16 Fan-Favorite Trader Joe's Pantry Items This September

Pack your pantry without breaking the bank. You can stock up and save on groceries at Trader Joe’s this fall. 

From gourmet goodies to breakfast staples, these bargain buys will keep your September shopping budget in check. And unlike other grocery stores, you won’t need to join a loyalty program or download e-coupons to an app just to get a deal.

Editor’s note: Prices are subject to change and may vary by location.

Price: $2.99

Pass on plain pasta. This organic artisan option is an affordable alternative to the spaghetti you always eat. Made with 100 percent organic durum wheat semolina sourced from farms in the Puglia region of Italy, this gourmet product is a steal for under $3.

Price: $3.99

Make a restaurant-quality meal for a fraction of the price. Instead of takeout, try this pink sauce on your favorite pasta. The creamy blend of milk, cheese, onion, garlic, oregano, and basil is a savory selection. Mix the silky sauce with ground beef, top grilled chicken, or layer it into lasagna.

Price: $2.99

This seasonal hot sauce is a new autumn item that won’t stay on store shelves long. The limited-time buy has a fiery taste with a touch of sweetness. In-the-know shoppers rave about this sweet potato-habanero blend. Ocular-sorcerer praised the taste on Reddit, “Bought this today and used half the bottle! I love hot sauce, and this might be my new favorite for the season.”

Price: $2.99

It’s that time of year again. Pumpkin spice has made its way to store aisles ― and this fan favorite is back for a limited time. Cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger give Trader Joe’s pumpkin bagels a pie-like flavor that you will crave. Toast one and top it with pumpkin cream cheese, apple butter, plain butter, or honey.

Compare the $2.99 price tag for this six-pack to $4.79 for Thomas’ Pumpkin Spice Bagels at Krogers.

Price: $3.99

Start your day in a sweet way with this peanut butter and chocolate granola. The decadent blend of sweet and salty flavors is pure perfection. Mix the rolled oat blend with Greek yogurt and fresh fruit, or add nuts to make trail mix.

Price: $2.99

Cereal prices are skyrocketing. But not at Trader Joe’s. Get a 12.2-ounce box of Cinnamon Toast Crunch dupe for $2.99. The brand-name version costs $3.48 at Walmart.

Price: $2.79

This is more than basic mustard. Trader Joe’s aioli garlic sauce is creamy, tangy, and has just the right zesty zip. Add this gourmet condiment to an end-of-the-season barbecue buffet, use it as a party dip, or smother grilled chicken with the savory sauce.

Price: $2.49

For less than $2.50, this 16-ounce container of unsalted crunchy peanut butter is a steal of a deal. The same size jar of Jif costs $3.19 at Target. And don’t worry about extra unnecessary ingredients in Trader Joe’s bargain-priced nut butter. It's free of binders and sweeteners.

Price: $3.99

Not a fan of hazelnut spread? This cocoa almond butter is an affordable alternative if you prefer something sweeter. Redditor Grossmalone0 raved about this fan favorite, writing, “We love Nutella, but I LOVE the Trader Joe’s cocoa almond spread WAY more than the name brand product.”

Price: $9.99

Skip the pricey barista blends and try this new limited-time coffee from Trader Joe’s. The dark roast blend has a semi-sweet, almost chocolatey flavor that pairs well with pancakes, waffles, or pastries.

Price: $1.99

Fans of Trader Joe’s original pizza sauce are in for a treat. The retailer recently reintroduced an updated version of this classic. Skip delivery and add this tomato-packed pick to a homemade pizza, or use the sauce to make your own calzone.

Price: $4.99

This classic chicken broth soup is back on store shelves. Now that there’s a chill in the air, you’re ready to feast on warm comfort food. Tiny meatballs, kale, carrots, onions, pasta pearls, and a touch of Parm give this foodie find a taste that rivals any restaurant’s recipe.

Price: $3.99

No gluten? No problem. You don’t have to scour store shelves for a gluten-free pancake/waffle mix. You’ll get 18 ounces of ready-to-use mix in this Trader Joe’s bargain buy. And bonus, you can use this pantry pick for more than just pancakes and waffles. Reddit user Chiefduke suggests, “Gluten free fish fritters using Trader Joe’s Gluten Free Buttermilk pancake and waffle mix.”

Price: $4.99

Maple syrup is a fall staple that could cost more than you want to spend. Whole Foods Market sells Grade A pure Vermont maple syrup for $8.99. But at Trader Joe’s, you can get an 8-ounce bottle of a slightly lighter amber option for $4.99.

Price: $9.99

You don’t have to overspend just to get high-quality EVOO. Trader Joe’s Sicilian Selezione Extra Virgin Olive Oil is inexpensive for under $10. Made from three types of olives, this bottled blend has a distinctively decadent, peppery flavor.

Price: $4.99

Don’t forget about your canine companion. Snag a few of these limited buys when you stock up on pantry products. Fall flavors have found their way into the pet food aisle. This seasonal selection of maple and bacon-flavored bites is a bargain for less than $5. Your pup will thank you.

Trader Joe’s has the top fall foodie finds at budget-friendly prices. You can score unbeatable savings on must-have pantry products right now.

Get more for your money with the top rewards credit cards. Earn travel points, cash back, and more on eligible grocery purchases this September.