Trader Joe's Dethroned as America's Favorite Supermarket - Did Costco Take the Top Spot? See Full List

The study reveals a new winner for shopper satisfaction.
Updated Feb. 9, 2024
Fact checked
woman using reminder on smartphone while shopping in supermarket

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

People love Trader Joe’s. The California-based supermarket makes national headlines every time it releases a new snack, fans write odes to Two Buck Chuck, and devoted shoppers line up to nosh on free samples or just browse the aisles of the beloved, indie-turned-mainstream grocer. 

They were America’s most popular grocery store for years, but not anymore. 

After three years as America’s top supermarket, two regional grocers and a warehouse store knocked the beloved chain off its perch.

Earn cash back on everyday purchases with this rare account

Want to earn cash back on your everyday purchases without using a credit card? With the Discover®️ Cashback Debit Checking account (member FDIC), you can earn 1% cash back on up to $3,000 in debit card purchases each month!1

With no credit check to apply and no monthly fees to worry about, you can earn nearly passive income on purchases you’re making anyway — up to an extra $360 a year!

This rare checking account has other great perks too, like access to your paycheck up to 2 days early with Early Pay, no minimum deposit or monthly balance requirements, over 60K fee-free ATMs, and the ability to add cash to your account at Walmart stores nationwide.

Don’t leave money on the table — it only takes minutes to apply and it won’t impact your credit score.

Apply for a Discover Cashback Checking account today

What the ACSI poll says about our favorite supermarkets

Every year the American Consumer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) polls thousands of Americans to gauge satisfaction levels in the retail space. Consumers rank department stores, online retailers, specialty stores, and grocery stores, and the ACSI collates the data into several categories. 

This year, the ACSI gathered data from over 40,000 customers who were randomly chosen and contacted via email. Customers were asked to rate their recent shopping experiences and individual supermarkets on a variety of criteria, including staff interactions, value, services, and cleanliness, on a 100-point scale.

While some companies have held a number one spot for years, the results this time around are startling.

Supermarket satisfaction is up

Customers were happy to hit the aisles this past year. The overall satisfaction score increased by 4%, from 82 to 86, for the 79 supermarkets in the study. Why were people happier with food shopping? It was a combination of things: better sales, good deals on promotional items, a healthier supply chain, and food inflation slowing down.

For the most part, stores have increased their hours, recovering from pandemic-era early closing times and allowing consumers to shop later in the day. And, thanks to an evening out of the supply chain issues that plagued retailers during and shortly after the COVID-19 pandemic, it was easier for customers to get everything on their shopping list.

The quality and freshness of meat and produce jumped four points from 80 to 84, and consumers appreciated having the ability to buy brand-name goods, up from 80 to 84. Having a more comprehensive range of available options resulted in an increase of six points, from 75 to 81.

Increased availability means more promotions to get people in the door and shopping. And more deals made people happy. The satisfaction rating for deals was 80, up five points from last year.

Three supermarkets tied for first place

This year, three stores tied for first place — Costco, H-E-B, and Publix — all with a satisfaction rating of 85. While all three received high marks for their private-label goods, there were standouts in other categories.

Costco and San Antonio-based H-E-B took the spotlight in product value. Customers shopping at both stores got a bigger bang for their buck than if they bought the same things from a competitor.

Publix, a Southern regional chain found in Tennessee, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, South Carolina, and Virginia, knocked it out of the park with its immaculate stores, helpful staff, and store layout.

As for the store whose cashiers wear Hawaiian shirts, Trader Joe’s didn’t move up or down in the satisfaction index. While their rank went down, their customer satisfaction rate, 84, stayed the same.

Stores and their scores

Ranking Supermarket Satisfaction Rating
1 Costco 85
2 H-E-B 85
3 Publix 85
4 Trader Joe’s 84
5 Sam’s Club (Walmart) 83
6 BJ’s Wholesale Club 82
7 Target 82
8 Wegmans 82
9 Whole Foods (Amazon) 82
10 Aldi 81
11 Meijer 80
12 ShopRite 80
13 All Others 79
14 Albertsons Companies 78
15 Hy-Vee 78
16 Ahold Delhaize 77
17 Kroger 77
18 Giant Eagle 76
19 Save A Lot 75
20 Walmart 74

Bottom line

Trader Joe’s is known for great prices, healthy options, and a relaxed atmosphere. Even with an ardent fan base, they lost their spot as the most satisfying supermarket to shop in the United States.

H-E-B, Costco, and Publix toppled Trader Joe’s winning streak. While all four of these stories provide great ways to save money on groceries, what was the true deciding factor? 

Based on the data, one thing stood out — promos and sales, which Trader Joe’s famously eschews in favor of fair pricing all the time. Maybe the chain should try running a sale or two, like the competition. And bring back the fresh cranberry orange relish.

Discover®️ Cashback Checking Benefits

  • Earn 1% cash back on up to $3,000 in debit card purchases each month1
  • No minimum deposit, no minimum balance, and no account fees
  • Access your paycheck up to 2 days early with Early Pay
  • 60K+ fee-free ATMs and make cash deposits at Walmart stores nationwide

Author Details

PJ Gach PJ Gach is a professional writer who has over a decade of experience covering the fashion, beauty, and lifestyle beats. Her writing credits include Shop TODAY, GoBankingRates,, Reader's Digest, The New York Post, Rolling Stone, and more.

Want to learn how to make an extra $200?

Get proven ways to earn extra cash from your phone, computer, & more with Extra.

You will receive emails from Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy

  • Vetted side hustles
  • Exclusive offers to save money daily
  • Expert tips to help manage and escape debt