If you’re new to investing, one of the easiest ways to start is to use a robo-advisor. Two of the best robo-advisors out there are Wealthfront and Betterment. Each has its own benefits and drawbacks, and one might work better for you than the other.
In this Wealthfront vs. Betterment overview, we’ll look at the basics of each, as well as provide information that can help you make the best choice for your long-term goals.
Wealthfront vs. Betterment
|Management fees||.25%||.15%, .25%. .30%, or .40%, based on your plan and balance|
|Asset classes||Exchange-traded funds (portfolios made up of U.S. and international stocks and bonds)||Exchange-traded funds (portfolios made up of U.S. and international stocks and bonds)|
|Account types available||
|Best for...||Those interested in a low management fee, and who want access to a college savings plan.||Those most interested in starting no matter their financial circumstance, and who want to put their long-term goals on autopilot.|
What is Wealthfront?
Wealthfront is a robo-advisor that allows you to start investing in the stock market with a minimum deposit of $500. After answering a few initial questions, Wealthfront will put together a portfolio for you, based on your risk tolerance and other factors. Wealthfront focuses on using stocks and bonds to create a portfolio, though it also offers exposure to real estate and natural resources. All you have to do is contribute money to your account, and Wealthfront will automatically allocate it according to your profile and goals.
In addition to offering retirement accounts and taxable investment accounts, Wealthfront is a little different in that you can also open a 529 account. This allows you to use a tax-advantaged account to help save for a child’s college education.
You aren’t limited to investment products, though. Wealthfront also offers access to banking products, including the Wealthfront Cash Account, an FDIC-insured product that allows you to save and spend using a debit card. Plus, you get access to a portfolio line of credit, which provides you with a low-interest way to borrow based on the size of your portfolio.
Finally, it’s possible to get planning help for specific goals by using Path, an advice engine designed to help you map out a way to achieve your goals.
Pros of Wealthfront
- Low expense ratios for ETFs
- One low annual fee for account management
- Tax-loss harvesting
- 529 account
Cons of Wealthfront
- Minimum of $500 required
- No discount for a large balance
- Focuses on Path, rather than human planners
What is Betterment?
Like Wealthfront, Betterment is a robo-advisor. Using principles of modern portfolio theory, Betterment will build you a portfolio based on your answers to questions designed to help determine your risk tolerance and goals. It’s possible to open different types of accounts to help you work toward various goals, and there is no minimum investment required to get started.
Betterment has also introduced different investment strategies, including a socially responsible investing strategy. If you have a specific goal, you can choose one of these strategies to better align with your values.
Betterment provides you with banking products as well, including FDIC-insured cash accounts. There’s even a high-yield cash reserve account and a checking account that can be accessed using a debit card. Projection tools allow you to see whether you’re on track with saving for short-term goals and longer-term ones.
In addition, Betterment allows you to easily roll over an existing 401(k) into an IRA. Plus, you can connect external accounts so you can see where you stand and incorporate them into your planning. Betterment also has a two-way sweep feature you can activate to move excess money from your primary checking into your Betterment cash account, and also move money from your Betterment cash account into your checking account when it drops below a certain level.
You get access to humans who can help you work through specific goals, whether you're saving for college or retirement planning. These services cost extra money, but it’s easy to schedule time with a potential human financial advisor using an online interface. These planning tools are offered for a flat fee.
Pros of Betterment
- No minimum to invest
- Goal-based tools to help you accomplish your objectives
- Access to human advisors for financial planning help
- Discount for the highest balances
Cons of Betterment
- Limited investment options
- Management fee can be as high as .40%
- No custodial or college savings accounts
3 important differences between Wealthfront and Betterment
When looking at Wealthfront vs. Betterment — or comparing any of the best investment apps — it’s important to understand the differences. By looking at the different features, you can determine which is most likely to meet your particular needs.
Both Wealthfront and Betterment are robo-advisors that come with features such as tax-loss harvesting and automatic rebalancing. Both of these robo-advisors help you minimize the taxes you pay when making adjustments to your plan, as well as rebalance when needed. However, there are some different features to be aware of.
First, Wealthfront offers a 529 plan. This is not something a lot of robo-advisors offer, and it sets Wealthfront apart. Betterment doesn’t offer a 529 plan choice, so if you want to save for college, Betterment won’t be much help.
On the other hand, Betterment offers human help with specific financial planning goals. You can sign up — for a flat fee — to get personalized guidance from a human with Betterment. Wealthfront instead focuses on the use of Path, its advice engine is designed to help you work through these planning issues on your own. Depending on your situation, you might like the idea of more access to human advice. Indeed, once your balance reaches $100,000, you can decide to pay a higher management fee of .40% and get access to a human wealth advisor on a more regular basis through Betterment.
Wealthfront, however, offers a portfolio line of credit, which allows you to borrow money at a lower rate when you meet certain requirements. Your line of credit is secured by the investments in your portfolio, so it’s possible to get a competitive rate without the need for a high credit score.
When looking at Wealthfront vs. Betterment, fees can make a difference. Wealthfront charges only .25% annually, no matter the size of your account.
Betterment, on the other hand, takes a tiered approach to fees. For many accounts, the advisory fee is .25%. However, once your Betterment account balance reaches $100,000, you can choose to opt for more tailored advice and help by paying a higher management fee of .40%. Betterment also offers a discount for very high balances of $2 million or more. For those higher balances, it’s possible to pay .15% for a basic account and .30% if you want more personalized advice and access to planners.
3. Expense ratios
An expense ratio is a fee charged by a fund. Because both Wealthfront and Betterment use ETFs, expense ratios are part of the cost of using these services. An expense ratio is charged on top of the management fee.
In general, Wealthfront offers funds with fees of between .06% and .13%. Betterment also uses funds with fairly low fees. The ETFs commonly used by Betterment have an average expense ratio of .08%. However, individual ETFs might have ratios that are higher or lower than that number.
Wealthfront vs. Betterment: which investment app should you choose?
The investment app you choose should depend on your individual needs and circumstances. Both Wealthfront and Betterment have their advantages and disadvantages, so carefully consider these before you make your decision.
If you’d like to use a robo-advisor to help plan for college, and save using a 529, Wealthfront can be a good choice. Additionally, if you want access to a line of credit based on your portfolio, rather than relying on debt from a bank or credit card, Wealthfront can provide you with an alternative way to access capital.
On the other hand, Betterment might work better if you want access to a basic account and goals-based tools supported by the ability to talk to a human financial planner. Betterment offers a variety of tools designed to support goals-based planning, and it’s possible to easily switch your money between accounts. Additionally, Betterment can work well for beginners who don’t have a lot of money to invest initially. With no minimum investment requirement, Betterment is ideal for those who don’t have $500 to get started.
FAQs about Wealthfront vs. Betterment
Is Wealthfront better than Betterment?
As with any app or financial tool, it depends on your situation. If you want a 529 account and access to a portfolio line of credit, Wealthfront can be better. However, if you don’t have $500 to start investing, Betterment might be the better choice for you.
Can you lose money with Wealthfront?
It’s possible to lose money any time you invest. If the market drops, and you withdraw money from your account while investments are trading at a loss, you can lose money. However, Wealthfront is SPIC insured and you’re protected if Wealthfront goes out of business.
Is Betterment good for beginners?
Betterment can be good for beginners because it allows you to start investing with a small amount. You can have your money automatically invested in a portfolio based on your risk tolerance without the need to know a lot about stock picking.
Is Wealthfront good for beginners?
If you have at least $500 to start investing, Wealthfront can be worth it. You don’t need to know a lot about stock picking to get started.
Are Wealthfront fees worth it?
Wealthfront charges a flat .25% management fee. This fee is in line with other robo-advisors and can be worth it if you’re hoping to have someone else manage your investment portfolio for you.
The bottom line on Betterment vs. Wealthfront
If you’re looking to start investing, or even just turn your portfolio management over to someone else, both Wealthfront and Betterment can be good choices. Both investment apps make use of the principles of modern portfolio theory and use low-cost ETFs to create portfolios designed to help you reach your long-term goals.
There are some differences in some of the accounts and features offered by Wealthfront vs. Betterment, though. As a result, it’s important to carefully consider the features you’re likely to use and the types of accounts you want to open. You might find other choices, such as Robinhood or Stash, that could work even better for you.