Arby’s and McDonald’s Both Drop Pumpkin Pie Treats - Which Is Worth Your Money?

As the air turns crisp and the leaves start to change, fast food chains are gearing up for the fall season with their latest seasonal releases. This year, Arby’s and McDonald’s are leading the charge with new pumpkin-themed treats that promise to capture the essence of autumn. 

From Arby’s latest Pumpkin Pie Turnover to the return of McDonald’s beloved Pumpkin and Creme Pie, here’s what you need to know about these delicious fall offerings and what they might mean for your wallet.

Arby’s adds a little extra flavor to the fall season with its latest menu item: the Pumpkin Pie Turnover. This new treat combines Arby’s signature flaky turnover pastry with a creamy, spiced pumpkin filling topped with a drizzle of sweet icing glaze. The turnover’s crispy layers provide a delightful contrast to the rich pumpkin filling, making it a simple yet elegant seasonal addition.

Available for a limited time starting Sept. 30 at participating locations, the Pumpkin Pie Turnover is the perfect way to celebrate the arrival of fall.

Not to be outdone, McDonald’s is bringing back a fan-favorite fall dessert: the Pumpkin and Creme Pie. First launched in 2011, this seasonal pie features a spiced pumpkin filling paired with a sweet cream filling, all encased in McDonald’s signature flaky crust. Known for its perfect blend of fall flavors, the Pumpkin and Creme Pie has become a beloved staple among the chain's seasonal offerings.

Availability may vary as the Pumpkin and Creme Pie has not been rolled out nationwide yet, so fans eager to try this autumn delight should check their McDonald’s app to see if it’s available in their area. 

While exact pricing for Arby’s Pumpkin Pie Turnover hasn’t been disclosed, their classic Apple Turnover costs $1.99, and it’s expected to align with other seasonal pastries, likely in the $2–$3 range. 

McDonald’s classic Apple Pie will run you $1.29 and the Pumpkin and Creme Pie has traditionally been priced similarly, so we expect the treats to be relatively affordable options for fall indulgence.

The real value might come down to availability and accessibility. With McDonald’s seasonal pie not yet available nationwide, some fans might have to wait or travel to get their fix. Meanwhile, Arby’s is expected to have the Pumpkin Pie Turnover widely available at participating locations starting at the end of September.

This fall, Arby’s and McDonald’s are both vying for your taste buds with pumpkin-inspired treats. Depending on your location, availability might be the deciding factor, but both options promise to deliver the warm, comforting flavors of the season.

Whether you’re a die-hard McDonald’s fan or looking to try something new at Arby’s, this fall is shaping up to be a delicious season for pumpkin lovers everywhere. So, grab your best cash back credit card and indulge in these limited-time treats while you can.