9 Precious Moments Figurines That Are Actually Worth Hundreds

Precious Moments is a collection of teardrop-eyed figurines launched in 1978 to convey biblical messages and remains popular today. They have new arrivals launching frequently, with the latest additions scheduled for August 2025.

New figurines cost between $35 and $150, depending on their exclusivity. But older, collectible Precious Moments editions could be worth even more and be a great way to make cash on the side.

Take a look at this list of valuable Precious Moments figurines and see which you have in your collection.

Editor's note: Values for figurines were taken from eBay.

Market value: $60

The original 1978 version of this figurine (one of the Original 21) shows a shepherd and an angel heralding the birth of Jesus. Despite their age, many of the Original 21 only sell for $15-$30. However, this adorable scene can fetch between up to $119 at online auctions.

Check for the catalog number E-2012, as this indicates that it's part of the original run of figurines.

Market value: $100

Most of the Original 21 have a faith-based message, and this sweet sculpture shows a figure gazing adoringly at a baby in a manger. You should look for the original Jonathan and David mark on the base, which were the pen names of creators, Sam Butcher and business partner Bill Biel.

The "Come Let Us Adore Him" figurine can sell for between $75 and $200 in good condition.

Market value: $300

A figurine is retired when the "mold" is officially broken, meaning it can no longer be produced. This is also what makes these models that much more valuable. "God Loveth a Cheerful Giver," another one of the Original 21 from 1978, depicts a little girl with a barrow of puppies. It was inspired by artist Sam Butcher's own daughter.

In good condition, this figurine fetches between $200 and $400. Look for a "Jonathan and David" mark, which shows it's a genuine early edition.

Market value: $800

Musical Precious Moments pieces are often popular due to their novelty factor. This Disney collaboration celebrates Cinderella in her ball finery, playing the song "A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes."

The base should have a sticker showing the date 2013 and the Disney Showcase emblem. It's extremely rare, with only 1,500 pieces made worldwide. Even with a small scratch, it's not uncommon to see listings for this item ranging up to $1,000.

Market value: $500

Of the Original 21, "Love One Another" is the only one still in production. It shows a boy and a girl sitting back-to-back on a tree stump, celebrating friendship.

Originals with the Jonathan and David mark or a Sam Butcher signature can sell for $500 or more. Marks like the Holy Trinity Triangle weren't added until 1981, so if you see a mark like this, it's a newer model.

Market value: $900

Another of the Original 21, this statuette has been relaunched a few times over the years. There's both a girl and a boy edition, with the girl clutching a bunny and the boy squeezing a teddy bear.

Recent sales of this model have ranged from $149 to $900, though the higher price was for a signed, limited-edition variant.

Market value: $900

Some Precious Moments designs were exclusive to the Precious Moments Chapel in Carthage, MO. "We Would See Jesus" is one such item, featuring three kings riding a camel with teddies on its back.

Launched in 2021, this piece should have an official "Precious Moments by Enesco" stamp on the base and a number between 1 and 1,500. In good condition, it can be worth between $400 and $1,200.

Market value: $375

This Hawaiian-inspired creation depicts a girl dancing in a hula skirt, wearing a lei around her neck, as if she's at a traditional luau. The name means "Till we meet again," and the piece was produced as part of the 2005 Anniversary Hawaiian Collection.

Genuine pieces will have the name and date on the base. Because it's limited, this piece can be worth a lot of money. A signed version can fetch anything from $375 to $2,999.

Market value: up to $2,999

Collaborations with renowned brands are often highly sought after. The Disney collection, in particular, is very popular. "True Love Conquers All "is a cute, musical piece from 2021, and only 500 were made.

While some of these cute figurines sell for around $100, fans who missed out on buying the original Precious Moments figurine are willing to pay up to $2,999 to complete their Disney collection.

These are some of the most expensive Precious Moments figurines available, but condition is a key factor. Keeping your collectibles safe and in good condition helps maintain their value, so you can sell them and get ahead financially. Check for yearly production marks, which are a good indicator of whether your piece is genuine.

Whether you're collecting for fun or hoping to earn extra money, estate sales, thrift stores, and auctions are great places to hunt for hidden gems. Even Facebook Marketplace can surprise you: Someone once snagged eight of the Original 21 for just $5 each!