If You Were Accidentally Paid Too Much by Social Security, Do You Actually Need To Repay It?

Is extra money from Social Security a blessing or a curse?
Updated June 6, 2024
Fact checked

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

In an unexpected turn of events, a recent poll revealed that a staggering one in four Americans who receive Social Security payments reported receiving more than they were owed. The revelation has left Social Security recipients unsure whether they owe money back to the Social Security Administration (SSA). Let's delve into the intricacies of this issue, exploring what led to overpayments, whether recipients need to repay, and the processes involved.

If you’re over 50, take advantage of massive discounts and financial resources

Over 50? Join AARP today — because if you’re not a member you could be missing out on huge perks. When you start your membership today, you can get discounts on things like travel, meal deliveries, eyeglasses, prescriptions that aren’t covered by insurance and more.

How to become a member today:

  • Go here, select your free gift, and click “Join Today”
  • Create your account (important!) by answering a few simple questions
  • Start enjoying your discounts and perks!

Important: Start your membership by creating an account here and filling in all of the information (Do not skip this step!) Doing so will allow you to take up 25% off your AARP membership, making it just $12 per year with auto-renewal.

Become an AARP member now

The overpayment conundrum

According to exclusive Newsweek polling, 25% of Social Security recipients admitted to receiving more funds than they were entitled to. The SSA, under scrutiny for the mismanagement of overpayments, has faced criticism for understating the issue. Recent reports indicate that over 2 million Americans are impacted by these overpayment issues annually — double the figure presented to lawmakers in a congressional hearing just a few months ago.

Public opinion on repayments

Public sentiment on the SSA's efforts to reclaim overpayments is divided. The Redfield & Wilton Strategies poll for Newsweek highlighted that 43% of respondents believe it is unjust for the SSA to demand repayments from recipients who have inadvertently received more than their entitlement. 

This comes against a year marked by high inflation and high prices in categories mainly affecting seniors, like groceries. On the other hand, 36% sided with the agency, asserting its right to seek repayments. An additional 21% remain undecided on the matter. In the end, this isn't the way to make extra money.

Impact on recipients

Social Security benefits form a significant portion of many recipients' income and help stretch their budgets further, but the overpayment issue has far-reaching consequences. Many Americans rely solely on their monthly Social Security checks for daily expenses. 

Disturbingly, stories have emerged of individuals receiving repayment demands amounting to tens of thousands of dollars, causing financial distress and, in extreme cases, homelessness. Lawmakers, such as Rep. Mike Carey (R-OH), have expressed concerns about penalizing seniors and disabled Americans for bureaucratic mistakes made by the SSA.

The SSA's response

The SSA, under the leadership of acting commissioner Kilolo Kijakazi, has publicly acknowledged the overpayment problem. Kijakazi apologized and informed lawmakers that the agency is conducting a comprehensive review of its data. She assured the committee the findings would be shared once the data was thoroughly vetted. The SSA has initiated a review of its overpayment procedures and policies, recognizing the need for a solution. The best thing you can do for you is to repay the funds as quickly as you can. 

Statistical insights to overpayments

Despite the alarming figures surrounding overpayments, the SSA contends that only 0.5% of the yearly $1.4 trillion disbursed in benefits constitutes overpayments. The Supplemental Security Income program faces a slightly higher overpayment rate of 8%. According to the SSA, the complexity of administering income and resource limits and asset evaluations contributes to these higher figures.

The financial impact of overpayments

An inspector general's report revealed that the SSA had recouped $4.7 billion of overpayments during the 2022 fiscal year. However, a staggering $21.6 billion in overpayments remained outstanding at the year's end. The agency clarified that it does not intend to collect the outstanding amount, emphasizing a case-by-case approach. Recipients disputing overpayments have the right to appeal, and those facing financial hardship can request a waiver of the repayment.

Bottom line

The Social Security overpayment issue underscores the challenges faced by the SSA and recipients. As the agency grapples with the fallout of its overpayment issues, recipients find themselves caught in the crossfire, dealing with repayment demands that can have profound financial implications. While the SSA is taking steps to address the problem, the road ahead remains uncertain. 

Social Security beneficiaries should stay informed, understand their rights, and consider seeking professional advice if facing overpayment challenges. The unfolding situation prompts a crucial dialogue on improving benefits administration, ensuring that bureaucratic errors do not burden seniors and disabled Americans.

Choice Home Warranty Benefits

  • First month free
  • Protection for unexpected expense
  • 24/7 claims hotline
  • Network of over 15,000 technicians

Author Details

Georgina Tzanetos Georgina Tzanetos is a former financial advisor who has been active in financial media for the past six years. She holds a master's in political economy from NYU, where she studied distressed labor markets.