11 High-Quality Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Items (Most Are Better Than the Name Brand Stuff)

Store brands used to be the compromise you made to save a few dollars. Member's Mark is not that anymore. Spend an afternoon on the Sam's Club site, and a pattern shows up fast: the same jar size as the name brand, the same certification on the label, and a lower price.

Some of these are outright dupes. There are cookie thins built on the same crisp-and-thin idea as a famous bakery brand, a chestnut suede slipper that looks awfully familiar, and a three-wick candle that holds far more wax than the mall version.

Here are 11 that hold their own, plus a few ways to get the most out of your Sam's membership.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

Multiple Cars?

Yes

No

Homeowner

Yes

No

Age

30-39

• 18-29
• 30-39
• 40-49
• 50-59
• 60-69
• 70-79
• 80+

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Great News! We’ve located some excellent quote options just for you.

Where can we send you info and recommendations?

Enter Email

Bundle Home & Auto to Save More?

Yes

No

Active Military?

No

Yes

Compare Quotes

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Price: $4.98

If you have ever paid up for Tate's Bake Shop, this is the comparison that stings. Tate's Chocolate Chip Cookies run $4.97 for a 7-ounce bag at Walmart, or about 71 cents an ounce. These come in a 16-ounce bag for a penny more, which works out to 31 cents an ounce.

That's less than half the price of the name brand, but just as delicious if not better. They are thin, snappy, and built for dunking, and they hold a 4.6-star rating across more than 1,250 ratings.

One buyer, SDW, wrote that they are "so good and crisp and delicious, but they don't stay in stock all the time, which can be disappointing." Grab two bags when you see them.

Price: $9.76

This is the closest thing to a Starbucks egg bite you can keep in your own refrigerator. You get 10 bites, packed two to a sleeve, for $1.95 a pack. A single order at the coffee counter costs several times that, and you have to leave the house for it.

The base is nonfat cottage cheese and whole eggs, which is what gives the Starbucks version its custardy texture too. They hold 4.5 stars across 2,917 ratings. One buyer, Douglas, wrote that "these have become my go-to breakfast." Another noted they reheat easily in an air fryer.

Price: $11.48

Bibigo dumplings have the freezer aisle sewn up, but this 48-ounce bag is the one worth keeping on hand. It holds roughly 16 servings at four pieces each, so a bag covers a weeknight dinner and a drop-in guest with room to spare.

Shoppers give them 4.6 stars across 3,309 ratings. One buyer, Emily, steams hers in a lidded pan with a little water and oil, and wrote that "the amount you get for the price is great."

Price: $12.98

Here is the biggest gap on this list. Pottery Barn's Cozy Teddy Faux Fur Throw lists for $199 and is currently marked down to $62.97. This one is $12.98, measures 60 by 72 inches, and is reversible: sherpa on one side and high pile on the other.

It carries 4.8 stars across 8,682 ratings, the strongest showing in this roundup. One buyer, Mary, wrote that "these throws are so soft and warm. They launder very well, no shedding of fibers."

Price: $12.98

DiGiorno built the rising-crust category, and this is a direct shot at it. A DiGiorno Rising Crust Ultimate Pepperoni with Cheese is $5.97 for 24.7 ounces at Walmart.

Sam's sells three individually wrapped pizzas totaling just over 90 ounces, which comes to $4.33 and about 30 ounces per pizza. So you get a bigger pizza for less money, with 14 grams of protein per serving.

The rating is 4.7 stars across 8,942 ratings. One buyer, KeriLynn, wrote, "I've never been the biggest fan of frozen pizza, however these ones are worth it!"

Price: $14.97

Bath & Body Works trained us all to think $25 is a normal price for a candle. Its Mahogany Teakwood 3-Wick Candle is $24.95 for 14.5 ounces, or roughly $1.72 an ounce. This one is 24 ounces for $14.97, which is about 62 cents an ounce.

Both are soy-wax blends in heavy glass with three wicks, so the format is the same, and the jar here is simply larger. It holds 4.1 stars across 39 ratings, a smaller sample than most items on this list. Scents rotate seasonally.

Price: $14.98

This is the cleanest apples-to-apples swap in the roundup. Planters Deluxe Salted Mixed Nuts costs $19.96 for a 34-ounce jar at Walmart. Member's Mark sells the identical 34-ounce jar for $14.98, a difference of nearly $5 for the same amount of nuts.

The ingredient list is short, and there is no peanut filler: cashews, almonds, pecans, pistachios, peanut oil, and sea salt. That mix is exactly what "deluxe" is supposed to mean, and it holds 4.5 stars across 2,397 ratings. Set the jar out for company, and nobody will ask what brand it is.

Price: $16.98

Sandwash is the buttery, slightly brushed finish that made Lululemon's Softstreme line a cult item at well over $100. This jogger goes after the same feel for $16.98, and the fabric blend is the reason it gets close: 49% recycled polyester, 43% Livaeco modal, and 8% spandex.

Modal gives the pants their drape rather than that stiff athletic-legging feel. They have a midweight, relaxed fit, are sized XS through 3XL, and are rated 4.5 stars.

Price: $17.24

Greenies are the default here, and they are expensive: $28.98 for a 24-ounce regular-size pack at Walmart, or roughly $1.21 a chew. These are 30 chews for $17.24, which is 57 cents each.

The detail that matters is on the label. Both are accepted by the Veterinary Oral Health Council, the certification that separates a real dental chew from a biscuit with ridges. These are also wheat- and gluten-free with no added artificial colors.

They hold 4.7 stars across 5,700 ratings. One buyer, Heather, said her dogs have "less tartar on their teeth than before. And they get so excited when they see the bag."

Price: $19.48

Look at these two side by side, and the math is almost funny. Tide PODS in Original Scent cost $19.94 for 76 pods at Walmart, about 26 cents a load. These are $19.48 for 130 pods, or 15 cents a load. Same money, 54 more loads.

The formula uses biodegradable cleaning agents and contains no phosphates, and the rating is 4.5 stars across 2,235 ratings. One buyer, Mike, put it plainly: "I normally use a major name brand but thought I would give the Sam's Club brand a try. It had more suds, clothes came out nice and clean."

Price: $25.98

Here's the splurge pick and the most obvious dupe on the list. UGG's Women's Scuffette II is $100 and comes in Chestnut. This slipper is $25.98, also comes in Chestnut, and pairs a suede upper with a plush wool lining and a slip-resistant EVA outsole you can wear to the mailbox.

UGG lines its version in sheepskin, so this is not a perfect match, but at roughly a quarter of the price, it is close enough for most people. It holds 4.7 stars, though only across 22 ratings. Chocolate and Pink are sold out, sizes 6 and 11 are gone, and shipping is the only option.

The store brand has quietly turned into the best argument for a Sam's Club membership. The wins are not random, either. They cluster in aisles where the name brand is charging for the label rather than the ingredients, so that is where to start comparing.

Two practical notes. Fulfillment varies item by item, so check whether something ships or is pickup only before you build a cart around it. And apparel and home goods rotate faster than groceries, so buy the color you like when you see it.

While you are trimming the budget, look for more ways to save money on groceries beyond going for Sam's generic brand, like keeping an eye on the instant savings offered every month by the bulk retailer.