11 Sam's Club Bulk Items That Seem Like Deals (But Really Aren't)

Wholesale retail chains like Sam's Club are great places to score household items and food products at reasonable rates, effectively helping you combat inflation. Though you may be looking to get the most out of your Sam's Club Membership, some items just aren't worth grabbing in bulk, no matter the price or quality.

Skip these items during your next shopping trip to Sam's Club.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price: Varies

Unless you are excellent at meal planning regularly or have a large family, buying produce in bulk isn't always the best idea. Plans can pop up unexpectedly, and some of that produce will probably go to waste.

With all that in mind, it makes sense that produce is one of the most returned items at Sam's Club.

Even when the per-pound price looks attractive, a bargain disappears quickly if you don't eat everything before it spoils. Smaller produce purchases from a regular grocery store can give you more flexibility to buy only what you need for the week. That can be especially helpful with berries, leafy greens, avocados, and other items that don't have a particularly long shelf life.

Buying smaller quantities also makes it easier to adjust your shopping list around changing plans. You may pay a little more per pound, but avoiding food waste can save more money overall. The best grocery deal isn't necessarily the lowest unit price. It's the option that gives you the most usable food for your money.

Price: $5.46/lb

Sam's Club is known for offering bulk groceries at prices that can beat traditional supermarkets, but not every item is necessarily the best deal. Ground beef is one example where it can pay to compare prices before adding it to your cart.

Sam's Club's 90/10 ground beef roll costs about $5.46 per pound, while Costco's comparable 90/10 ground beef can cost less at around $4.99 per pound. That difference may seem small, but it adds up when you're buying several pounds at a time or stocking your freezer.

Ground beef is a grocery staple for everything from burgers and tacos to meatloaf and casseroles, so finding a lower price can make a noticeable difference in your grocery budget. Prices can vary by location, but shoppers who have both warehouse clubs nearby may want to check Costco before buying their ground beef at Sam's Club.

Price: $16.96

If you're on your way to a vacation that will require more sunscreen than usual, or are committed to a life of daily sunscreen use, then stocking up at Sam's Club can seem like a great option.

The problem is that most sunscreen comes in packages of two or three with the same expiration date, making it difficult for one person to use them all up before then.

A smaller package from another retailer may make more sense if you don't go through sunscreen quickly. Walmart, for example, carries Banana Boat Sport Ultra SPF 50 in smaller configurations, giving shoppers more flexibility instead of committing to multiple cans at once.

Sunscreen isn't something you want to keep around indefinitely, either. The FDA requires sunscreen to maintain its original strength for at least three years, and sunscreen should be discarded after its expiration date. That means a three-pack isn't necessarily a bad purchase for a family, frequent traveler, or anyone who uses sunscreen generously. But for occasional use, buying less at a time can reduce the chance of having an unused bottle sitting around for too long.

Price: $12.98

Buying soup in bulk can seem like an easy way to save money, especially when you're shopping at a warehouse club like Sam's Club. But a multi-pack isn't automatically a better deal, so it pays to compare the per-can price before stocking up.

Campbell's Condensed Chicken Noodle Soup is a pantry staple that can come in handy for quick lunches, easy dinners, or recipes that call for canned soup. While Sam's Club offers the convenience of buying multiple cans at once, local grocery stores regularly run sales on canned goods, including Campbell's soups. Those promotions can bring the cost per can below what you'd pay at Sam's Club.

If your grocery store has Campbell's soup on sale, you may be better off buying only what you need there rather than committing to a larger pack. Checking weekly sales and comparing the price per can can help you get more soup for your grocery budget.

Price: $22.98

While five cents per ounce sounds incredible, getting through this much grain in a reasonable amount of time is almost impossible without a large family or a rice-heavy diet.

A smaller bag can be the better choice if rice isn't a major part of your weekly meals. Walmart's Great Value Jasmine Rice comes in a 5-pound bag for $7.23, giving occasional rice eaters a much smaller upfront purchase. The larger Sam's Club bag can offer a lower unit price, but saving a few cents per ounce doesn't help much if the bulk package takes up valuable pantry space or sits untouched for months.

Rice is shelf-stable, so this isn't a product that will necessarily spoil quickly. USDA guidance lists rice and dried pasta among shelf-stable foods, but proper storage still matters. A smaller bag also lets you replenish your supply as needed instead of tying up nearly $23 in one pantry staple.

Price: $8.14

While the price of five cents per ounce sounds low, loyal customers of this product are displeased with the decreasing quality of this aloe vera hand soap.

One customer laments: "The last [two] bottles I bought, they are definitely watering down the product now," while another admits, "The quality isn't that good."

Those complaints make it worth considering another hand soap before committing to a large refill. Walmart, for example, offers Equate Aloe Vera Liquid Hand Soap with Moisturizers in a 50-fluid-ounce size for as little as $2.97, giving shoppers a lower upfront cost and an opportunity to try a different formula without buying a huge refill.

Softsoap also offers a 50-fluid-ounce aloe vera refill for $5.97, providing another familiar-brand alternative. If you're unhappy with the quality of a bulk product, the cheapest option isn't necessarily the best value. A smaller bottle that you actually enjoy using can be a smarter purchase than a large refill that leaves you disappointed.

Price: $7.48

Though you may want to save money on groceries, and 19 cents per ounce seems like a great deal for bulk seasoned salt, you must be committed to using a spice this size frequently if you want to finish it before it is no longer potent.

Sam's Club's 40-ounce container is an excellent unit price, but that doesn't mean it is the best purchase for every kitchen. Walmart sells Lawry's in an 8-ounce bottle for $3.28, giving shoppers a much smaller option for recipes that only call for a little seasoning at a time. The smaller bottle also takes up less cabinet space and makes it easier to keep your spice collection manageable.

You don't necessarily have to abandon Lawry's to avoid the bulk purchase. You can simply buy the size that matches how frequently you cook with it. For occasional use, paying more per ounce may be worthwhile if it prevents you from accumulating a pantry full of oversized containers.

Price: Varying

Gift card multipacks can look like an easy way to save, especially when Sam's Club offers discounts on cards from popular retailers and restaurants. If you already know you'll use the gift cards, buying them in a multipack can make sense and help you get more value from money you were planning to spend anyway.

The problem comes when you buy gift cards simply because they appear to be a deal. Unlike groceries or household essentials, gift cards can sit unused for months. You may forget about them, lose track of the balance, or buy cards for stores you don't visit as often as you expected. Tying up money in gift cards you won't use soon can also make it harder to manage your budget.

Before buying a multipack, consider who will use each card and when. If you don't have a specific plan for the gift cards, skipping the bulk deal could be the better financial move.

Price: $5.98

As handy and versatile as white vinegar can be, you absolutely don't need two gallons of this stuff lying around, especially for as little as is normally used, not to mention the storage space that something this size would require.

Walmart offers Great Value Distilled White Vinegar in a 128-fluid-ounce, 1-gallon bottle for $3.94, giving shoppers a way to buy the same basic pantry and cleaning staple in a smaller quantity for less upfront. The Walmart option is also rated 4.8 out of 5 stars from more than 40,000 ratings, so shoppers aren't giving up an established store-brand option to avoid the larger Sam's Club container.

Vinegar is useful for cooking, cleaning, deodorizing, and other household jobs, but two gallons is still a lot for many households. If you don't use it frequently, the smaller bottle can free up storage space while keeping more cash in your budget.

Price: $24.98

Buying batteries in bulk seems like a good idea, but batteries can overheat, freeze, or leak contaminants if they're not stored properly or if they expire.

Instead, buy smaller packs when needed to ensure you get more fresh batteries with a better shelf life.

The good news is that Energizer MAX AA batteries actually have a long storage life, so this isn't necessarily a product that will go bad quickly. Energizer lists up to 15 years of storage life for its MAX AA batteries. That makes the 48-pack less risky than some other bulk purchases, particularly for households with lots of battery-powered devices.

Still, smaller packs can make more financial sense if you don't use AA batteries often. Walmart sells a 16-pack for $13.99, letting you spend less upfront and restock when needed. At Sam's Club's $24.98 price, you're buying three times as many batteries for less than twice the price of the smaller Walmart pack. The bulk package wins on cost per battery, but the smaller purchase may be better for shoppers who simply don't need 48 batteries at once.

Price: Varies

While lotion is a fantastic bulk purchase if you're stocking up for multiple people or purchasing it as a gift, buying giant vats of popular lotions like CeraVe, Vaseline, and Jergen's doesn't make sense for just one or two people.

Once opened, the shelf life of lotion is between six and 12 months, so giant bottles may very well end up in the trash, turning this into a wasteful purchase.

A smaller bottle from a grocery, drug, or mass retailer can be a better choice if you are the only person using it. That lets you choose a formula you already know works for you without tying up as much money in a large container. Walmart, for example, carries a range of Vaseline lotions in smaller sizes, giving shoppers more options without requiring a bulk commitment.

It's also worth remembering that the FDA does not require cosmetic products such as ordinary moisturizers to carry expiration dates, although manufacturers are responsible for product safety and shelf life. Heat, moisture, air, and repeated use can affect products over time. Buying a manageable size can help you use your lotion before its quality changes.

Most bulk purchases will save you money on essentials in the long run. However, it is just as important to keep the expiration date and contents of your item in mind.

Just as you wouldn't want bleach left in a thin plastic tub for too long, some items are better purchased and stored in smaller quantities.

The lowest price per ounce isn't always the same thing as the biggest savings. If a bulk purchase causes food to go uneaten, leaves you with more household products than you can use, or takes up valuable storage space, the savings can disappear. Shopping at Walmart, a local grocery store, Costco, or another retailer can give you more flexibility to buy the amount you actually need.

Before reaching for the largest package at Sam's Club, compare the total price, unit price, package size, and how quickly your household will use the product. Sometimes spending a little more per ounce at another store can leave you with less waste and more money in your wallet.