Cruises have a reputation as one of the easiest ways to travel on a budget, since one fare covers your cabin and most of your meals. But that deal gets a lot less sweet when your ship gets dinged by health inspectors or your sailing gets canceled months after you booked. A typical cruise already runs just over $2,750 per adult, so picking the wrong line is a pricey mistake.
To build this list, we looked at 2026 CDC Vessel Sanitation Program scores (anything 85 or below is a fail), passenger satisfaction ratings, recurring complaints, and recent cancellations. Just keep in mind that a sanitation score only reflects conditions on inspection day, so a ship's grade can swing a lot from one visit to the next. Here are the lines that kept popping up for the wrong reasons.
Norwegian Cruise Line
Norwegian finished dead last among 19 cruise lines in Consumer Reports' 2026 survey of 18,850 members. Loyal passengers point to a string of cost-cutting moves, like a new charge for additional entrées and the switch from show reservations to first-come, first-served seating that means long lines. The line also changed preset itineraries in October 2025, which left plenty of booked guests frustrated.
Sanitation is another sore spot. Norwegian Dawn scored an 84 during a March 29 inspection in Tampa, the first failing grade of the year. Norwegian sent the CDC a corrective action report five days later.
To be fair, Norwegian Viva earned a perfect 100, and the line's scheduling flexibility is still a real perk if you like a looser vacation.
MSC Cruises
MSC also ranked low in the Consumer Reports survey, and crowding is the gripe you'll see most often in reviews. One MSC Meraviglia passenger who sailed from Brooklyn ended up clearing tables for fellow guests who had nowhere to sit at the buffet. Another Meraviglia reviewer noted that only one entrée is free at dinner, with each extra costing $5.
Fees are creeping up, too. MSC raised its Hotel Service Charge from $16 to $17 per person per day in standard staterooms on May 11, 2026. MSC Meraviglia also scored an 89, one of the lowest passing marks this year.
Still, MSC ranked third among megaships in Condé Nast Traveler's 2026 Readers' Choice Awards. If you love a giant, flashy ship and don't mind sharing it with up to 6,700 people, it could still work for you.
Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival has carried a budget reputation for years, and the Consumer Reports survey again placed it among the lower-scoring lines. Costs keep inching up as well. Carnival bumped its daily gratuity from $16 to $17 per person in standard cabins as of April 2, 2026.
Cancellations have stung some travelers. Carnival scrapped 11 Carnival Firenze sailings from Long Beach that were scheduled between October 12 and November 16, 2026. Affected guests could rebook a comparable cruise or take a full refund, but that's cold comfort if your vacation days were already locked in.
Carnival's sanitation record also shows how much scores can swing. Carnival Breeze dropped from a perfect 100 in January to an 86 on May 14, the bare minimum to pass. Meanwhile, Carnival Celebration earned a 100. If you grab a rock-bottom fare and keep your expectations realistic, Carnival can still be a fun, cheap getaway.
Earn a travel bonus worth $250 with this incredible card
With the Bank of America® Travel Rewards credit card you can earn 25,000 bonus points after spending $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening.
The 25,000 bonus points can be redeemed for a $250 statement credit toward travel or dining purchases.
The best part? There's no annual fee.
Princess Cruises
Princess usually gets solid marks, which makes its rough 2026 stand out. Emerald Princess scored a 78 during an October 16 inspection in Long Beach, its first failing grade since launching in 2007. Inspectors documented spoiled food and dirty kitchen equipment. Sun Princess, one of the line's newest ships, scored an 89 earlier in the year.
Itinerary shake-ups have piled on. Royal Princess dropped two Alaska ports in September 2026 after an engine issue, and Princess canceled all Majestic Princess sailings from Galveston between November 2026 and March 2027.
That said, Emerald Princess scored a 99 in May and has earned seven perfect scores over its career. Fans of the line may want to wait for a passing re-inspection before booking that ship.
Bottom line
None of these lines guarantees a bad trip, but low satisfaction ratings and shaky inspection results mean you should do a little homework first. Look up your specific ship on the CDC's inspection search tool rather than judging the whole fleet, and stick to reviews from the past few months since conditions change fast.
Also, a failing score doesn't force a ship to stop sailing, but the CDC posts the line's corrective action statement next to the inspection report, so you can see exactly what got fixed. And if you want to save money on travel, add daily service charges and dining upcharges to the fare before comparing lines, because the cheapest sticker price isn't always the cheapest cruise.
More from FinanceBuzz:
- 12 ways to pocket up to $300.
- Are you a homeowner? Get a protection plan on all your appliances.
- 10 little weird hacks Costco shoppers should know.
- Learn how to escape the paycheck-to-paycheck grind.
Add Us On Google