10 Sam's Club Member's Mark Dupes That Are as Good as the Real Deal (For Way Less)

Buying the same brands out of habit is easy, but paying extra for them every shopping trip is less appealing. If you're hoping to keep more of your money, comparing Member's Mark essentials with familiar national brands is a practical place to start.

The best swaps offer more than a bigger package. Similar materials, ingredients, and useful features help explain why these alternatives deserve a closer look.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price $20.93

Paper towels don't need a familiar logo to earn their spot beside the kitchen sink. Member's Mark includes 15 rolls with 150 sheets each, totaling 1,031.25 square feet. That works out to about $2.03 per 100 square feet.

The Bounty Select-A-Size pack costs $25.68 for 12 rolls with 110 sheets each, or 614 square feet. That's approximately $4.18 per 100 square feet. Both offer two-ply construction and smaller tear-off sections for everyday kitchen spills and messes. Member's Mark also has a 4.9-star rating at Sam's Club. The savings are substantial, provided you're happy with how many sheets each cleanup takes.

Price $24.76

Saving money on toilet paper shouldn't mean giving up comfort. Member's Mark offers 45 rolls with 235 sheets each, totaling 1,254 square feet. You're paying about $1.97 per 100 square feet.

Charmin Ultra Soft costs $29.38 for 32 rolls with 215 sheets each and 748 square feet overall, or approximately $3.93 per 100 square feet. Both products are two-ply and labeled septic-safe.

Member's Mark emphasizes softness, strength, and absorbency, while Charmin adds its distinctive wavy tear edges. Your preference for toilet paper texture is personal, but the store brand offers considerably more paper for less money upfront, making it worth testing.

Price $19.98

Spending more on something headed straight for the trash deserves a second look. Member's Mark's box contains 200 scented, 13-gallon bags for approximately 10 cents each. At Walmart, the Glad ForceFlex Fresh Clean package costs $17.27 for 110 bags, or about 15.7 cents apiece.

Both have drawstring closures, flexible construction, and scent features. Member's Mark also lists leak-protection seals and a drawstring designed to grip the trash can. Those are useful similarities beyond the price difference. The box costs slightly more upfront but includes 90 additional bags. Test the fit in your kitchen can before deciding the switch is a keeper.

Price $15.98

The bigger detergent bottle isn't always the better bargain, so compare labeled loads alongside ounces. Member's Mark's 196-ounce container covers 127 medium loads, putting the cost at approximately 12.6 cents per load.

Tide Original costs $24.98 for 170 ounces and 152 labeled loads, or about 16.4 cents per load. Member's Mark advertises stain removal and a fresh scent, and both listings currently carry 4.7-star ratings.

One Sam's Club reviewer who normally bought Tide reported good cleaning results after switching, although they found the fragrance strong. That makes scent preference worth considering along with the savings, especially before buying another large jug.

Price $8.98

Holiday cooking tends to leave plenty of dishes behind, making dish soap a sensible place to compare costs. Member's Mark's 100-ounce bottle works out to about nine cents per fluid ounce. At Walmart, Dawn Platinum Fresh Rain refill costs $9.94 for 68 ounces, or approximately 14.6 cents per fluid ounce.

Both products target grease during handwashing, and their larger containers are convenient for refilling a smaller bottle beside the sink. Member's Mark also advertises removal of stuck-on food. The formulas aren't established as identical, so pay attention to how much you use. A lower ounce price matters less if you repeatedly need extra squirts.

Price $32.98

Your morning coffee is probably one routine you'd rather keep, no matter what. Switching the box you buy might be easier than changing the habit. Member's Mark Breakfast Blend includes 100 pods for approximately 33 cents each.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Breakfast Blend costs $35.98 for 80 pods at the displayed sale price, or about 45 cents each. Both are light-roast breakfast blends, making this a closer comparison than matching a mild coffee with a dark roast. Member's Mark lists Arabica coffee as its ingredient, and shopper reviews describe a smooth cup. Fans of stronger coffee might prefer something bolder, regardless of the savings.

Price $23.98

Member's Mark extra virgin olive oil costs about 23.7 cents per fluid ounce in its 101-ounce bottle. Bertolli's 50.7-ounce bottle costs $14.98, or approximately 29.5 cents per fluid ounce.

Both ingredient lists identify extra virgin olive oil, making this a comparison within the same oil category. Member's Mark describes its oil as cold-pressed and suitable for roasting, sautéing, and other everyday cooking.

Bertolli offers a smaller bottle that requires less money upfront. For someone regularly preparing vegetables, soups, and homemade meals, the larger jug may fit the routine. Occasional cooks should consider whether they need that much before buying it.

Price $13.98

A bowl of cashews is an easy addition to a holiday gathering, but familiar branding adds to the snack bill. Member's Mark's 33-ounce jar costs approximately 42.4 cents per ounce. Planters Deluxe Lightly Salted Whole Cashews at Walmart costs $9.97 for 18.25 ounces, or about 54.6 cents per ounce.

This pairing compares whole cashews with whole cashews, rather than a cheaper assortment of broken pieces. Both products use peanut oil and sea salt, and both have resealable packaging. That gives shoppers some concrete similarities to weigh alongside taste. Member's Mark requires a larger purchase, so consider how quickly your household finishes a jar.

Price $13.97

This comparison starts with the label rather than a shopper's opinion. Member's Mark contains 200 milligrams of ibuprofen per tablet, matching the active ingredient and strength in the Advil tablets.

The Member's Mark package includes two 600-count bottles, totaling 1,200 tablets, for approximately 1.2 cents each. Walmart's 300-count Advil bottle costs $23.48, or about 7.8 cents per tablet. That's a large unit-price difference, although inactive ingredients and coatings may differ.

The quantity is also substantial for a smaller household. Check expiration dates and buy only what you reasonably expect to use. Follow label directions, including warnings, regardless of the brand.

Price $17.68

Pet supplies are another recurring expense where a store-brand option deserves consideration. Member's Mark includes 120 pads measuring 23 by 24 inches for approximately 14.7 cents each. The Four Paws Wee-Wee Superior Performance package at Chewy costs $42.99 for 100 pads measuring 22 by 23 inches, or about 43 cents each.

Both list leak-proof protection and a built-in attractant. Member's Mark uses five layers, while Four Paws advertises a six-layer system and a rapid-drying surface. Those differences matter because a cheaper pad isn't always equally absorbent. Still, Member's Mark offers a slightly larger surface and a substantially lower purchase price for everyday use.

You don't have to replace every familiar brand to reduce your shopping bill. Start with one item you use regularly, then compare its performance with your usual purchase.

To avoid wasting money, resist buying several bulk packages before testing the first. Try one roll, run a few loads, or brew several cups before deciding. Keep a quick note of the price and how long the package lasts. The most useful bargain is one you'd happily buy again.