insurance car insurance

GEICO vs. Progressive [2025]: Which Insurer Offers You the Best Value?

GEICO generally has better ratings and more affordable premiums than Progressive, but it lacks coverage add-ons that may be important to some people.
Updated May 6, 2025
Fact checked
Our trusted partners
+ MORE

GEICO and Progressive are two of the country's largest car insurance companies, and you might find it tough to decide between them. After all, Flo and the adorable GEICO gecko each make a compelling sales pitch.

For most people, GEICO is the better option. The company has better financial strength and customer satisfaction ratings than Progressive and offers more affordable premiums on average, especially for liability-only coverage. The company also offers more discount opportunities.

However, Progressive has some unique coverage options that GEICO lacks, and the company may offer cheaper premiums to drivers in certain states. Progressive's usage-based program is also more widely available. Ultimately, I recommend considering several companies and comparing customized quotes before making a final decision.

How we evaluate products

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.
Compare car insurance rates in Ohio
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

Geico pros and cons

Pros
  • A++ (Superior) financial strength rating with AM Best
  • Low premiums, especially for liability-only coverage
  • Many discounts, including a multi-car discount of up to 25%
Cons
  • Below-average claims satisfaction rating from J.D. Power
  • Pending class action lawsuit for misleading policyholders about accident forgiveness
  • Few additional auto coverage options

Learn more in our GEICO review.

Progressive pros and cons

Pros
  • Many unique add-ons for customized coverage
  • Tiered loyalty program with many perks
  • Budget-friendly "Name Your Price" tool
Cons
  • Poor claims satisfaction rating from J.D. Power
  • Many poor customer service reviews

Learn more in our Progressive review.

Which company is better?

GEICO Progressive
AM Best A++ A+
J.D. Power claims satisfaction 692/1,000 672/1,000
BBB A+ (Not accredited) A+ (Not accredited)
NAIC complaints 0.75 (private passenger) 0.97 (private passenger)

GEICO has better third-party ratings than Progressive. AM Best, an independent credit rating agency for the insurance industry, gave GEICO its highest financial strength rating. This indicates the company was rated as superior for keeping up with its claim-handling obligations. Progressive received the second-highest grade available from AM Best.

GEICO also surpasses Progressive in multiple measures of customer satisfaction. The company received a higher rating than Progressive in the 2024 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, though both insurers ranked below average. The study measures satisfaction with different aspects of the claims process, including the speed, ease, and fairness.

GEICO and Progressive both have poor customer reviews on multiple websites. While both companies have an A+ rating with the BBB, neither company is BBB accredited. However, GEICO has fewer NAIC complaints for private passenger insurance relative to its market share than Progressive, indicating that GEICO policyholders are less likely to file formal complaints.

Get Custom Quotes Today
Allstate Logo
Safe Drivers Save with Allstate®
Average Rate:

Get rewarded with savings for having a clean driving record.

State Farm Logo
See how much you could save today!
Average Rate:

Drivers who switch their auto insurance and save with State Farm save $764 on average!

Which company is cheaper?

National average premiums for GEICO car insurance are lower than those for Progressive car insurance across all types of drivers. GEICO's liability-only insurance premiums are especially inexpensive relative to Progressive, with Progressive charging nearly twice the monthly premium that GEICO charges on average for drivers with infractions on their records.

Bear in mind that premiums vary by state and even by zip code. For example, Progressive offers cheaper full-coverage insurance to drivers in Mississippi than GEICO, but Progressive's rates in Florida are nearly triple GEICO's rates.

Car insurance premiums also depend on a combination of individual factors, like your age and driving record, the type of car you drive, your driving habits, your location, and the coverage limits you choose. That's why it's best to compare customized quotes from Progressive, GEICO, and other top car insurance companies before buying a policy.

Here's a look at GEICO's average premiums across coverage types:

Driver type GEICO liability-only monthly premium GEICO full-coverage monthly premium
Clean driving record $52 $114
Speeding ticket on driving record $63 $138
At-fault accident on driving record $67 $145
DUI on driving record $85 $185
Teen driver $84 $183
Senior driver (60s) $40 $87
Senior driver (70s) $39 $84
Data sourced from Insurify

And here are Progressive's average rates for comparison:

Driver type Progressive liability-only monthly premium Progressive full coverage monthly premium
Clean driving record $96 $149
Speeding ticket on driving record $117 $182
At-fault accident on driving record $115 $198
DUI on driving record $155 $240
Teen driver $176 $273
Senior driver (60s) $58 $89
Senior driver (70s) $58 $89
Data sourced from Insurify

Clean driving record

GEICO offers cheaper premiums than Progressive for drivers with a clean record, on average. But both companies offer savings for a clean driving record and telematics programs that can help you lower your car insurance premium based on your driving habits.

Save On Your Auto Insurance
  • You could save up to $600 with some companies.
  • Compare dozens of providers in under 5 minutes.
  • Fast, free, and easy way to shop for insurance.
  • Quickly find the perfect rate for you.

Average rate:

Speeding ticket on record

Drivers with a speeding ticket on their record tend to pay lower premiums at GEICO than at Progressive for both full coverage and liability-only car insurance. For example, Progressive charges drivers with speeding tickets an average of $53 more per month for liability insurance than GEICO does.

At-fault accident on driving record

GEICO has lower average premiums than Progressive for drivers who have had an at-fault accident. But if you currently don't have an at-fault accident on your record, keep in mind that Progressive offers small accident forgiveness to policyholders free of charge, and you can also earn large accident forgiveness after a 5-year violation-free period. This can help keep your rates low if you cause an accident in the future.

DUI on driving record

While both companies increase premiums for drivers after a DUI, GEICO offers cheaper rates to drivers who have committed this serious offense, particularly for liability coverage. The average monthly premium for liability-only insurance after a DUI is just $85 with GEICO.

Teen driver

GEICO's average rates for teens are among the cheapest of the providers reviewed. Progressive charges more than GEICO, on average, for teen drivers, though the company still charges less than the national average for teens. Plus, Progressive offers a unique discount for policyholders who have been with the company for at least 1 year and add a teen driver.

Senior driver

Drivers in their 70s pay lower premiums at GEICO than Progressive for both full coverage and liability coverage, but not by much. The premium difference is just $1 for seniors buying full-coverage insurance. That said, in many states, GEICO offers a discount to seniors who complete a defensive driving course. Progressive doesn't offer a similar discount.

Discounts

GEICO offers a greater variety of discounts than Progressive, with particularly appealing options for new car owners. Unlike Progressive, GEICO offers an array of safety and security equipment discounts and a discount of up to 15% for new vehicles. The company also offers discounts for military members, federal employees, and members of certain organizations.

You can also save money on car insurance with GEICO by taking a driver's education course or defensive driving course, while Progressive doesn't offer these opportunities. But Progressive offers more perks for loyal customers, like its teen driver discount, accident forgiveness, and discounts on car rentals and other services through its Perkshare program.

Otherwise, the two companies share many discounts, including: for bundling, for students, and for paying in full and automatic payments.

Discount Does GEICO have it? Does Progressive have it?
Loyalty No Yes
Multi-policy/bundling Yes Yes
Multiple vehicle Yes Yes
Airbag Yes No
Anti-lock brakes Yes No
Anti-theft Yes No
Safe driver Yes Yes
Good student Yes Yes
Away-from-home student Yes Yes
New car Yes No
Pay in full Yes Yes
Automatic payments Yes Yes
GAP insurance No Yes
Senior No No
Military Yes No
Defensive driving course Yes No

GEICO DriveEasy vs Progressive Snapshot

GEICO and Progressive both offer telematics or usage-based programs designed to save you money for safe driving behavior. However, Progressive offers its program to drivers in more states than GEICO. These similar programs offer savings based on factors such as how often you drive, when you drive, how hard you brake, and whether you use your phone while driving.

Progressive offers a discount just for enrolling in Snapshot, with an average savings of $169 for the first policy period. GEICO may offer a discount of up to 15% for eligible drivers who enroll in DriveEasy. Both companies collect driving data via a mobile app, but Progressive also offers the option of a plug-in device (in some states, it's the only option for existing customers).

While both programs may provide ongoing savings, there's also a chance your rates could increase due to risky driving behavior. Note that some other car insurance companies offer usage-based programs without the risk of a base premium increase.

Coverage

Progressive offers a wider array of coverage options than GEICO, including unique coverage add-ons that protect you from a variety of risks. If you're looking for a customized policy with more coverage, GAP insurance for a new vehicle, or a rideshare endorsement because you drive for Uber or Lyft, Progressive may be a better fit for your needs.

Both companies offer the standard coverage types that state laws require and a handful of optional coverage options, including:

  • Bodily injury liability coverage
  • Property damage liability coverage
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage
  • Medical payments coverage (MedPay)
  • Personal injury protection (PIP)
  • Collision coverage
  • Comprehensive coverage
  • Emergency roadside assistance
  • Rental car reimbursement
  • Mechanical breakdown/major systems coverage (similar to a warranty)

Additionally, Progressive offers the following car insurance add-ons:

  • Loan/lease payoff (GAP insurance)
  • Trip interruption insurance for road trips
  • Custom parts and equipment value coverage
  • Rideshare coverage
  • Pet injury coverage
  • Deductible Savings Bank

FAQs

How do I contact GEICO?

To speak to customer service, you can use GEICO's live chat, call the 24/7 support line at 1-800-207-7847, or send an email through the company's website. As a policyholder, you can also use GEICO's online portal or mobile app, and you can call 1-800-424-3426 to use your roadside assistance coverage.

How do I contact Progressive?

Progressive has a live chat, an online email form, and a 24/7 phone support line at 1-888-671-4405. If you become a policyholder, you can also use the self-service support tools on Progressive's online portal and mobile app.

Is Progressive the best insurance?

While Progressive is a legitimate and respected car insurance company that offers affordable rates and an array of coverage options, it may be the best option for some drivers. It's neither the best-rated nor the cheapest company in most states. Consider your coverage needs and compare multiple car insurance options to find the right provider.

Why is GEICO so much cheaper?

GEICO is the third-largest auto insurer in the U.S. and attracts a broad demographic of customers by offering special discounts to seniors, young drivers, government employees, new vehicle owners, and others. Its national presence, diverse risk pool, and efficient processes may be a few of the reasons GEICO can offer more affordable rates than other companies.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings
Ohio: Say Goodbye to High Auto Insurance Rates if You Live in These Zip Codes
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
Start Saving

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy


Bottom line

When trying to decide between GEICO or Progressive for car insurance, consider that GEICO has better ratings, cheaper premiums, and more discount opportunities than Progressive. However, Progressive does offer more coverage options and a unique loyalty program.

While GEICO is generally the better choice for most drivers, individual factors (like your state of residence) can dramatically impact the cost and options available from each company. You should compare quotes from the best car insurance companies to make sure you get the best value for your coverage needs.

Save On Your Auto Insurance
  • You could save up to $600 with some companies.
  • Compare dozens of providers in under 5 minutes.
  • Fast, free, and easy way to shop for insurance.
  • Quickly find the perfect rate for you.

Average rate: