The Midwest Is Home to 3 of the Top 5 Most Competitive Rental Markets of 2023 (Omaha, Really?)

Unveiling the most competitive rental markets of 2023 brings some surprises
Updated July 18, 2024
Fact checked

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

As the curtain falls on 2023, the rental landscape in the United States reveals intriguing patterns of competition, with the Northeast and Midwest claiming their stakes in the top tiers. 

A recent study delved into the details of the most competitive rental markets, analyzing factors such as vacant days, occupancy rates, and lease renewals. The results not only highlight the regions vying for supremacy but also prompt a reflection on the implications of living in a fiercely competitive rental market.

If you’re over 50, take advantage of massive discounts and financial resources

Over 50? Join AARP today — because if you’re not a member you could be missing out on huge perks. When you start your membership today, you can get discounts on things like travel, meal deliveries, eyeglasses, prescriptions that aren’t covered by insurance and more.

How to become a member today:

  • Go here, select your free gift, and click “Join Today”
  • Create your account (important!) by answering a few simple questions
  • Start enjoying your discounts and perks!

Important: Start your membership by creating an account here and filling in all of the information (Do not skip this step!) Doing so will allow you to take up 25% off your AARP membership, making it just $12 per year with auto-renewal.

Become an AARP member now

Northeast: A melting pot of challenges and opportunities

The Northeast, boasting economic powerhouses like New York, Boston, and Philadelphia, claims its stake in the competitive rental arena. However, the dynamics in this region are nuanced. While cities like Suburban Philadelphia and Brooklyn showcase high levels of competitiveness, Manhattan lags, perhaps due to its concentration of upscale properties.

The appeal of the Northeast lies in its diversified economy and high employment rates, attracting a diverse population seeking big-city amenities. However, the undersupply of housing, especially in areas like Suburban Philadelphia, has led to fierce competition, with 11 prospective renters vying for each available unit.

Midwest reigns supreme

In a surprising turn of events, the Midwest emerges as the unrivaled champion of rental markets in 2023. According to the study, three of its markets are in the top five nationwide, and they had the most in the top 10 with 1/3 of the cities being within the region the region defies the overall trend of softening rental competitiveness in most of the country. 

The secret behind the Midwest's dominance lies in its economic revival, driven by initiatives like the Rise of the Rest fund, which fosters entrepreneurship beyond coastal hubs. The appeal of spacious living, tailored-for-remote work, and immediate access to the great outdoors attract renters in droves.

Cities like Milwaukee, Grand Rapids, and Omaha have become magnets for those seeking more affordable living and better career opportunities. However, the success story is not without its challenges. The increased demand has led to heightened competition, making it challenging for apartment seekers to secure a spot in these thriving Midwest markets.

Miami: A tropical hotspot of rental competition

Meanwhile, with its sizzling tech scene and business-friendly climate, Miami takes the crown as the hottest rental market in the nation. The city's allure extends beyond its sun-soaked beaches, drawing innovators and entrepreneurs globally. The lack of income tax sweetens the deal, making it an attractive prospect for locals and newcomers. The robust demand for rentals in Miami has created a cutthroat environment, with an astonishing 22 applicants for every vacant rental.

Yet, the surge in new apartment constructions has not been sufficient to meet the voracious appetite for housing, further intensifying the competition. The scenario in Miami encapsulates the paradox of desirability and scarcity as the city grapples with the challenges of catering to an influx of new residents.

Navigating the landscape of competitive rentals

Living in a competitive rental market comes with its set of pros and cons, both for renters and homeowners. The Midwest's competitive rental landscape reflects economic vibrancy but poses challenges for those searching for housing. On the flip side, Miami's allure is undeniable, but the cutthroat competition makes securing a rental a daunting task, and finding ways to pay your high rent could be difficult in the area.

The abundance of options in a competitive market can be a double-edged sword for renters. While it provides a range of choices, the intense competition may drive up prices and limit the time available for decision-making. Lease renewals become a strategic move, with many opting to stay put in the face of challenging apartment hunts.

On the other hand, homeowners may find the competitive rental market a boon. The demand for rentals often translates to increased property values, giving homeowners a lucrative investment opportunity. However, it also poses a dilemma for those contemplating a shift from renting to homeownership, as the fiercely contested market makes buying a property equally challenging.

Bottom line

As we bid adieu to 2023, the rental market landscape reflects a tapestry of competition and opportunity. The Midwest, Miami, and the Northeast are the focal points of this intricate weave. Whether navigating the challenges of the Midwest's bustling economy or grappling with the scarcity in the Northeast, both renters and homeowners find themselves at the crossroads of choice and competition. 

As we enter a new year, the rental market remains a dynamic arena shaped by economic forces, demographic shifts, and the ever-evolving preferences of those seeking a place to call home.

Choice Home Warranty Benefits

  • First month free
  • Protection for unexpected expense
  • 24/7 claims hotline
  • Network of over 15,000 technicians

Author Details

Georgina Tzanetos Georgina Tzanetos is a former financial advisor who has been active in financial media for the past six years. She holds a master's in political economy from NYU, where she studied distressed labor markets.