I used to head straight to Target for things like batteries, gift wrap, or a little extra storage. Five Below rarely crossed my mind until I found a $7 spinning organizer that does what I'd want a $20 one to do, and I started wondering what else I'd been paying more for out of habit.
Most items outside the candy aisle now have whole-dollar prices from $1 to $5, and higher-priced Five Beyond items are mixed into the regular aisles. With holiday shopping coming up, checking Five Below for things already on my list seems like a smart way to avoid wasting money. Here are 10 finds I wish I'd looked for there sooner.
Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.
Spinning Organizer
Price $7.00
There's always one bottle I have to move three other things to reach, which is what sold me on the idea of a two-tier spinning organizer for the bathroom counter. Five Below's clear version has two tiers and a base that turns all the way around, so the items at the back are easy to reach.
Target's clear Brightroom spinning vanity organizer costs $20 and has a similar raised design. At $7, the Five Below version saves $13. I'd keep taller bottles on the top tier and use the lower tier for shorter items like lip balm or small jars.
Metal Rolling Cart
Price $20.00
This three-tier cart would come in handy when a project takes over the kitchen table. If I'm wrapping gifts, I could keep tissue paper and tags up top, gift bags in the middle, and ribbon and tape on the bottom. When I need the table back, I could roll everything out of the way and pick up where I left off later. I'd use the same setup for sewing or craft supplies once the holidays are over.
The Five Below cart is just under 30 inches tall and about 18 inches wide. Target's $40 Brightroom cart is about the same width and a little taller and deeper. Going with Five Below would save me $20. Five Below lists an 11-pound limit per shelf, which is plenty for the supplies I'd put on it.
Snow Cool Tissue Sheets
Price $5.00
I always think I have enough tissue paper until I'm wrapping the last few gifts and find two crumpled sheets at the bottom of the bin. A 100-sheet pack is the kind of thing I'd buy once at the start of the holidays and keep with the gift bags for the rest of the year. It's also handy when a gift needs a little cushioning or when I want to make a plain bag look more festive.
Michaels' Celebrate It assorted tissue value pack also comes with 100 sheets and costs $11.99. That works out to about 12 cents a sheet, compared with five cents at Five Below.
Channel Throw
Price $7.00
A couch blanket in my house is fair game for whoever gets to it first, which is probably the best argument for buying a second one. This one measures 50 by 60 inches, so it's a practical size for pulling over your lap during a movie or draping over the arm of a chair. I like that the raised stripes give it a little texture, especially if it's going to live out in the open.
The Lux Decor ribbed fleece throw listed at Target is the same size and has a similar look. At its $16.99 sale price, it's still $9.99 more than the Five Below throw.
Stackable Mini Organizer
Price $5.00
This is where all the little things that disappear the second I set them down could finally live. Hair ties and clips could go in one drawer, spare buttons in another, and the tiny screwdriver for battery compartments could finally have a home. It would work just as well on a desk for paper clips, sticky notes, and the odds and ends that otherwise get pushed into a corner.
Office Depot's Sterilite three-drawer organizer costs $11.99 and is a little bigger. I'd pick the Five Below version for a shallow shelf or a crowded counter, where the smaller footprint is part of the appeal. It also saves $6.99.
Palmer's Cocoa Butter Formula
Price $1.00
I like a travel-size lotion that I could throw in my purse and forget about until I need it. This 1.7-fluid-ounce bottle of Palmer's Cocoa Butter Formula is the size I'd keep in a work bag or tuck into a toiletry kit for a weekend away. At a dollar, I could grab two and leave one wherever I always seem to need lotion.
Target lists the same-size Palmer's lotion for $1.79. A 79-cent difference probably wouldn't send me across town, but if I'm already at Five Below, I'd rather spend the dollar there. Two bottles would cost $2 at Five Below or $3.58 at Target.
Series-8 Fitness Dumbbell
Price $7.00
If five pounds is the weight you already reach for at home, this is an inexpensive way to add a second dumbbell. A pair of five-pound dumbbells is easy to tuck beside a chair or under a desk, and having them nearby makes it easier to squeeze in a few exercises when I have time. Buying the weights individually also gives me the option to start with one and come back for a second.
Target's All in Motion five-pound dumbbell costs $12. Both stores sell the weights individually, so two would cost $14 at Five Below or $24 at Target. That's $10 I'd keep in my pocket.
Xtreme Power AAA Alkaline Batteries
Price $5.00
The time I usually remember to buy batteries is the moment the remote stops working. An eight-pack makes more sense for me than buying a couple at a time, especially around the holidays when a decoration or a gift might need batteries, too. I'd check what my device takes first because AAA and AA packs look close enough when I'm shopping in a hurry.
Target's eight-pack of Duracell Coppertop AAA alkaline batteries is $8.79. Five Below's Xtreme Power pack works out to about 63 cents per battery, compared with about $1.10 each at Target. That's $3.79 less for the pack.
USB-C To USB-C Cable
Price $7.00
The charging cable I always want is the one that reaches the couch without making me sit on the very end of it. Five Below's six-foot USB-C cable gives you more room to reach an outlet behind the couch or beside a favorite chair. I'd check that both my device and wall adapter take USB-C before buying it, especially if I'm replacing a cord I've had for years.
Target's six-foot Heyday cable costs $14.99 and has a braided exterior and a 240-watt rating. For a spare phone cable where my main concern is getting six feet of reach, I'd pocket the $7.99 difference.
Get a protection plan on all your appliances
Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.
Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.
For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.
Kraft Gift Bags
Price $5.00
Plain kraft gift bags are something I'd rather have in the closet than buy on the way to a birthday party. A little ribbon or colored tissue makes them feel festive, and the same pack works for holiday or birthday gifts. I'd keep a few folded flat with the rest of my wrapping supplies, for those unexpected moments when you need a small bag.
The Five Below five-pack comes out to $1 a bag. Target's medium Spritz kraft bag costs $2 on its own, so buying five of those would cost $10. Check the bag dimensions if you're wrapping anything bulky.
Bottom line
The rolling cart and spinning organizer are the first two things I'd look for. Both give a practical reason to switch, and together they cost $27 at Five Below compared with $60 for the Target picks.
If you're looking to stretch your retirement dollars further, I'd keep a short list of things you're about to run out of and check it when you're already near a Five Below. I'd grab the batteries or tissue paper while I'm there and save myself the last-minute trip when the remote dies or I'm halfway through wrapping a gift. I'd jot down the pack size, too, so I'm comparing the same quantity.
on Wells Fargo's secure website Intro Offer
$100 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months
Annual Fee $0 Why we like it
If you love earning cash rewards but prefer to avoid the hassle of tracking spending categories, the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card could be a good option for you. Card members can earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases.
This card also offers a 0% intro APR on qualifying balance transfers and purchases for 12 months from account opening, then 18.74%, 24.74%, or 28.74% Variable. Those looking for straightforward rewards and an introductory APR will likely find value in this card.
FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment.
Our partners do not influence how we rate products.
Subscribe Today
Learn how to make an extra $200
Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.
Add Us On Google