14 Best Costco Fall Foods and Drinks You Can't Skip This October

Costco's fall lineup does not linger. The warehouse chain typically starts stocking its seasonal bakery case in late August or early September, and by early December, the most popular items are already gone. That short window is exactly why shoppers who wait until Halloween to start their fall Costco run often come home empty-handed on the items they wanted most.

This October's standout lineup spans the whole store: a legendary bakery pumpkin pie that reportedly sells millions of units a year, a broccoli cheddar soup built for a cold afternoon, and a limited-edition holiday coffee blend that is unlikely to return to shelves once it is gone. Between the bakery case, the snack aisle, and the beverage cooler, there is a genuinely wide range of fall flavors to stock up on this month.

For more ways to get the most out of your membership, check out these great Costco hacks that regular shoppers swear by.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Price: $7.45

This 58-ounce pumpkin pie has been a Costco bakery fixture since 1987, and it remains one of the retailer's most talked-about fall items every single year. Food outlets have already reported spotting it on shelves as early as late August, with some locations already running low by mid-September.

Costco reportedly moves millions of these pies between September and Thanksgiving, and shoppers who wait until November to grab one regularly report empty bakery cases. Through Same-Day Delivery, this pie runs $7.45, though it is famously priced closer to $5.99 in-warehouse, which is part of why it disappears so quickly. Either way, it remains one of the better dessert values in the entire store for a pie that easily feeds a crowd.

Price: $9.94

These bite-sized apple strudels come 12 to a box and are currently one of the better-selling items in Costco's fall bakery lineup, according to Same-Day Delivery listings. Each bite wraps warm apple filling in a flaky pastry shell with a caramel finish, giving you the flavor of a full apple strudel without cutting a single slice.

At under a dollar a bite, they are one of the more affordable ways to bring fall bakery flavor to a lunchbox or an after-dinner treat without committing to a whole pie. They also travel well, which makes them a solid pick for a fall potluck or a school event where a full dessert would be impractical to serve.

Price: $12.43

Costco's grocery aisle carries this Panera-branded broccoli cheddar soup in a 2-count, 24-ounce pack, bringing a restaurant-familiar comfort food home for less than a single bowl typically costs at the cafe itself. It is a best seller on Costco's Same-Day Delivery platform, which tracks how often the soup shows up in shoppers' fall grocery hauls.

Two 24-ounce tubs go a long way for a family dinner or a week of easy lunches once the weather turns cold, and reheating takes just a few minutes on the stove or in the microwave. It is the kind of item worth grabbing early in a Costco trip before the refrigerated section empties for the season.

Price: $13.55

This 50-count box of classic milk chocolate hot cocoa mix is one of the highest-rated items in this entire lineup, holding a 4.8-star average across more than 4,100 Costco Same-Day Delivery reviews. Each packet makes a single warm mug, which makes portioning simple for a household with kids or a steady stream of weekend guests.

At roughly 27 cents a packet, it works out to a fraction of what a single cup costs at a coffee shop, and the shelf-stable packets keep well in a pantry for the entire cold season. It pairs naturally with the caramel apple strudel bites above for an easy fall afternoon snack.

Price: $14.92

This organic ravioli pairs roasted butternut squash with caramelized onions inside a delicate pasta shell, making it one of the more elevated cozy-dinner picks in Costco's fall lineup. It is a Same-Day Delivery bestseller, and the pouch makes enough for a full family dinner with a simple butter-sage sauce or just a drizzle of olive oil.

Costco sells it in a 2-count, 16-ounce pack, so there is enough to split between two smaller dinners or serve a crowd at once. Because it leans on real butternut squash rather than a canned filling, it captures the same fall flavor as a homemade squash ravioli without the hour of prep work that dish usually takes.

Price: $16.16

For shoppers who lean apple over pumpkin, this lattice-topped apple pie is the fall bakery case's other major draw, and it is sized to match the same crowd-feeding scale as its pumpkin counterpart. The visible woven crust sets it apart from a standard covered pie, and it holds up well for a day or two once it is home.

It costs more than twice as much as the pumpkin pie on Same-Day Delivery, largely because of the more labor-intensive lattice crust, but it remains a strong value next to a comparable bakery pie from a grocery store chain. Warming a slice for a few seconds before serving brings out the cinnamon-apple filling best.

Price: $16.16

This 33.8-ounce bottle of organic maple syrup is a Same-Day Delivery best seller, and it rounds out the pumpkin-and-apple bakery lineup with the third flavor fall shoppers reach for most. It is real maple syrup rather than a corn-syrup blend, which matters once pancakes and waffles become a more regular weekend breakfast.

At roughly 48 cents an ounce, it undercuts most grocery store organic maple syrup by a wide margin, especially once a smaller bottle runs out mid-season. The large size also means it doubles as a baking ingredient for fall recipes that call for real maple rather than imitation syrup.

Price: $17.40

This is not labeled as cider, but the 12-pack of individual 10-ounce Martinelli's bottles fills the same role at a fall gathering, especially warmed on the stove with a cinnamon stick or two. It is a familiar name-brand pick that both kids and adults recognize, which makes it an easy add for a Halloween party or a Thanksgiving table.

The individual bottles also mean no pouring or spills at a party, since each guest gets a sealed single serving. Costco's warehouse locations sometimes carry an actual fresh-pressed cider in the produce section during fall, but availability varies heavily by store and week, so this shelf-stable option is the more dependable pick if you are shopping online.

Price: $19.02

This 60-count box of mini Frito-Lay snack bags is built for the exact stretch between now and Halloween night, whether that means trick-or-treaters at the door or a stocked pantry for after-school snacking. The individually wrapped 0.5-ounce bags keep everything portioned and easy to grab without opening a full-size bag.

At roughly 32 cents per bag, it is a solid value next to buying the same variety in smaller multi-packs from a regular grocery store. Because it is explicitly a Halloween-branded item rather than a year-round snack mix, it is also one of the more likely items on this list to sell through and disappear once the holiday passes.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price: $19.89

These candy-coated pecans wrap a classic Southern praline glaze around whole pecan halves, giving them a crunchy, sweet finish that works as a snack on its own or a topping for fall desserts. The 2.5-pound bag is a Costco Same-Day Delivery bestseller, which tracks with how often praline pecans show up on fall charcuterie boards and holiday cookie plates.

At roughly $7.96 a pound, it undercuts most specialty nut shops that sell praline pecans in small gift bags for two or three times that price per pound. The resealable bag also keeps them fresh for weeks, so a single bag is likely to stretch across multiple gatherings without going stale.

Price: $20.64

Fever-Tree's ginger beer is a bartending staple, and a 12-pack of the 9.3-ounce bottles is exactly the kind of mixer that turns a fall gathering into a build-your-own mocktail bar. Paired with apple cider, cranberry juice, or just a squeeze of lime, it makes a spiced, non-alcoholic drink that still feels festive.

It works just as well as a mixer for guests who are drinking, so one case covers both the mocktail table and the cocktail one without buying two separate mixers. The individual bottle size also means it stays carbonated through the whole party instead of going flat in a larger bottle.

Price: $5.34 per pound

This beef chili is sold by weight rather than a fixed price, averaging around $21.41 for roughly 4 pounds at $5.34 a pound, which makes it one of the better per-serving values in this entire lineup. It is the kind of ready-made comfort food that turns a cold October evening into a five-minute dinner instead of an hour at the stove.

Because it is sold in bulk rather than a single can, it is built for a family dinner with leftovers rather than a single bowl, and it freezes well for portioning out across a few colder weeks ahead. Topped with shredded cheese, sour cream, or a handful of tortilla chips, it turns into a full meal in minutes.

Price: $27.36

This whole pumpkin cheesecake comes topped with whipped cream and is the dressier, richer counterpart to the classic pumpkin pie in Costco's fall bakery lineup. It is one of the pricier items on this list, but a whole cheesecake this size would easily run more at a dedicated bakery or a sit-down restaurant dessert menu.

Because it shares bakery case space with the pumpkin pie, it tends to sell through on a similar timeline, especially as Thanksgiving approaches and shoppers start planning holiday desserts. Anyone who wants both the pie and the cheesecake for a gathering should plan to grab both on the same trip rather than counting on a restock later in the season.

Price: $44.77

This 72-count box of Starbucks Holiday Blend K-Cups is currently marked down to $44.77 from its regular $53.77 price on Same-Day Delivery, a 17% discount. As a limited-edition medium roast, it is not sold on shelves year-round, and it holds a 4.3-star rating across 283 reviews from shoppers who have already stocked up.

At 72 pods, a single box covers a household's morning coffee for weeks, which makes the current markdown a genuinely good time to buy rather than wait. Once this seasonal blend sells through for the year, it typically does not return to shelves until the following fall, so this is one of the more time-sensitive items on the whole list.

Costco's fall food and drink selection rewards shoppers who move early rather than waiting for the last minute. The bakery case in particular tends to sell out fast once October turns into November, and a handful of these items, like the seasonal coffee blend and the Halloween snack mix, are not restocked once they are gone.

Grabbing favorites on sight rather than planning to circle back later is generally the safer bet, since Costco's seasonal assortment varies by location and may shift week to week. Building out a fall grocery list from a mix of the bakery case, the pantry aisle, and the beverage cooler also tends to stretch a single trip further than chasing one or two specific items.

For more ways to keep your everyday budget in shape, make sure to bring your best cash back credit cards when you shop.