14 Collectibles To Buy Now at Five Below With Potential To Be Super Valuable Some Day

Collectors could find deals in an unexpected store — Five Below. The discount chain has been the home to some rare and exclusive collectibles, and some of the items they sell now could be worth much more in the future. Most shoppers frequent Five Below as a way to save money on everyday essentials, but some are viewing the store's stock with an eye for potential resale on future collectibles.

Learn what Five Below collectibles could increase drastically in value and help you make bank in the future.

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change and may vary by location.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Rainbow Brite is a nostalgic franchise born in the 80s that revolves around the premise of a young girl trapped in a grey world who rescues the seven Color Kids with the help of a furry sprite, and restores color to the world.

Why you should collect it:

Rainbow Brite and her friends have been fetching outrageous prices from the very beginning. There's no way to know which of the eight different figurines will be hard to find in the future, but Patty O'Green is currently retailing at Walmart for $22.99.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Funko Pops are stylized figurines that feature characters from popular movies, video games, comic books, and other pop culture icons.

Why you should collect it:

The average price of a Funko Pop ranges between $13 and $60, and the iconic collectibles can skyrocket in price from there. Five Below has a mystery grab bag with one random mini vinyl figure that is based on a classic Disney villain. The "blind bag" style offering means you could score a rare figure that will increase in value in the future.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Dragon Ball began as a Japanese manga that grew into a dual anime series, and is now a massive media franchise. The plot follows Goku as he explores the world searching for seven Dragon Ball orbs that will summon a wish-granting dragon when combined.

Why you should collect it:

Dragon Ball is one of the largest and most varied series you can collect because of the wide range of types of collectibles within the franchise. The Super Saiyan Rose Goku Black figure is already reselling for as much as $25.99, and is unavailable from Walmart, while other variations are still in stock.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Squishmallows are stuffed plush toys launched by Jazwares, a company owned by Berkshire Hathaway, which has a CEO famous for investing — Warren Buffett. The plushes have a cute, kawaii look and rose to popularity during the pandemic through viral social media outlets. And, as you can probably tell, they are incredibly squishy.

Why you should collect it:

The Squooshems are smaller than standard Squishmallows and have a tactile sensation more like stress-relief balls than stuffed animals. Figures like Ileana the Easter Cupcake are already selling for $13.95 on resale sites like eBay, and that is just one of the potential options available in the mystery blind bag available at Five Below.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

The Littlest Pet Shop was a toy franchise and cartoon series launched by Hasbro in the 90s. The franchise includes over 3,000 "adoptable" pet toys and has spawned several video game adaptations. The most recent, a mini-game, was launched on Roblox at the end of 2023.

Why you should collect it:

Rare or old LPS figurines continue to have a thriving market on resale sites like eBay and can generate a surprising amount of profit. The Springtime Bunny already sells for between $10 and $20 to collectors, so it could continue to appreciate in value over the next few years.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

SpongeBob SquarePants is a beloved children's comedy cartoon that first aired in 1999 and has continued in popularity ever since. The show focuses on a sea sponge and his aquatic adventures living in a submerged pineapple and working in a fast food restaurant that serves the underwater population.

Why you should collect it:

The SpongeBob food figures are shaped like fast food takeout options from the show's Krusty Krab restaurant, and while they may not be worth much yet, they have a strong similarity to McDonald's Changeables Happy Meal toys, which have increased significantly in value over time.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Disney's Lilo & Stitch is an animated classic from 2002 about an alien science experiment that lands on Earth. The creature pretends to be a dog and gets adopted by an eccentric young girl who is being raised by her sister.

Why you should collect it:

A new live-action movie is scheduled for release by Disney later this year, which could position Stitch figurines to increase in collectible value

Price: $5.00

What it is:

All the nostalgia of classic 80s and 90s era toys is squeezed into these mini Funko figurines. Even non-collectors will be tempted by these vintage-style collectibles.

Why you should collect it:

Several of the figures are already worth more than the five-spot price tag, especially the three exclusive figures. The My Pet Monster figure is one of the most popular and is reselling for about $20 on third-party sites. Cavity Sam from the game Operation is reselling for about $15, along with the Monopoly Man, Play-Doh Pete, and Mrs. Potato Head.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Tokidoki is a Japanese-inspired pop culture brand created by Italian artist Simone Legno that blends the cute with the edgy and is featured on a range of apparel and collectible items.

Why you should collect it:

Tokidoki has a high resale value because they update their styles and designs with seasonal limited editions, so popular characters and merchandise have a short retail shelf life before only being available as resales. The individual Unicornos carnival pins are already reselling for approximately $13 to $15, but very few are even being resold from the carnival set due to their popularity, so demand could shoot up.

Price: $2.25

What it is:

Tokidoki Unicornos are like My Little Ponies if they were all unicorns and going through an edgy teenager phase.

Why you should collect it:

Most Tokidoki products have a high resale value after a short time, but stickers are also rising in popularity as many people have returned to physical journaling to avoid AI technology and intrusive social media practices by tech giants. These sticker books are already reselling for $7.99, and Five Below has them marked as a low stock item, so they're selling out fast.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Tokidoki's Moofia characters are a line of dairy-inspired personified foods, and dairy-ified people and animals.

Why you should collect it:

Tokidoki notebooks resell for around $10 to $15, and the tabbed design is a newer addition likely to continue to increase in value.

Price: $5.55

What it is:

Wicked is the movie adaptation of a stage musical adaptation of a book adaptation of the classic musical film adaptation of the book The Wonderful Wizard of Oz by L. Frank Baum. It is currently streaming on Peacock.

Why you should collect it:

The Wizard of Oz world has been around for 125 years since the original book's publication and has remained steadily popular. The newest iteration starring Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo has everybody singing along instead of just the usual theater majors. A framed version of the movie poster is already being sold at Target for $64.99, so it could be worth tucking away for future resale.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Netflix popped out a surprise hit with Stranger Things, and the fifth and final season is expected to stream this year. The sci-fi series is set in the nostalgic 80s, where a town is plagued by a hostile alternate reality called the Upside Down.

Why you should collect it:

The 100-piece set has repositionable decals in a variety of artistic styles, and retails slightly higher at other outlets, running between $9 and $12. It's likely to see a price bump that coincides with the release of the final season.

Price: $5.00

What it is:

Hershey's is the chocolate capital of the U.S. and is basically synonymous with chocolate for Americans. The company's branded products are often sought-after collectibles due to their nostalgia, interesting design, and limited availability.

Why you should collect it:

Resellers are already pricing these between $9 and $17 on sites like eBay, and the last Hershey's branded model resells in used condition at about twice that price.

There are never any guarantees in the collectible market, but Five Below has quite a few that are already selling higher on the market. The general theme of 2025 so far is that prices only go up on everything, so picking up a few cheap collectibles that are likely to go up in value quickly could help you make cash on the side.