Williams Sonoma built its reputation on beautiful kitchenware, but beauty comes at a price. A single glass oil dispenser there could cost more than a whole cart of items at Dollar Tree.
That gap got us curious. Could the dollar store's glassware, butter dishes, and serving pieces hold their own against the high-end originals, at least in looks? Some of these pairs land strikingly close. For more ways to cope with increasing bills, check out these smart ways to save money shopping.
Here are 12 items to grab at Dollar Tree instead of Williams Sonoma.
Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.
Glass Bottle for Storing Oil and Vinegar
Price: $1.50
Anyone who keeps olive oil or vinegar by the stove would know this shape on sight: an 8-ounce glass bottle with a metal pour spout. One buyer said the little plastic cap keeps flies out, though the oil needs to be held so fingers keep the spout in the bottle.
Williams Sonoma's Glass Olive Oil Dispenser starts at $22.95, so this one saves you $21.45. That one is mouth-blown with a stainless-steel spout, a sturdier build than the dollar store version.
Glass Sugar Pourer With Metal Lid
Price: $1.50
This retro-shaped glass shaker works for sugar, though one shopper fills hers with parmesan instead. Another called it great and pretty and solid, adding that it feels well-made for the price.
Williams Sonoma's Breakfast Powdered Sugar Shaker costs $24.95, so this one saves you $23.45. It is a similar style rather than an identical piece, but the job it does lines up.
Lattice Pattern Glass Jar With Rose Gold Metal Lid
Price: $1.50
The rose gold lid gives this jar some shine on a counter, whether it holds spices or leftover candle wax for a craft project. One buyer used it for refrigerator pickling and found it leaks when tilted.
Williams Sonoma's Hold Everything Stackable Glass Canister costs $44.95, so this one saves you $43.45. The smallest canister in that line holds 5.5 cups, so sizes likely differ.
Diamond Lid Glass Bottle
Price: $1.25
A decorative diamond-cut stopper dresses up a vanity for next to nothing. One shopper grabbed a couple of colors after spotting them, while another said the stopper slides back up and eventually falls off.
Williams Sonoma's White and Gold Ginger Jar starts at $250, so this one saves you $248.75. That one is ceramic rather than glass, but it plays the same lidded-vessel role on a shelf.
Cooking Concepts Wire Napkin Holder
Price: $1.25
A wire napkin holder keeps a stack tidy on the table without eating up room. One reviewer admitted it is a little too lightweight and works best weighed down, while another called it well built especially for the price.
Williams Sonoma's Pantry Napkin Rings, a set of six, costs $38.70. Keep in mind this is a caddy for a stack rather than individual rings, so the formats differ.
Cooking Concepts Nickel Colored Wire Paper Towel Holder
Price: $1.25
This countertop holder keeps a roll upright and within reach of the sink. One buyer called it strong, steady, and durable when seated into a craft base, while another warned it could bend under heavier use.
Williams Sonoma's Hammered Copper Paper Towel Holder starts at $89.95, so this one saves you $88.70. That one is a premium copper piece, a different league in materials from this simple wire design.
Melamine Kitchen Spoon Rest
Price: $1.25
A spoon rest saves the counter from drips while a sauce simmers, and this melamine version comes in assorted colors. It measures 9.25 by 3.625 inches, plenty of room for a stirring spoon.
Williams Sonoma's Honeycomb Porcelain Spoon Rest costs $39.95, so this one saves you $38.70. Porcelain stands up to heat and scrubbing better than melamine over time, so there is a durability trade-off.
Cooking Concepts White Melamine Butter Dish
Price: $1.25
Soft butter on the counter is a small kitchen luxury, and this white melamine dish measures 7.375 by 3.25 by 1.875 inches, enough for a standard stick. No one has reviewed it yet, but the clean white look reads like pricier porcelain.
Williams Sonoma's Open Kitchen Butter Dish costs $79.95, so this one saves you $78.70. That one is porcelain and sells at full price year-round, while this dish is a closeout bonus buy.
Striped Round Woven Basket
Price: $3
A woven basket lined with a cloth napkin makes dinner rolls or chips look like they came from a bakery case. Dollar Tree sells this one individually, and the listing says it is made in the USA.
Williams Sonoma's Rattan Bread Basket runs $26.99 on sale, so this one saves you $23.99. Dollar Tree does not list dimensions for its basket, so the sizes may not line up.
Get a protection plan on all your appliances
Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.
Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.
For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.
Home Decor Woven Oval Basket
Price: $3
This oval basket does the same job as its round sibling but suits a longer loaf or a stack of napkins and silverware on a buffet table. The listing leaves out the material and exact dimensions.
Williams Sonoma's Ceramic Woven Bread Basket costs $79.95. That one is ceramic with a woven look, so it is a style match more than an identical piece.
Rectangular Beveled Mirror
Price: $1.50
A small beveled mirror works as a tray base for perfume bottles or as an accent leaned against a shelf. One shopper said, "I love these mirrors I use them as stand alone mirrors or to decorate with by adding items to it," while another said they are hard to find in stock.
Williams Sonoma's Antique Mirrored Tray costs $169. That is a decorative tray rather than a flat mirror, the closest mirrored piece in the lineup.
Glass Trinket Box
Price: $5
A glass trinket box is the kind of catch-all that holds rings, earrings, or a few keepsakes on a dresser. One reviewer called it a well made trinket box, and another said it worked perfectly for what she needed.
Williams Sonoma's Decorative Trays & Boxes collection starts at $142.99. That listing covers a range of premium boxes rather than one identical match.
Bottom line
Dollar store glassware and accents could look close to their pricey counterparts, especially pieces that just sit pretty on a shelf. The trade-offs show up in durability, so think about how hard a piece has to work before you buy. For more, check out these best cash back credit cards.
on Wells Fargo's secure website Intro Offer
$100 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months
Annual Fee $0 Why we like it
If you love earning cash rewards but prefer to avoid the hassle of tracking spending categories, the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card could be a good option for you. Card members can earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases.
This card also offers a 0% intro APR on qualifying balance transfers and purchases for 12 months from account opening, then 18.74%, 24.74%, or 28.74% Variable. Those looking for straightforward rewards and an introductory APR will likely find value in this card.
FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment.
Our partners do not influence how we rate products.
Subscribe Today
Learn how to make an extra $200
Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.
Add Us On Google