15 of Warren Buffett’s Most Enduring Financial Controversies and Scandals

Warren Buffett is known worldwide as one of the most successful investors in history, earning his nickname "The Oracle of Omaha." Over the decades, Buffett has built a reputation for financial fitness and philanthropy, becoming a trusted voice in the investing world. Yet, as with anyone operating at the top of their field, he hasn't avoided controversy.

Whether tied to his investment strategies, corporate acquisitions, or ethics, Buffett has faced scrutiny for decisions that have sparked public debate. Here are 15 financial controversies that continue to linger around Warren Buffett's legacy.

In 1974, Buffett and his longtime partner Charlie Munger were embroiled in a controversy over the acquisition of Wesco Financial Corporation.

They were accused of interfering with another company's attempt to acquire Wesco, allegedly in an effort to secure their own stake in the business. The SEC investigated, and shareholders received a $115,000 payout as compensation — a rare blemish on Buffett's investment record.

Buffett faced antitrust charges after acquiring the Buffalo Evening News. He was accused of breaking a "gentlemen's agreement" with competitors, which led to legal proceedings. Although Buffett prevailed, the case highlighted the challenges of consolidating media companies and the ethical dilemmas tied to such deals.

A ProPublica report in 2023 accused Buffett of actions that seemed at odds with his public statements on trading ethics.

Questions were raised about Buffett's personal trading activities connected to some of his companies, prompting people to wonder whether Buffett consistently practices what he preaches regarding fairness and transparency.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings

Compare car insurance rates in Ohio

See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes

Check Rates

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

During the 2008 financial crisis, Warren Buffett made headlines by investing $5 billion in Goldman Sachs preferred stock, signaling confidence in the U.S. financial system. When Goldman redeemed the shares in 2011, Berkshire Hathaway profited $3.7 billion.

However, Buffett's ties to Goldman, a company criticized as a symbol of financial greed, sparked debates about the ethical implications of the investment.

As a major shareholder of Coca-Cola, Buffett came under fire in 2014 when the company proposed an executive compensation plan that critics described as excessive. While Buffett abstained from voting, his decision not to oppose the plan outright drew criticism from those who expected him to take a stand against corporate greed.

Buffett has often been criticized for Berkshire Hathaway's investments in fossil fuel companies. Despite his public acknowledgment on climate change, his continued support for oil and gas ventures has sparked debates about whether his actions align with his words on environmental responsibility.

Buffett's investment in Kraft Heinz took a hit when the company faced an accounting scandal in 2019. The SEC investigated irregularities in its financial reporting, leading to restatements of earnings.

While Buffett wasn't directly implicated, the controversy raised questions about his oversight of portfolio companies.

Berkshire Hathaway held a 10% stake in Wells Fargo starting in 1989, but the relationship soured after the bank's 2016 scandal. Wells Fargo faced a $185 million fine for unethical practices, including opening fraudulent bank accounts and cross-selling products and services to customers.

Buffett condemned the bank's initial attempts to downplay the revelations. In the end, Wells Fargo paid $3 billion to settle investigations, and Berkshire Hathaway divested nearly all its shares by 2021 and completed the sale in 2022.

In the early 1990s, Buffett was pulled into the Salomon Brothers bond trading scandal. As a major shareholder, he stepped in to run and stabilize the company after traders were caught submitting false bids to the U.S. Treasury.

While his leadership helped salvage the firm, the scandal remains a notable blemish on Berkshire Hathaway's history.

Buffett has faced criticism for the lack of emphasis on diversity within Berkshire Hathaway's leadership ranks.

Buffet's stance is that he always selects board members based on relevant business experience, competence, shareholder value, and special interest in Berkshire Hathaway. Diversity isn't known to be a key factor when selecting leadership at the company.

In 2006, Berkshire Hathaway's subsidiary General Reinsurance Corporation faced serious accusations of collaborating with AIG in a scheme involving finite reinsurance. The claim was that this practice didn't actually involve insurance, but that it was instead a financial tactic to make AIG's financial reports look better by avoiding risk transfer.

The fallout led to General Reinsurance settling with AIG shareholders for $60.5 million, paying $19.5 million to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service Consumer Fraud Fund, and making another $12.2 million in payments to resolve SEC charges.

Buffett's significant stake in Moody's came under scrutiny after the 2008 financial crisis. As a credit rating agency, Moody's was accused of contributing to the crisis by giving overly favorable ratings to risky mortgage-backed securities.

Buffett said very little about his investment in the company, and some believe that he downplayed the company's role in the meltdown.

Buffett has faced occasional accusations of insider trading, with critics questioning whether his access to non-public information has given him an unfair advantage in certain deals. Although no legal actions have stuck, the whispers persist as part of his controversial legacy.

NetJets, a Berkshire Hathaway subsidiary known for its luxury private jet services, has faced a series of legal battles over the years.

In one high-profile case, NetJets filed a defamation lawsuit against its pilots' union, accusing it of spreading false claims about the company's business practices. This controversy and others highlight the ongoing tensions within one of Buffett's most exclusive investments.

Some of Berkshire Hathaway's acquisitions and business practices have been labeled monopolistic by critics, who argue that the conglomerate's dominance in certain sectors stifles competition.

While Buffett defends his business model as a collection of independently run companies, the accusations linger.

Warren Buffett's long career has been defined by financial success and public admiration, but even "The Oracle of Omaha" has not escaped controversy. From corporate acquisitions to ethical debates, these scandals highlight the complexities of navigating power and influence in the financial world.

For readers, these stories offer a chance to reflect on the lessons, and risks, inherent in investing, like how do you balance opportunity with ethics as you seek to avoid surprising financial mistakes and set yourself up for a bright financial future?