THE BEST

of

2025

Credit Card Awards

How credit card companies structure rewards programs

Understanding how issuers design rewards programs helped us evaluate which cards offered the most value to consumers.

Credit card companies use different reward structures to attract specific cardholders. Flat-rate cash back credit cards provide the same earning rate on every purchase, making them straightforward for consumers who want simplicity. The Wells Fargo Active Cash^® Card is a good example of this type of card.

Bonus category cards offer higher earning rates in specific spending categories, rewarding cardholders who can maximize those categories. These cards often rotate categories every quarter. Some cards, like the Bank of America^® Customized Cash Rewards credit card, let consumers choose their own bonus categories, offering flexibility for different spending patterns.

Companies offer rewards in points, miles, or cash-back percentages. A card offering 2% cash back returns $2 for every $100 spent. A card with "3X points" awards three points per dollar, though the actual value depends on redemption options. This distinction helped us compare true value across different reward currencies.

How credit card companies determine fees

Fee structures significantly impact the total cost of carrying a credit card, and understanding these helped us evaluate overall value propositions.

Annual fees range from $0 on basic cards to $700 or more on premium travel cards. The fee typically correlates to benefit generosity. Premium travel cards justify higher fees through travel credits, lounge access, and elevated earning rates.

Foreign transaction fees typically add 3% to international purchases, though many travel-focused cards waive this charge entirely. Cards best suited for international travelers eliminate these fees.

Balance transfer fees usually range from 3% to 5% of the transferred amount. Cards that focus on low-interest promotions often maintain standard transfer fees despite their other advantages.

How credit card companies structure welcome offers

Welcome offers represent a major competitive tool for credit card issuers, and understanding their structure helped us evaluate introductory promotions.

Companies set minimum spending requirements that cardholders must meet within a specified timeframe, typically three months. Premium travel cards might require $4,000 to $15,000 in spending for substantial bonuses. These thresholds vary widely. Student cards often require minimal or no spending thresholds, while premium business cards set higher requirements.

The value proposition varies significantly depending on the redemption options. Points from some cards can be transferred to airline partners for potentially higher value, while cash back from others provides straightforward dollar-for-dollar value. This redemption flexibility factored heavily into our award evaluations.

Common credit card benefits and protections

The best credit cards extend beyond rewards to offer valuable benefits and protections that help us differentiate between similar products.

Travel benefits: Premium cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve^® include benefits like trip cancellation insurance, trip delay reimbursement, lost luggage coverage, and rental car insurance. Many also provide airport lounge access, delivering substantial value to frequent travelers.

Purchase protections: Extended warranty protection adds coverage beyond manufacturer warranties, while purchase protection covers theft or damage for a limited period after buying items. Many cards include these protections as standard features.

Fraud protections: Federal law limits cardholder liability for unauthorized charges to $50, though most issuers offer zero liability policies. These protections helped us evaluate which companies provided the strongest security features across all card types, from secured cards to premium options.

Cell phone protection: Some cards offer cell phone insurance when consumers pay their monthly bill with the card, covering damage or theft up to certain limits.

Types of reward redemption options

How issuers structure redemptions significantly impacts the actual value cardholders receive from their rewards.

Statement credits and direct deposits apply rewards directly against account balances or deposit cash into bank accounts. These options offer straightforward value with 10,000 points equaling $100 in statement credits.

Travel portals operated by issuers allow points to gain enhanced value. Some cards, like the Chase Sapphire Preferred^® Card, earn additional value when redeemed through the issuer's travel portal. However, portal prices may exceed third-party booking sites.

Transfer partners on premium cards create the highest potential value but require the most expertise. Many premium cards allow you to transfer points to airline and hotel loyalty programs. Points might be worth significantly more when transferred strategically to partners.

Cash back options on many cards offer the simplest redemption, with no complexity around point values or transfer ratios.