirror measures 37.7 inches wide and 25.9 inches high, compared with Pottery Barn's 40-by-31.25-inch frame. Both use iron, although the outlines and ornaments differ. Measure above your console or mantel before deciding which proportions suit the space.

Price $1,299.99

Replacing a dining set before the holidays gets expensive quickly, especially when the chairs are sold separately. Costco's Westen includes an extendable table and six cross-back chairs with light gray upholstered seats for $1,299.99. The table extends from 62 to 80 inches using a self-storing leaf.

Pottery Barn's Seadrift Toscana table, extending from 60 to 84 inches, is $1,599 on sale from $1,999. Adding six $429 Layton upholstered chairs brings Pottery Barn's total to $4,173. Costco costs $2,873.01 less, but the chairs are noticeably different. The strongest resemblance is between the tables' rustic rectangular tops and substantial crossed bases, rather than the complete sets.

Price $129.99

Holiday dishes are fun until the total starts competing with the grocery budget. Costco's 24-piece Mikasa Tartan Red set includes eight dinner plates, eight salad plates, and eight bowls, giving you matching place settings for eight people. Its red plaid brings a similar festive feel to Pottery Barn's Stewart Plaid collection.

Eight of each corresponding Pottery Barn piece total $377, with two $69.50 dinner-plate sets, two $59.50 salad-plate sets, and two $59.50 bowl sets. Costco's listed $129.99 price is $247.01 lower. The materials differ, with bone china at Costco and stoneware at Pottery Barn. Mikasa's dishes are both microwave and dishwasher safe for everyday use throughout the season.

Price $119.99

A place to set your coffee doesn't have to become a major furniture purchase. Costco's Concord set pairs two white marble tops with slender matte black iron frames. The look echoes Pottery Barn's Delaney Round Marble Nesting End Tables in bronze, currently $399 on sale from $449.

At the $119.99 Costco price, the difference is $279.01 for two tables. The smaller footprint deserves attention, though, because Costco's marble tops are about 10 inches across, while Pottery Barn's measure 13 and 18 inches. Costco's tables stand 22.3 and 18.2 inches tall. They are great for compact seating areas, but offer less surface space than the Pottery Barn pair.

Price $29.99 (on sale from $39.99)

A soft white tree skirt gives colorful ornaments and wrapped gifts a simple backdrop without adding another pattern to the room. Costco's Mon Chateau Faux Fur Tree Skirt in ivory measures 60 inches across, matching Pottery Barn's $129 Faux Fur Alpaca Tree Skirt. Both are made from polyester rather than real animal fur, and both have machine-washing instructions.

At $29.99, down from $39.99, Costco's version saves $99.01. The fur texture differs slightly in the photos, but the shared size, pale color, and plush appearance make this a straightforward holiday comparison. It's designed for indoor use beneath your decorated Christmas tree.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price $24.99

A lantern near the entryway adds a little warmth when the evenings start getting dark earlier. Costco's LumiPur Iron Lantern includes a weatherproof LED candle, batteries, and a timer that runs six hours on and 18 hours off. Its black architectural frame offers a similar decorating idea to Pottery Barn's bronze Malta Outdoor Lantern.

Costco's version stands 23 inches tall and costs $24.99, while Pottery Barn's 17-inch small lantern is $69. That is $44.01 less before adding a candle to Pottery Barn's version. The heights, finishes, and shapes differ, though, and the lantern-only savings are about 64%. It's a value alternative rather than an exact match.

Price $29.99

A cozy throw is a small update that makes the couch more inviting as the weather gets cooler. Costco's Life Comfort Contour Faux Fur Throw measures 60 by 70 inches and costs $29.99. Pottery Barn's standard Faux Fur Ruched Throw measures 50 by 60 inches and costs $179, making Costco's larger blanket $149.01 less.

Both offer plush texture, but Costco's raised block pattern differs from Pottery Barn's gathered, wavy surface. The Life Comfort throw has a polyester front and reverse, with machine-washing and low-heat drying instructions. Choose it for the soft, layered look while keeping the material and texture differences in mind.

Getting a home you love doesn't have to mean buying everything from the same store. A few carefully chosen Costco pieces might give you the textures, colors, and classic shapes you like while leaving more room in your budget for everyday expenses.

Before buying, compare the exact size, finish, and quantity included. A four-panel curtain set is a different purchase from one curtain, just as a complete dining set is different from a table sold alone. Consider what you already own, too. To avoid wasting money, focus on pieces that fit your space and serve a purpose, rather than buying something simply because it costs less.