Is Alaska Airlines Being Cheap By Only Offering Passengers $1,500 for Their Trauma?

In the wake of a mid-flight nightmare aboard Alaska Airlines Flight 1282, where a door plug gave way at 16,000 feet, the question lingers in the air: what price tag can you assign to human trauma? As passengers grapple with the aftermath of a compensation offer that seems tiny, given the magnitude of their ordeal — a mere $1,500 — the incident prompts a conversation about how much companies truly value their customers.

What happened at the Alaska Airlines event?

A door “plug” toward the end of the plane became loose and fell into the sky shortly after takeoff during the Alaska Airlines flight. As the door plug burst, chaos ensued, with belongings sucked into the night sky, oxygen masks dropping, and passengers fearing for their lives.

The two passengers who would have been seated directly next to the opening fatefully missed their flight. The force from the blow was strong enough to rip a young boy’s shirt off his body and other passengers had personal belongings, like the (now famous) iPhone that miraculously survived the 16,000-foot drop, sucked into the night sky.

How much is your trauma worth?

In a situation where the financial evaluation of emotional distress remains controversial, Alaska Airlines seems to have already figured it out. When facing the horror of a mid-flight emergency, passengers questioned whether they would live to tell the tale. One passenger, Emma Vu, texted her parents shortly after the plane door flew off, telling them to pray for her as she believed she was not going to make it.

Alaska Airlines has put a price tag on this stress — at just $1,500 to prepare financially for the effects of the event. The meager amount offered per passenger raises questions about the adequacy of the offer and the airlines' moral responsibility when compensating individuals for the intangible toll of trauma.

What Alaska Airlines says

Alaska Airlines' compensation package, a mix of a ticket refund and the $1,500 sum becomes a focal point of scrutiny. From the airline's perspective, this amount is presumably a response to the passengers' inconveniences and to lower financial stress.

No fatalities or major injuries were reported. However, many say the incident could have been avoided entirely, questioning whether the airline knowingly allowed the plane to fly.

Despite the Boeing 737 Max 9 that suffered the accident being brand-new, warning lights were triggered on three flights, including each of the two days before the unfortunate events of Friday night.

The lights were warnings from a cabin-pressurization system, which Alaska Airlines was aware of. Instead of grounding the plane, the airline chose not to use the plane for its route to Hawaii over the Pacific and limited its routes to on-land destinations so it could return to an airport quickly in the case of an emergency. Alaska Airlines has since declined to comment.

The AP reports that the FAA has grounded all Alaska, United, and some foreign airline Max 9s for inspection after the near-fatal incident. On Monday afternoon, United Airlines said it found loose bolts and other installation issues on door plugs inspected after the Alaska accident.

The cost of other traumatic events

To contextualize the Alaska Airlines incident, it helps to examine how other airlines have handled compensation for similar traumatic events. 

Alaska Airlines has previously been involved in controversy. In January of 2000, Flight 261 crashed into the Pacific Ocean en route from Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, to Seattle, Washington. All 88 on board were killed. The victim's families were awarded $40 million in compensation.

In 1994, American Eagle Flight 4184 suffered a fatal crash killing everyone on board after an inattentive flight crew and faulty de-icing system caused a crash during an ice storm. Over $110 million was secured for 28 families whose cases were consolidated.

The current Alaska Airlines situation is not the first for the Boeing 737 Max, which seems to have had several problems over the last few years. The airplane model suffered crashes in October 2018 and March 2019. The victims' families received a $500 million settlement.

The crashes, under Lion Air in Indonesia and Ethiopian Airlines, killed a total of 346 people. The Max was grounded globally for 20 months. The Max 9 at fault for the current Alaska fiasco, supposedly delivered with new built-in safety features, is the newer iteration of the Max.

How trauma settlements are typically calculated

The process of calculating trauma settlements is multifaceted, involving legal, psychological, and ethical considerations. Proximity to the traumatic event, individual experiences, and the challenges in arriving at a fair and sufficient compensation amount are considered.

Each passenger’s individual experience, like their proximity to the hole blown into the plane, factors into the amount of damages a jury would likely award them in a trial. That said, any passenger on the plane is entitled to file a lawsuit.

Legal professionals' recommendations

Seeking clarity amid the turmoil, passengers turn to legal professionals for guidance. Daniel Laurence, a partner at the Stritmatter Firm, emphasizes the inadequacy of the offered $1,500, asserting that passengers have a legitimate claim for emotional distress, reports the Washington Post.

Laurence also stresses that passengers affected by the accident should seek professional counseling before pursuing compensation. “My advice to every client in every personal injury situation, and particularly in situations like this, is to get well first, to the extent they can,” said Laurence, who is representing several passengers in the Horizon/Alaska Air case.

Bottom line

It’s hard to put a number on pain, but $1,500 seems insensitive given the negligence in avoiding clear warning signs in the days leading up to the accident. Luckily, there were no fatalities or injuries. Still, the harrowing experience — and seemingly unreasonable response after that — prompts a greater look into the consideration large airlines and corporations truly give their customers.

Easy-to-Earn Unlimited Rewards

Bank of America^® Travel Rewards credit card

Benefits

Card Details

• Earn 25,000 online bonus points after you make at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening - that can be a $250 statement credit toward travel purchases
• Earn 1.5 points per $1 spent on all purchases
• Longer intro APR on qualifying purchases and balance transfers
• No foreign transaction fees
• Apply Now

• Earn unlimited 1.5 points per $1 spent on all purchases, with no annual fee and no foreign transaction fees and your points don't expire as long as your account remains open.
• 25,000 online bonus points after you make at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening - that can be a $250 statement credit toward travel purchases.
• Use your card to book your trip how and where you want - you're not limited to specific websites with blackout dates or restrictions.
• Redeem points for a statement credit to pay for travel or dining purchases, such as flights, hotel stays, car and vacation rentals, baggage fees, and also at restaurants including takeout.
• 0% Intro APR for 15 billing cycles for purchases, and for any balance transfers made in the first 60 days. After the Intro APR offer ends, a Variable APR that’s currently 18.24% - 28.24% will apply. A 3% Intro balance transfer fee will apply for the first 60 days your account is open. After the Intro balance transfer fee offer ends, the fee for future balance transfers is 4%.
• If you're a Bank of America Preferred Rewards® member, you can earn 25%-75% more points on every purchase. That means instead of earning an unlimited 1.5 points for every $1, you could earn 1.87-2.62 points for every $1 you spend on purchases.
• Contactless Cards - The security of a chip card, with the convenience of a tap.
• This online only offer may not be available if you leave this page or if you visit a Bank of America financial center. You can take advantage of this offer when you apply now.

4.1

FinanceBuzz writers and editors score cards based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.

Apply Now

on Bank of America’s secure website

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

Earn 25,000 online bonus points after you make at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening - that can be a $250 statement credit toward travel purchases

Annual Fee

$0

+ -

Why we like it

• The Bank of America^® Travel Rewards credit card is great for individuals who enjoy earning rewards and traveling.

• Cardholders will enjoy the flexibility to redeem points with no blackout dates and receive a statement credit to pay for travel and dining purchases.

• Earn 1.5X points on all purchases everywhere, every time.

• Apply Now