12 Best Small Towns To Buy a Cheap Historic Home

For buyers who want character over new construction, older homes still offer some of the best value on the market. Plenty of towns have neighborhoods built generations ago with solid bones, taller ceilings, and mature trees lining the street, often at prices that newer subdivisions cannot match.

Before buying an older home anywhere, it's worth budgeting for a thorough inspection, asking about insurance costs tied to older roofs, wiring, or plumbing, and checking whether the property sits in a local historic district that limits renovations. With that groundwork in mind, here's a look at 12 small towns where older homes remain within reach.

Editor's note: Median gross rents are from City-Data's 2024 figures, average home values are from Zillow's September 2026 data, and cost-of-living figures are from Sperling's BestPlaces.

Kenner, Louisiana

Median rent: $1,212

Average home value: $259,864

Kenner's established neighborhoods hold a mix of modest single-story houses and larger older homes, giving buyers room to compare fixer-uppers against properties that have already been updated.

A downtown commercial corridor and neighborhood shopping strips keep grocery stores, pharmacies, and casual restaurants within easy reach. Anyone eyeing an older home here should plan for a full inspection and ask early about insurance requirements, since older construction can carry different coverage considerations than newer builds.

Gary, Indiana

Median rent: $968

Average home value: $87,485

Gary's defining feature is its stretch of waterfront parks and trails along Lake Michigan's southern shore, with dune-and-savanna natural areas nearby for hiking and birdwatching. A local college campus in town adds steady college-town energy to the community calendar.

With home values averaging around $87,000, Gary's older housing stock stays unusually affordable, including homes with original woodwork and larger lots than newer construction typically provides.

Indiana does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does levy its own income tax on other earnings. A regional hospital system serves residents in the surrounding area, and the local cost of living runs about 12.7% below the national average.

Decatur, Illinois

Median rent: $892

Average home value: $104,647

Waterfront parks and trails line a reservoir lake fed by a river winding through town, offering fishing, walking paths, and open green space. A local college keeps year-round activity going, while the surrounding area's agricultural roots give Decatur a quieter, small-city pace.

Home values averaging under $105,000 make older houses here notably affordable, and hospital-based health systems with clinics and specialty centers serve the city and the surrounding central Illinois area.

Illinois does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does tax other income. Decatur's cost of living runs about 27.1% below the national average.

Janesville, Wisconsin

Median rent: $993

Average home value: $296,361

Janesville sits along the Rock River, with extensive parkland and trails that have long given it a park-centric reputation. A local college adds college-town energy, and the city still carries a manufacturing-rooted identity tied to its agricultural-equipment and auto-industry past.

Older homes near the riverfront and on historic residential blocks offer character at a range of price points, from compact cottages to roomier houses waiting on updates.

Wisconsin does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does levy a regular income tax on other earnings. A regional hospital and health care network serves the area, and the local cost of living runs about 17.2% below the national average.

Albany, Georgia

Median rent: $964

Average home value: $132,195

The Flint River flows through the heart of downtown Albany, offering waterfront parks and trail access right in the city. Local colleges contribute to a college-town feel, and the city carries meaningful history tied to the Civil Rights era.

With home values averaging around $132,000, older houses near downtown and in established residential neighborhoods remain within reach for buyers seeking character without a steep price tag.

Georgia does not tax Social Security income, though the state does levy its own income tax on other earnings. A regional health system with hospitals and clinics serves southwest Georgia, and Albany's cost of living runs about 27.3% below the national average.

Waterloo, Iowa

Median rent: $1,005

Average home value: $146,001

The Cedar River bisects Waterloo into eastern and western halves, lining the city with waterfront parks and multi-use trails. A local college adds steady college-town energy, and the overall pace stays relaxed.

Home values averaging around $146,000 put older homes with established character within reach of most budgets, whether buyers want a riverside cottage or a larger older house with room to update.

Iowa does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does still tax other earnings. A regional hospital system serves the area, and the cost of living runs about 24.3% below the national average.

Schenectady, New York

Median rent: $1,212

Average home value: $331,463

Schenectady sits along the Mohawk River, with waterfront parks and trails and a historic downtown district lined with tree-shaded streets. A local college adds steady energy, and a mix of century-old architecture and small-scale downtown revitalization appeals to buyers who want walkable, historic surroundings.

Older homes here often come with the architectural detail that defines a true historic property, though buyers in designated historic blocks should check on any restrictions before planning exterior renovations.

New York does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does tax other income. A regional hospital and health system provides emergency and general medical care, and the cost of living runs about 8.5% below the national average.

Canton, Ohio

Median rent: $844

Average home value: $174,287

Canton's older residential streets include homes built generations ago, many with the deeper lots and mature landscaping that come with long-established neighborhoods. A downtown core and surrounding commercial strips keep grocery stores, pharmacies, and local dining within a short drive for most residents.

With home values averaging around $174,000, buyers can find a range of older housing stock, from smaller fixer-uppers to larger homes already updated. As with any older purchase, a full inspection and a clear understanding of insurance costs tied to an aging roof or electrical system are worth budgeting for upfront, along with a check on whether a property falls within a local historic district before planning any exterior changes.

Ocala, Florida

Median rent: $1,628

Average home value: $263,895

Ocala's long-standing equestrian and horse-farm heritage gives the surrounding countryside a distinct feel, while nearby natural springs and a national forest supply trails, paddling, and other outdoor recreation. A local college in town adds college-town energy to the community.

Home values here average around $265,000, with older homes near downtown offering a different character than the area's horse-farm properties.

Florida does not tax Social Security benefits, and the state has no personal income tax at all. A regional hospital system serves the community, and the cost of living runs about 13% below the national average.

Pawtucket, Rhode Island

Median rent: $1,229

Average home value: $399,302

A historic mill city along the Blackstone River, Pawtucket pairs riverfront parks and walking trails with a revitalized downtown arts and maker district. Its location puts the Providence and Boston metro areas within easy reach for day trips or bigger-city amenities.

Older mill-town housing stock here includes homes with genuine period detail, from worker cottages to larger houses on established streets.

Rhode Island does tax Social Security benefits, and the state also levies a regular income tax, so buyers should factor that into the math alongside the metro-area access. Primary care and community health clinics operate in town, with larger regional hospital systems nearby in the Providence area. The local cost of living runs about 8.8% above the national average.

Jonesboro, Arkansas

Median rent: $872

Average home value: $226,988

Jonesboro sits atop Crowley's Ridge, a geological formation rising above the surrounding Mississippi alluvial plain and giving the town a wooded, ridge-top setting amid the flat Delta. A long-established local college adds college-town energy, and parks around town offer trails, lakes, and outdoor recreation.

Older homes on and around the ridge often come with mature trees and elevation-driven character, at home values averaging around $227,000.

Arkansas does not tax Social Security benefits, though the state does tax other income. A regional hospital and health system serves Jonesboro and the surrounding Northeast Arkansas area, and the cost of living runs about 20.9% below the national average.

Flint, Michigan

Median rent: $964

Average home value: $64,412

A river flows past downtown Flint through riverside parks, with a paved trail running alongside it, and multiple local colleges keep college-town energy flowing year-round. The city's visible automotive-manufacturing heritage still shapes its identity and its older residential neighborhoods.

With home values averaging just over $62,000, Flint's older housing stock is about as low-cost as it gets, including homes built during the city's manufacturing boom with solid, if sometimes dated, construction.

Michigan does not tax Social Security benefits at the state level, though the state does levy its own income tax on other income. A regional hospital system serves the area, with medical facilities located along the riverfront near downtown, and the cost of living runs about 14.9% below the national average.

Bottom line

Across these 12 towns, older homes come in a wide range of styles, conditions, and price points, with character, taxes, and everyday costs varying just as widely. The right fit depends on how much renovation a buyer wants to take on, how a state treats Social Security income, and how much weight someone puts on walkable downtowns versus waterfront access.

Whatever the choice, a careful inspection, a clear read on insurance costs, and an early check on any local historic-district rules will help any buyer turn an older house into a long-term home without stretching a tight budget.

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice.

You May Also Like

23 Ways To Get Money Without Getting A Second Job

By FinanceBuzz Editors

How To Save Money on Car Insurance: 12 Ways to Lower Rates

By Elyssa Kirkham

10 Things Seniors Born Between 1941-1969 Could Take Advantage Of

By FinanceBuzz Editors

19 Dumbest Things Smart People Waste Money On

By Team FBZ

7 Moves If You Want to Stop Living Paycheck to Paycheck

By FinanceBuzz Editors

7 Clever Ways to Crush Your Debt

By FinanceBuzz Editors

Help Protect Your Savings From Stock Market Volatility With Gold

American Hartford Gold Benefits

• American Hartford Gold helps individuals protect their retirement by rolling over IRAs and 401(k)s into physical gold.
• Includes FREE IRA rollover and storage for up to 3 years.
• Get up to $20,000 in free silver on qualifying purchases.

Download your guide for free

---

Subscribe Today

Learn how to make an extra $200

Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.

or

Subscribe Now →

By submitting this form you agree to receive emails from FinanceBuzz and to the privacy policy and terms