How Much is Car Insurance for a 16-Year-Old? How to Get Lower Premiums

There’s no bigger milestone in the teen years than getting a driver’s license, but the excitement can quickly wear off when you learn the cost of the premiums.

Car insurance companies base their premiums on risk and the lack of experience new drivers have is enough for most companies to hike up the rates. Fortunately, there are a few things you can do to lower the cost of car insurance for a 16 year old.

How much does car insurance for a 16-year-old cost?

The exact cost of car insurance for your 16-year-old varies based on your location, their gender, the make/model of the vehicle, and if your teen is on the policy with you or by themselves.

To give you an idea of how much you may have to pay for an individual policy for a 16-year-old male or female, here’s a quick summary from two major insurers based on quotes received in August 2024.

Average car insurance cost for 16-year-old males and females

For the quotes below, drivers were newly licensed 16-year-olds living in Delray Beach, Florida, with a clean driving record. They drove a two-wheel-drive 2020 Mazda CX-5 Sport. These quotes are for teenage drivers on their own policies.

Full coverage car insurance quotes had limits of 10/20/10 with $500 deductibles for comprehensive coverage and collision coverage. The 10/20/10 numbers represent coverage limits of $10,000 for bodily injury coverage for one person, $20,000 for bodily injury coverage for all people, and $10,000 in property damage liability coverage.

Why car insurance for teenagers is so expensive

Overall, teenagers can be riskier to insure than other groups. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) says, “Teen drivers have a higher rate of fatal crashes, mainly because of their immaturity, lack of skills, and lack of experience. They speed, they make mistakes, and they get distracted easily.”

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) also states that fatal crashes are about three times as likely for 16- and 17-year-olds than drivers ages 20 and older. With these jarring statistics, it’s easy to see why car insurance is typically so expensive for teenagers.

What factors impact the cost?

Because teen drivers don’t have a driving history, car insurers base their premiums on several other factors. They mostly use data from other 16-year-old drivers in similar circumstances to price the policies.

Here’s what affects most car insurance premiums for teens.

Gender

Like it or not, gender impacts car insurance costs. This is likely due to information from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety showing that male drivers aged 16 to 19 have an almost two times higher fatal passenger motor vehicle crash rate per mile driven than female drivers in the same age group.

Car accidents cause insurance companies money, and fatal accidents are often even more expensive due to the nature of the incident. Each car insurance company has different rates for male vs female teens, but it’s not unusual to see rates as much as 20% higher for males.

Teen policy vs. parent policy

There are several reasons to consider adding your teen to your policy versus purchasing one in their name.

• Secondary driver: When you add your teen to your policy, they become a secondary driver, especially if you have more drivers than cars. A secondary driver is less risky than a primary driver because ultimately, they drive less frequently.
• Lower rates: Because you’ve established a driving history already, your teen can piggyback off the history and secure lower rates. An individual policy doesn’t offer that option since there’s no driving history for a new driver.
• Discounts: You may be eligible for more discounts than your teen would on his/her own. For example, you may get bundled or multi-vehicle discounts.

Location

Your location plays an important role in your teen driver’s insurance rates, for several reasons:

• State laws: Each state has different minimum insurance requirement laws. The more insurance you need, the higher the premiums.
• Type of area: Where your teen will be driving affects their insurance premiums. For example, congested cities are often much more expensive than rural towns.

Coverage level

Beyond the state’s minimum requirements, you have options regarding how much coverage you purchase for your teen. Of course, the higher the coverage amount, the higher the cost, but you must look at the big picture.

Let’s say for example you purchase only the state minimum coverage of $25,000 liability for bodily injury/property damage and your teen causes an accident that incurs $50,000 in medical bills. The victims could sue you for the difference, so carrying adequate coverage likely makes more sense as it will cost much less than the damages caused to another person or property.

Vehicle type

The make and model of the vehicle your teen drives will affect the premiums. Every insurance company has different rates for different vehicles. Before buying a car for your teen, I recommend contacting a couple of insurance companies to find out the estimated premiums first.

Newer cars may have lower premiums because of the advanced technology and newer safety features, but you don’t know until you get a quote. How a car drives and protects its occupants in a crash might also impact rates. For example, minivans aren’t known for excellent acceleration, but they generally protect their occupants fairly well. Similarly, a Honda Civic is an economical sedan designed to get people around town affordably. These factors could potentially result in lower rates than insuring a performance-oriented, convertible sports car, such as a Corvette or a BMW.

Also, keep in mind that the more expensive a car is, the more an insurance company may have to pay out in an accident, assuming you have enough coverage. If your family owns multiple cars, it’s a good idea for your teen to drive the least expensive one.

How to save money on your teen’s car insurance

Fortunately there are several ways to save money on car insurance for your teenager. In addition to adding your teen to your policy, you might lower costs by increasing the deductibles on the car insurance plan. You will likely have to pay more money out of pocket after an accident if you do this, though, so make sure you can cover the car insurance deductible cost you choose.

Here are some additional ways to save money on teen car insurance.

Good grades

Many insurance companies reward students who maintain good grades. These students are generally seen as more responsible at school and as drivers. Each car insurance company might have its own definition of a good student, but many seem to use the B average (3.0 GPA) or better as a benchmark.

Driver education

Some insurance companies offer discounts if teens take additional courses besides the basic driver’s ed course. For example, they may lower the rate if your child takes a defensive driving course, or another course they offer to reduce the risk of an accident. For instance, Allstate allows you to take the teenSMART driver education program as one of three options to qualify for a discount.

Student away at school

When a student attends school away from home and doesn’t bring a car, insurance companies may offer a discount because they aren’t driving the vehicle. Check with your insurance company regarding the number of miles away the school must be to qualify.

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

By clicking the button below I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Check Rates

FAQs

Getting car insurance for teenagers can feel overwhelming. Here are answers to some frequently asked questions.

The bottom line

Car insurance for 16-year-olds isn’t cheap. While you probably want the best coverage for your new driver, you must take into account the overall cost. Adding your teen to your policy is your best bet at keeping rates down, while also shopping around for the best car insurance companies for teen drivers. I encourage you to ask for any and all discounts, including classes your child can take to keep the rates low.

Save On Your Auto Insurance

• You could save up to $600 with some companies
• Compare dozens of providers in under 5 minutes
• Fast, free and easy way to shop for insurance
• Quickly find the perfect rate for you

Get a quote now