Retirement Social Security

The One Social Security Assumption That Trips Up Middle-Class Retirees

The Social Security myth that can lead to smaller checks for life.

By David Maina

Edited by Amanda Machado

Updated Jan. 6, 2026

Many middle-class retirees treat Social Security as a fixed part of their retirement plan. It's been around for decades, and the benefit can seem like a steady paycheck you don't need to think much about.

That sense of certainty often leads to a common assumption. Many people believe that claiming Social Security early will not make much difference over the long run. In reality, that decision can permanently shrink your monthly checks and potentially reduce what you collect over your lifetime.

Here's why this belief is so common, where it falls apart, and how it can quietly leave retirees with less income than they expected.

Learn 7 ways to generate income with a $1,000,000 portfolio

Learn the strategies wealthy retirees use to fund their retirement with $1,000,000 — and how you can, too — with this new guide: The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income from Fisher Investments.

Fisher Investments has helped tens of thousands of investors retire comfortably since 1979. With over $332 billion under management, they provide tailored money management to help achieve long-term goals.

Get your guide here

Why many retirees claim as soon as they're eligible

Early claiming is appealing for simple, human reasons. Cash now feels better than cash later, especially when you're eager to retire or dealing with new expenses. At 62, eligibility kicks in, and taking benefits immediately can feel like the obvious move.

Some people assume they can invest the checks themselves. Others worry the system might change and want to collect while they can. Instead of running the numbers, the decision often gets driven by urgency or the idea that "something now" is better than waiting.

What gets missed is the permanent tradeoff. Claiming early locks in a lower benefit for life. You may collect for more years, but every monthly check is smaller.

Who really has the cheapest auto insurance in your area? Check your zip code here.

Why timing matters more than it seems

To see why early claiming is so costly, it helps to look at a simple example from the Social Security Administration (SSA). Suppose your full retirement age (FRA) benefit at 67 is $2,000 per month. If you claim at 62, your check is reduced by about 30%, leaving you with $1,400 a month.

Now compare that with waiting. If you delay until age 70, your benefit rises by about 24% above the $2,000 base, to roughly $2,480 per month. That is $1,080 more each month than claiming at 62, or about a 77% higher check.

To put it simply, what feels like a small timing decision can end up reshaping your income for decades.

The lasting income hit from claiming early

Early claiming locks in a permanent reduction to your benefit, lowering your guaranteed income floor for life. In the example above, claiming at 62 means $1,400 per month, while waiting until 70 locks in $2,480. Both amounts receive inflation adjustments, but the gap between them never closes.

Over time, that difference adds up. This is why planners often talk about a break-even age, which is the point where total benefits from waiting catch up to what you would have collected by claiming early. For many retirees, that break-even point arrives sooner than expected.

According to AARP, delaying from 62 to 70 boosts monthly benefits by roughly $970, with a break-even point about 10 and a half years later, or around age 80.

If you live beyond that, which many retirees do, delaying can add tens of thousands of dollars to your lifetime income. Claiming early may provide larger checks sooner, but it often comes at the cost of much smaller guaranteed income later in life.

Get a protection plan on all your appliances

Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.

Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.

For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.

Get a free quote

The inflation cost of a smaller benefit base

Social Security benefits receive annual cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs), but those increases apply only to the base benefit you lock in. A smaller base means smaller raises every year.

For example, a 2.8% COLA on a lower monthly check produces a much smaller increase than the same 2.8% applied to a higher one, and over decades, that gap widens further.

The retiree who waited to claim sees larger inflation adjustments year after year, which translates into more real spending power in their 80s and 90s.

On a practical level, a smaller Social Security check can also strain your monthly budget. If Social Security is expected to cover most fixed costs, a reduced benefit may force you to tap savings sooner or leave little room for surprises.

Higher medical bills, home repairs, or other unexpected expenses can be harder to absorb when your guaranteed income is permanently lower.

How early claiming affects a surviving spouse

Claiming early can also reduce benefits for a spouse or survivor. Under rules set by the SSA, a surviving spouse can usually collect up to 100% of the benefit the worker was receiving at death.

If you claimed early, that benefit was already reduced. Your survivor then inherits the smaller amount, and the cut becomes permanent for the rest of their life.

This is easy to overlook, especially for middle-class couples who focus on their own retirement timing. But an early claim can shrink the household's future income long after one spouse is gone.

Bottom line

Before you lock in a Social Security claiming decision, it's worth slowing down and running the numbers. Look at the break-even point, your health outlook, other sources of income, and, if applicable, your spouse's long-term needs. A few extra dollars each month today can mean giving up much more income over time.

The key is to move past gut instincts and surface-level assumptions. With a better understanding of the rules, you can use Social Security to support your plan and retire comfortably, instead of limiting your income for the rest of your life.

More from FinanceBuzz: