Late October is when Sam's Club rolls out its Member's Mark Thanksgiving spread, and the prepared food case fills up with trays, sides, and desserts that can cover most of a holiday table without anyone touching a mixing bowl.
The question is which pieces are actually worth buying. The lineup below runs from the smoked turkey to the mashed potatoes to a tray built for grazing before dinner even starts. A few are easy skips, and one is the clear standout.
Before you build a shopping list, a few ways to save money at Sam's Club keep the holiday haul from quietly inflating the bill.
Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.
- 18-29
- 30-39
- 40-49
- 50-59
- 60-69
- 70-79
- 80+
Member's Mark Yeast Dinner Rolls
Price: $3.98
Every Thanksgiving table needs a roll basket, and this 24-count bag covers it without anyone noticing it came from a warehouse club. They are baked fresh at Sam's Club daily, with a soft interior and a buttery golden crust, and they hold up fine on the counter without refrigeration.
One buyer, Linda, said, "We love these rolls. They're the perfect size for a sandwich. We divided them up in bags of 6 rolls per bag. We leave one bag out and freeze the rest." Another, JACloud50, rates them above King's Hawaiian rolls.
Member's Mark 12-Inch Pumpkin Pie
Price: $5.98
This 58-ounce pie serves about 11 to 14 people and is made fresh daily, with a golden crust and a well-spiced filling made from pumpkin puree, brown sugar, and cinnamon. At under $6 for a pie this size, it is one of the easiest wins on the list.
Fran said, "The pumpkin pie from Sam's Club is the best pumpkin pie I have ever had. When I buy them, I'll buy them three at a time and I freeze too." Shelley added, "Way cheaper than you can make it from scratch and just as good as grandmas home made pumpkin pie."
Member's Mark Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes
Price: $6.87 (regularly $7.87)
Two 32-ounce trays of Yukon Gold mashed potatoes skip the peeling and boiling entirely and still taste homemade. They microwave right in the BPA-free tray in six to seven minutes, which frees up oven space for everything else, and they are a dollar off right now.
One reviewer, The Bargain Foodie, called them "a great shortcut when you want the taste of homemade mashed potatoes without all the peeling, boiling, and mashing." Another noted an occasional watery layer that just needs stirring in, and suggested returning any tray with a damaged seal.
Member's Mark Five Cheese Bacon Macaroni
Price: $9.98
This one leans into comfort food, with cheddar, mozzarella, mascarpone, parmesan, and Romano melted over cavatappi noodles and a generous amount of bacon. At 40 ounces, it is about six servings, enough for a side dish that disappears fast at a crowded table.
Kevin said, "I'm not a Big Mac n cheese guy, but this was incredible! I only wish that it came as 2 smaller portions instead of one large. My girls loved it!" Ewa's family keeps buying it, saying it is easy to prepare and tastes creamy and cheesy.
Member's Mark Boneless Uncured Carver Ham
Price: $10.54
Priced at $2.97 a pound, this applewood-smoked ham averages about $10.54 and skips the bone, which makes carving far less of a hassle on a busy holiday afternoon. It is fully cooked, made without nitrates or nitrites, and reheats at 275 degrees for roughly 15 minutes per pound.
Oldguy99 called it "a must buy and my favorite signal that fall is here," adding that it is "real off-the-bone ham, not ground and pressed into a loaf." LB agreed, noting it is easy to slice and great on sandwiches or a party tray.
Member's Mark Fresh-Cut Vegetable Tray and Ranch Dressing
Price: $14.25
This tray runs $4.44 a pound and averages about $14.25, feeding six to eight people with broccoli, cauliflower, cucumbers, mini peppers, and more, plus two containers of Litehouse Homestyle ranch. The exact mix shifts with what the club has in stock that week.
It is also the one with the most mixed feedback. FurrykidsMom warned that the trays "are not sealed as well as you might think," and Michael Showalter returned his after finding slimy carrots. Give the tray a good look before it goes in the cart.
Member's Mark Fruit and Cheese Tray
Price: $17.43
At $4.98 a pound, this tray averages about $17.43 and covers a party's worth of green and red grapes, strawberries or apple slices, cheddar, and Colby Jack for six to eight people. It arrives ready to set on the table, no arranging required.
Tanya said, "The fruit was fresh and appealing with a nice variety. It was arranged beautifully on a tray! Didn't have to do anything except to place it on the table!" AlaNan ordered one online for curbside pickup before a family party and called it simple.
Member's Mark Gourmet Brownie Tray
Price: $20.93
Twenty-four pre-cut brownies, split between chocolate buttercream, cream cheese icing, and creamy caramel, round out dessert for anyone who wants options beyond pie. At 56 ounces, it is a lot of chocolate for one tray; it needs no refrigeration, and it is cut and ready to serve.
One reviewer said, "These brownies are absolutely wonderful. They are a very rich chocolate, so moist and were a big hit... didn't last long! I will be buying these again!" E Mac called the caramel and vanilla "decadent" and plans to buy them "over and over."
Member's Mark Hickory Smoked Whole Turkey
Price: $38.14
This is the centerpiece most people come for, a fully cooked, hickory-smoked whole turkey running 9 to 14 pounds, priced at $2.98 a pound and averaging about $38.14. It is gluten-free, raised with no added hormones or steroids, and feeds roughly 10 to 12 people with no oven time.
MRKJ said, "I've purchased smoked turkeys from well known smokehouses, and they are delicious. This smoked turkey from Sam's is absolutely as delicious as some that I have tried, but is a third the cost." CaliCafeFiend refuses to buy any other turkey for holiday meals.
Get a protection plan on all your appliances
Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.
Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.
For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.
Member's Mark Charcuterie Entertainment Tray
Price: $29.14
This is the standout, and it is not close. The 44-ounce tray works out to about 66 cents an ounce and feeds 10 to 12 people with Havarti Dill, smoked Gouda, Brie, prosciutto, hot soppressata, Genoa salami, a Greek olive medley, fig spread, pepper jelly, stone-ground mustard, mixed nuts, and multigrain crackers.
Yumpizza said, "It has everything you need and at a great value. The ingredients are really high quality and mirror what I usually buy a la cart when building a charcuterie board for parties." AKD said, "I love a good charcuterie, but it is expensive and time consuming to put a good one together."
At 4.8 stars, it is the highest-rated item here. Set it out before dinner, and it disappears well before the turkey hits the table.
Bottom line
The smarter approach is picking a mix of individual items rather than assuming the full meal bundle is automatically the better deal, since some trays and sides punch well above what they cost. Order the meat early, because anything priced per pound gets picked over as the holiday gets closer.
Reheat covered, low, and slow to protect the texture, and let the cold trays sit out just long enough to take the chill off before guests arrive. If you are budgeting for the whole season, lining up the best cash back credit cards means the grocery runs earn something back.
on Wells Fargo's secure website Intro Offer
$100 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months
Annual Fee $0 Why we like it
If you love earning cash rewards but prefer to avoid the hassle of tracking spending categories, the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card could be a good option for you. Card members can earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases.
This card also offers a 0% intro APR on qualifying balance transfers and purchases for 12 months from account opening, then 18.74%, 24.74%, or 28.74% Variable. Those looking for straightforward rewards and an introductory APR will likely find value in this card.
FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment.
Our partners do not influence how we rate products.
Subscribe Today
Learn how to make an extra $200
Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.
Add Us On Google