7 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pies for Thanksgiving (Some Cost Just $6)

Would anyone really know if you served a store-bought pumpkin pie instead of making one from scratch? With so many grocery stores offering ready-made holiday desserts, you might be surprised at how easy it is to skip the baking and save money on groceries without sacrificing a classic Thanksgiving treat. 

From oversized pies that can feed a crowd to smaller options for intimate gatherings, retailers like Costco, Aldi, and Trader Joe's offer plenty of choices. And some cost less than buying all the ingredients yourself.

Here are seven store-bought pumpkin pies worth considering for your Thanksgiving table.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Price: $5.99 in-store ($6.80 via Costco Same-Day)

Costco's Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie has become a popular Thanksgiving staple, and it's easy to understand why.

The enormous 58-ounce pie measures approximately 12 inches across, offering plenty of dessert for a large gathering. Despite its size, it has traditionally sold for around $5.99 at Costco warehouses.

That works out to roughly $0.50 per serving when divided into 12 slices, making it one of the most affordable options for feeding a crowd.

The bakery-prepared pie features a classic pumpkin filling with warm spices and a pastry crust. Since it's already baked, you can serve it without adding another task to your Thanksgiving cooking schedule.

You will need a Costco membership to purchase it at warehouse prices, and availability can vary during the busy holiday season. But for shoppers who want a large, affordable pumpkin pie, Costco is our top overall pick.

Price: $6.99

Kroger's Bakery Fresh Pumpkin Pie is a solid choice if you're looking for a classic Thanksgiving dessert without any extra fuss. The eight-inch pie offers a traditional pumpkin filling with warm spices, making it an easy addition to your holiday spread.

Its smaller size is especially convenient if you're hosting just a few people or planning to serve several desserts. You won't have to worry about finding room in the refrigerator for an enormous pie.

Kroger's bakery selection also makes it easy to pick up dessert while shopping for the rest of your Thanksgiving meal. Just check availability at your local store before making a special trip.

Price: $5.29 online

Aldi's Bake Shop Pumpkin Pie is another option for shoppers hoping to keep Thanksgiving expenses under control. The eight-inch, 24-ounce pie is a manageable size for smaller gatherings and eliminates the need to prepare dessert from scratch.

The ready-made pie also gives you a convenient starting point if you want to add your own finishing touches. A dollop of whipped cream or a sprinkle of cinnamon can make it feel a little more special.

While Aldi's pricing varies by location, the discount grocery chain is worth checking if you're trying to stretch your holiday food budget. Just remember that seasonal bakery items may have limited availability as Thanksgiving approaches.

Price: $7.34

Walmart's Freshness Guaranteed Pumpkin Pie is a convenient choice if you want something larger than a standard eight-inch pie without purchasing a warehouse-sized dessert.

The 10-inch pie weighs 37 ounces and comes fully baked, so you can skip the oven and focus on preparing the rest of your Thanksgiving meal.

At $7.34, it works out to about $0.92 per serving if you cut it into eight slices. That makes it an affordable option for families who want a traditional holiday dessert without spending much.

It's also easy to add to your regular Walmart grocery order, saving you an extra trip during an already busy holiday week.

Price: $6.99

Trader Joe's is known for its seasonal pumpkin products, and its Pumpkin Pie gives shoppers another way to bring those fall flavors to the Thanksgiving table.

If you're already visiting Trader Joe's for holiday appetizers, sides, or other seasonal favorites, picking up a prepared pumpkin pie can help simplify your shopping list.

It's also a convenient option for hosts who want to serve a familiar dessert without spending time making pie crust or preparing filling.

For a homemade touch, transfer the pie to a serving plate and top individual slices with freshly whipped cream. You can also add a light dusting of cinnamon or nutmeg before serving.

Since Trader Joe's seasonal products can disappear quickly, it's worth checking with your local store before Thanksgiving week.

Price: Check local store

Whole Foods Market's Pumpkin Pie is worth considering if you're looking for a ready-made dessert while shopping for a more upscale Thanksgiving meal.

Buying a prepared pie means you can skip measuring ingredients, making crust, and waiting for dessert to cool. That's especially helpful when you're already preparing several other dishes for a holiday gathering.

Whole Foods also offers the convenience of picking up dessert alongside specialty groceries and other Thanksgiving essentials.

If presentation is important, you can easily dress up the pie with homemade whipped cream or toasted pecans. Serving it on a decorative pie plate instead of in its original packaging can also make a difference.

Check your local Whole Foods bakery for current pricing, availability, and holiday ordering options.

Price: $5.98

If you're feeding a crowd this Thanksgiving, Sam's Club's Member's Mark Pumpkin Pie offers an impressive amount of dessert for the price.

The 12-inch pie weighs 58 ounces, making it considerably larger than many standard grocery-store options. At $5.98, you're paying about $0.50 per serving if you divide it into 12 slices.

The pie features a traditional pumpkin filling with warm spices and a pastry crust, giving guests the familiar holiday dessert they expect.

Its generous size makes it especially appealing for large family gatherings, potlucks, or anyone hoping to have leftovers after Thanksgiving dinner.

The main catch is that you'll need a Sam's Club membership to take advantage of warehouse pricing. But if you're already a member, this pie is one of the strongest budget options on the list.

You don't have to spend hours baking to put a pumpkin pie on the Thanksgiving table. Grocery stores offer plenty of ready-made options, whether you're hosting a few guests or feeding an entire family.

Costco's Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie is our best overall pick for its size and value, while Sam's Club's Member's Mark Pumpkin Pie is another excellent budget option. Whole Foods is worth considering if you're already shopping there for a more upscale holiday meal.

Whichever pie you choose, consider adding fresh whipped cream, toasted pecans, or a sprinkle of cinnamon before serving. A few simple touches can make a store-bought dessert feel more festive without adding much work. If Costco is your pick, try these best Costco hacks.