Costco Fans Say These 10 Products are No Longer a Good Value

Costco is a great place to find bulk bargains, but that doesn’t mean every product in the warehouse is a deal. Here are 10 items to avoid.
Last updated Jan. 23, 2023 | By Michelle Smith | Edited By Rachel Siegel
passenger cars parked at Costco Wholesale location

We may receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

As any devoted Costco shopper will tell you, Costco’s incredible bulk deals can ensure that your $60 membership more than pays for itself within a shopping trip or two. But while Costco can help you save in general, not every Costco product is a bargain. In fact, if you want to go easy on your budget, there are some products you should go out of your way to purchase anywhere but Costco — starting with the 10 items listed below.

Electronics

Courtesy of Costco Samsung Galaxy Tab A8 10.5-inch Tablet

Costco can be a great place to buy electronics, even laptops, phones, and accessories, but not always. Check to see that you are buying the latest model available; sometimes selection is limited. And check that you are getting a lower price than you might get at an electronics retailer such as Best Buy.

Soda

Courtesy of Costco Variety Pack of 24 mini soda cans from Coca Cola

Unlike a lot of other Costco staples, sodas are sold in bulk in most grocery stores. As a result, most stores have soda deals, not just Costco. Unless you need a 36-count box of soda on short notice for a party, it’s worth comparing soda costs between Costco and other grocery stores like Winco or Kroger to make sure you’re getting the best price.

Fruits and Vegetables

Courtesy of Costco Gourmet large bag of fresh asparagus from Costco

Since Costco’s focus is on bulk items, it’s never been particularly well known for its produce. Unlike shelf-stable products, you can’t just buy a bag of fruit and let it sit in your pantry for a few weeks while you slowly work your way through it. Produce like onions and potatoes typically last longer than berries and bananas, but most fresh produce will still go bad faster than a shelf-stable item like, say, chips or pasta.

Plus, buying fruits and vegetables in bulk can keep you from spotting obvious problems that might stand out in a smaller package. For example, a few moldy strawberries are easier to catch if you’re examining a regular-sized container, but they can easily hide in a massive crate. As a result, you might accidentally buy a half-moldy carton of strawberries from Costco without even realizing it — which means you’ll have even less time to consume that entire bulk purchase before it goes bad.

Diapers

Courtesy of Costco Diaper Pack from Costco Kirkland Signature

Diapers won’t spoil the way food will, but your baby can outgrow them, leaving you with diapers you can’t use. Diapers are also difficult to store in bulk. So unless you are buying for triplets, it may be better to buy less elsewhere.

Flour

Courtesy of Costco Ardent Mills Harvest Hotel & Restaurant All-Purpose Flour, 25 lbs

Flour doesn’t spoil as fast as fruits and vegetables, but it still goes bad after a few months. If you’re an intrepid baker and you know for sure you’ll be able to use an entire Costco-sized bag of flour within eight or so months, Costco’s flour might still be a great bargain for you. Otherwise, skip the bulk flour in favor of smaller packages at a regular grocery store, and don’t forget to avoid raw cookie dough: no matter where you purchase it, flour can be contaminated with E. coli.

Chicken

Courtesy of Costco Kirkland Signature Chicken Breasts, Boneless Skinless, 6 lb

We’re not talking about Costco’s famous $5 rotisserie chicken, which the company plans to keep at its lower-than-low price for years to come. Instead, we mean hand-trimmed chicken breasts, thighs, and legs—the typical meat you’d get at a poultry section at any grocery store. While Costco’s raw meat can save you money, it isn’t necessarily a bargain, especially if you forget to freeze the meat you haven’t cooked yet within a few days.

Paying More For Groceries? 8 Ways To Fight Inflation | FinanceBuzz

Kirkland Brand Paper Goods

Courtesy of Costco Bath Tissue 30 Pack Kirkland Signature Costco

Costco shoppers give rave reviews to most of its store-branded products, but not its Kirkland brand paper products. The toilet paper and paper towels are just not as durable and strong, so while the price is right, you end up using more of them. It can be a bargain to purchase in bulk, but not if you have to use the product up in volume.

Shoes

Courtesy of Costco New Balance Women's 990v5 Running Shoe

Costco frequently sells name-brand clothes at more affordable prices than many clothing outlets. However, some Costco shoppers have bought cheaper brand-name items like shoes at Costco only to be disappointed in the quality and fit, speculating that Costco can sell branded items for less because it gets lower-quality inventory. Low-quality running shoes can increase your risk of injury, so make sure your Costco shoes are good for your feet and knees as well as your budget.

Cooking Oil

Courtesy of Costco Kirkland Signature Canola Oil, 3 qt, 2-count

Like flour, cooking oil goes bad after a few months, so if you aren’t sure you’ll be able to use up a massive bottle of cooking oil in six months or so, your liter of Costco cooking oil isn’t the bargain you think it is.

Major appliances

Courtesy of Costco Kitchen with marble wall, beige cabinets, and Samsung 6.0 cu. ft. Front Control Slide-in Gas Range with Convection and Wifi

You might be able to find a cheaper-than-average water heater, barbecue, or other major appliance for sale at Costco, but make sure the item you buy is the right quality, brand, and price for the job. For one thing, Costco’s amazing return policy doesn’t usually apply to appliances: you only have 90 days to return an appliance. For another, Costco doesn’t necessarily sell appliances at the lowest prices, so don’t forget to check with other big-box stores like Target, Walmart, and Sam’s Club so you can get the best deal on your costly product.

Bottom line

trongnguyen/Adobe inside view of alaska costco store

Ask any budget-conscious Costco shopper: Costco can give you and your budget a fantastic shopping experience. But Costco’s bulk food deals will backfire if you don’t eat the food you buy before it goes bad. And, you can’t count on saving money on every single product you find on your local warehouse’s shelves. As a money-conscious shopper, make sure you compare Costco’s prices on individual products to the price of the same items at smaller chains.

Test your skills and get paid up to $115 every time you win Learn More
Get paid for taking surveys on your favorite brands Learn More

Author Details

Michelle Smith Michelle Smith has spent a decade writing for and about small businesses. She specializes in all things finance and has written for publications like G2 and SmallBizDaily. When she's not writing for work at her desk, you can usually find her writing for pleasure near large bodies of water.