Lemonade Renters Insurance: Why It’s a Top Pick for Millennials Everywhere

Heard great things about Lemonade? They’re all true.
Last updated Nov 30, 2020 | By Larissa Runkle
Couple dancing in new living room

FinanceBuzz is reader-supported. We may receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

It takes a lot for us to be impressed, especially when it comes to insurance. After all, no matter how user-friendly an insurance app or website may be, many insurance companies are not. For most of us, we end up paying the bare minimum in coverage and then cross our fingers and hope we never have to use it. Getting reimbursed for expensive medical bills or other unexpected insurance claims? It may just never happen — and could take months if it does.

Enter Lemonade, the company that’s single-handedly changing the face of insurance coverage for renters, homeowners, and even their pets. If you’re looking for great coverage from an insurer that’s on a mission to enact social change, keep reading. We have a feeling you’re going to like this.

Lemonade Benefits

  • Protect your home starting at just $5/month
  • Get insured in 90 seconds
  • Payouts in as little as 3 minutes
  • Easily switch if you're already insured

In this Lemonade renters insurance review:

What is Lemonade?

Lemonade is a New-York based insurance company founded in 2016 by two entrepreneurs, Shai Wininger and Daniel Schreiber. It has since grown to provide insurance coverage to renters and homeowners in nearly 30 states, selling more than 1.2 million policies.

The company describes itself as “injecting technology and transparency into an industry that often lacks both” — which feels pretty spot-on, and people are responding well. One reviewer recently called his experience “pretty sure it was easier than ordering pizza,” and another said it was his “best insurance experience ever.”

Besides providing three different types of insurance coverage (renters, homeowners, and most recently pet insurance), the company is also a recognized B-Corp® organization. This means it’s been awarded certification from the nonprofit B Lab in recognition of its efforts to promote social and environmental impact.

Unlike traditional insurance companies, where the claims process can take months, Lemonade prides itself on paying back claims quickly and makes the entire process of insurance coverage more transparent for its policyholders. Because the company is built on a different business model than most other insurance companies (which make profits on your denied claims), it’s able to repay claims quickly and without conflict. It does this by working with a reinsurance company, which offers insurance for insurance companies, and by operating on a flat-fee structure that annually returns or donates leftover user-paid premiums to charities you choose through its Giveback program.

How does Lemonade renters insurance work?

Besides offering exceptional customer service and a great user experience, Lemonade renters insurance works in much the same way as other renters insurance: by providing coverage for basic things renters need. With plans that start at just $5 per month, this coverage includes things like personal property, temporary living expenses (if something happens to your place), and personal liability and medical bills. This includes any damage from a fire, theft, or even if you or someone else gets hurt at your place.

It doesn’t include things owned by your landlord or other people unless their names are on your policy. For example, if you get a renters insurance policy through Lemonade and live with your parents or roommates but don’t share an insurance policy — then their stuff won’t be covered the way yours will.

Renters insurance also won’t cover the building you live in. Unlike homeowners insurance, which covers the actual structure of your home and other buildings on your property, renters insurance covers only what you own — as a renter, that’s not typically the building itself. As with insurance companies, Lemonade can’t prevent anything from happening to your stuff. But it can and is more likely to reimburse you if something happens to you or any of your personal property as a renter.

One final note here: A common misconception about renters insurance is that it’s not really worth paying for. But because renters insurance can protect your stuff whether you’re home (including stuff that may get stolen while you’re out and about) it’s a good bit of extra coverage for anyone who wouldn’t want to front the expense of replacing their stuff out of pocket.

What other products does Lemonade offer?

Besides renters insurance, Lemonade also offers homeowners and most recently pet insurance — and a bundling discount if you opt for multiple coverages. 

Homeowners insurance

Homeowner’s insurance, as we briefly mentioned above, is a lot like renters insurance, except it covers more things. Starting at just $25 per month, Lemonade’s home insurance has a 4.9-star rating both in the App Store and on Google Play. Its policies include everything in renters policies plus coverage for the physical structures on your property — like your house and garage.

If your home becomes unlivable, Lemonade will also cover temporary housing in a hotel or rental. The company prides itself on responding quickly to claims, with bots (and real people) working diligently to respond to any inquiries.

Pet insurance

This is a new insurance offering with Lemonade, but given its fantastic renter and homeowner reviews, we have pretty high expectations. Created with the help of a team of vets and pet parents, Lemonade’s pet insurance policy covers everything you need to keep Fido (and your wallet) healthy, and coverage starts at just $10 per month.

This policy includes things like diagnostic procedures, medication, accidents, and even illness. You can also add an optional wellness package to your plan for extra coverage of things like routine wellness exams, tests, and vaccines. This package also includes access to the team’s online medical team, which means if something happens, you can ask your questions online before heading to your local vet or emergency clinic.

And if you find yourself asking, is pet insurance worth it? The answer is yes. According to our recent pet insurance survey, at least half of all pet insurance holders we asked have used their policies to file a claim in the past year. Pet insurance can save you a lot of unexpected expenses and help you avoid making difficult decisions about the value of your pet’s health.

How to sign up for Lemonade renters insurance

When it says it takes 90 seconds to sign up, it’s not a joke. Getting started with Lemonade is super easy and goes a little something like this.

After selecting one of its prompts to sign up, you’ll be directed to a screen with an agent’s photo and name.

After entering your full name, you’ll be prompted to input your address.

Next up, you’ll be asked a series of questions based on what systems your place has (fire alarms or security systems), and whom you share the space with, such as a partner, pets, kids, or roommates.

After that, you’ll be asked about your belongings and whether you have anything especially valuable, such as jewelry, cameras, musical instruments, or fine art. This doesn’t require you to get into any specifics, just provide a general yes or no so it knows whether you need these things covered.

Finally, you’ll be asked whether you have insurance for this rental yet.

Then just plug in your date of birth and email and Lemonade will send you an insurance quote!

In addition to offering a straightforward process for getting a quote, Lemonade also offers you the option to customize your coverage options before you pay. When you sign up, it will send you a coverage summary, and you can choose to modify your coverage and change your deductible and other policy settings. Once everything looks good, you pay for coverage and Lemonade sends you your final policy in the mail. 

FAQs about Lemonade renters insurance

Is Lemonade renters insurance legit?

Lemonade is a legitimate insurance provider offering renters, homeowners, and pet insurance. It’s based out of New York and has sold more than 1.2 million insurance policies. In five years of business, it’s also earned a B+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and an average 4.4/5 star rating from more than 200 customers on the bureau site.

How much does Lemonade renters insurance cost?

Lemonade insurance policies vary in price depending on the type of coverage you need. However, policies start at just $5 per month for renters insurance and $25 per month for homeowners insurance.

How do you contact Lemonade customer service?

You can reach Lemonade customer service 24/7 through its app or website. You can also call its customer service team at 844-733-8666.

Does Lemonade renters insurance renew automatically?

Yes, Lemonade insurance policies renew automatically. Automatic renewals ensure you never miss a day of coverage.

In which states is Lemonade renters insurance available?

Lemonade renters insurance is available in 28 states (as of Nov. 30, 2020). Renters can get coverage in Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, District of Columbia, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin.

The bottom line

Getting the insurance coverage you need is important, and Lemonade is a fantastic option for renters and homeowners in the states it serves. Getting the right insurance is also a smart money move, as it allows for some peace of mind that no matter what happens, you can protect both yourself and your family.

A final word about Lemonade: Although there are many positives about this company, it’s still fairly new, and it’s not offering service everywhere quite yet. The good news is that you can already sign up for Lemonade renters insurance in more than 25 states, and given its success and aggressive plans for expansion, we have a feeling it won’t be too long until you can find Lemonade insurance nationwide.

Lemonade Benefits

  • Protect your home starting at just $5/month
  • Get insured in 90 seconds
  • Payouts in as little as 3 minutes
  • Easily switch if you're already insured

Author Details

Larissa Runkle Larissa writes for FinanceBuzz and divides her time between a cabin in the San Juan Mountains and traveling in a van. She enjoys writing about travel, debt relief, personal loans, and mortgages. Her work has been featured on MagnifyMoney, LendingTree, and Realtor.com. Outside of finance and real estate writing, she’s also at work on several fiction projects. When away from the computer, you’ll find her reading, exploring local trails, and climbing rocks.