News & Trending Shopping & Deals News

11 Costco Dupes That Give Crumbl Cookies a Run for Their Money

Crumbl cookies are delicious, but Costco has budget-friendly alternatives worth checking out.

costco wholesale location
Updated Sept. 24, 2024
Fact checked

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

Cronuts. Artisanal cupcakes. Gourmet donuts. Each of these delicious confections have had their time in the culinary spotlight. Now it’s Crumbl Cookies that are dominating in the sweet treat space.

Fortunately, everyone’s favorite big box retailer has comparable alternatives in its food court, bakery, and warehouse shelves, often for a fraction of the cost. 

And nothing could be easier than stocking up on delicious treats while you’re at Costco saving money on groceries. But are they as delicious as Crumbl’s elevated offerings? Let’s find out.

Earn 2% cash rewards at grocery stores and Costco

The Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card(Rates and fees) is a powerful rewards card that allows you to earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases — including on groceries, even at warehouse stores like Costco.

New cardholders can also earn a one-time cash rewards bonus — $200 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months!

If you’re looking for a powerful rewards card that offers an extended intro APR period, look no further, the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card checks that box too!

This card also offers an intro APR of 0% for 12 months from account opening on purchases and qualifying balance transfers (then 19.74%, 24.74%, or 29.74% Variable). Which is great for someone who wants a break from high interest rates, while still earning rewards.

The best part? There's no annual fee.

Click here to apply for the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card now.

Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Courtesy of Crumbl Double chocolate chunk cookie

If you’re a regular at the Costco food court, you’ve noticed that they replaced the OG churro with a double chocolate chunk cookie. It’s comparable to Crumbl’s semi-sweet chocolate chunk offering, which wins in the softness department.

But thanks to more chocolate chips, a homemade taste, and superior chocolate pull, Costco takes the cake on this one — or, rather, the cookie, according to taste testers.

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie

Courtesy of Costco box of Costco white chocolate macadamia nut cookies

Found in Costco’s bakery section, their white chocolate macadamia nut cookie is a cult favorite. But can it hold a flame to Crumbl’s comparable offering?

Because Costco’s cookie doesn’t have uniform consistency when it comes to the distribution of nuts and chocolate chips, the winner this time is Crumbl, with a perfect flavor and texture balance.

White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie

Courtesy of Instacart box of white chocolate cranberry cookies from costco

If you grab one of Costco’s white chocolate cranberry cookies fresh out of the container, they’re pretty comparable to Crumbl’s cranberry white chip option.

However, the consensus is that Crumbl has mastered the balance of cranberry tartness with white chocolate sweetness just a bit better than Costco.

Stop overpaying when you shop online at Costco

Shopping online has its perks. It's super convenient, but it can be time consuming to find the best deals. Instead of hunting for coupon codes (that don't always work!) and opening tons of browser tabs comparing prices, you can try Capital One Shopping.

Capital One Shopping makes saving money effortless. Just add the browser extension and when you check out, it'll scour the internet for coupon codes to help you save cash. And before you check out at 25+ major retailers, Capital One Shopping will notify you with a friendly pop-up if the item you're buying is available cheaper somewhere else.

Capital One Shopping is free to use and won't show you ads. Add it today and stop overpaying!1

Get Capital One Shopping now

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Courtesy of Instacart box of oatmeal raisin cookies from Costco

Arguably a controversial flavor in the cookie world, Crumbl has been known to throw down a delicious and consistent oatmeal raisin cookie.

This time we’re handing the medal to Costco, who over time has perfected their oatmeal raisin cookie recipe. It’s one of their best, thanks to its moist, chewy consistency and balanced, tart-to-sweet taste ratio.

David’s Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup cookie

Courtesy of Costco David’s Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup cookie

Costco carries a variety of David’s baked goods — a New York baking OG — in tins that include these huge, mouthwatering treats. The problem is that often, members say the cookies are in pieces, damaged by the shipping process.

That and Crumbl’s absolutely stellar comparable offering puts them on the top of this battle. It’s a favorite of many Crumbl aficionados.

David’s Butter Pecan Meltaways

Courtesy of Costco David’s Butter Pecan Meltaways

Crumbl’s pecan pie cookie is amazing, no doubt about it. But Costco carries David’s Butter Pecan Meltaways, and they are god-tier-level delicious, according to thousands upon thousands of reviewers.

Be careful if you bring them home, as word on the street is that they’re so addictive you’ll have a hard time stopping with just one — or one hundred.

David’s Double Chocolate Chip Cookie

Courtesy of Costco David’s Double Chocolate Chip Cookie

For true chocoholics, double chocolate chip Cookies are basically a sacrament. As for the David’s brand that Costco carries, reviewers praised them for being real crowd pleasers.

For that reason, they edge out Crumbl’s Dark Dream Cookie, which taste testers say lacked intensity, bitter contrast, and that essential sense of “Crumbl exclusivity.”

Ferrara's Bakery Cannolis

Courtesy of Costco Ferrara's Bakery cannolis

Ferrara’s is a famous New York City bakery, and Costco sells a variety of their cannolis, large and small.

Crumbl’s cannoli cookie edges out the competition, however, thanks to its off-the-charts deliciousness. The shell on Ferrara’s cannoli was just too soft (though the cream was delicious), according to connoisseurs.

Ferrara's Bakery Rainbow Cookie

Courtesy of Costco Ferrara's Bakery Rainbow Cookie

On the flip side, Ferrara’s Rainbow Cookies is well-executed; they have a great texture, a delicious and classic flavor, and are “hauntingly deliciously memorable,” per reviewers.

They definitely outshine Crumbl’s Hawaii Rainbow Cake Cookie, which suffers from a lack of frosting and flavor after an unfortunate makeover that stole the magic.

Get a protection plan on all your appliances

Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.

Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.

For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.

Get a free quote

Cheryl's Assorted Cookies

Courtesy of Costco Cheryl's Assorted Cookies

Cute, classic, and frosted with buttercream, fans of Cheryl’s Assorted Cookies from Costco love gifting them to their moms as a springtime treat.

But when it comes to a classic sugar cookie with delicious frosting, Cheryl’s creations can’t keep up with Crumbl’s classic Pink Sugar Cookie. It’s so popular it’s a permanent menu staple!

S’mores cookie

Brent Hofacker/Adobe plate of smores cookie

The s’mores cookies from Costco’s bakery have been called “dangerous” — they’re just that good. But the caveat is that taste testers put their cookies in an air fryer before eating them.

Meanwhile, Crumbl’s S’mores Cookie is nothing short of transcendent out of the gate, with a crispy crust and stretchy marshmallow center. Fans have called it literally perfect, so we’re giving Crumbl the win this time.

Bottom line

seanlockephotography/Adobe little girl eating cookie

Let’s face it: Crumbl Cookies have disrupted the sweet treat space, and we’re here for all of that ooey, gooey goodness. 

But sometimes, be it for budgetary reasons or matters of taste, a great Costco hack is their alternatives that give Crumbl a run for its money.

Fortunately for fans of both Costco and Crumbl, there are sure to be new offerings promising fun flavor experiences on the horizon. So make sure there’s room in your budget to explore all the yumminess ahead!

Lucrative, Flat-Rate Cash Rewards

5.0
info

Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card

Current Offer

$200 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months

Annual Fee

$0

Rewards Rate

Earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases

Benefits and Drawbacks
Card Details


Author Details

Cat Lafuente

Cat Lafuente is a Florida-based writer and editor with extensive experience in digital and print content spaces. Her own personal finance journey — particularly consolidating debt and paying it off, in turn boosting her credit score and becoming a homeowner — inspired her to join the FinanceBuzz team; she hopes she can help others do the same.