News & Trending Shopping & Deals News

10 Irritating Things That Make Thrift Store Shopping (Almost) Unbearable

From overcrowding to inflated prices, these thrifting things drive us absolutely bonkers.

woman trying out thrifted bag in mirror
Updated Jan. 1, 2026
Fact check checkmark icon Fact checked

Historically, a smart way to save money is to purchase items—clothing, accessories, decor, furniture—secondhand when available. Recently, increasing sustainability awareness and practices have been pushing people in that direction. 

The value of the secondhand apparel market is expected to reach $351 billion worldwide by 2027, and that's without accounting for any arbitrary inflation.

But, even with the increasing popularity of thrifting, these 11 things drive us crazy.

Get a protection plan on all your appliances

Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.

Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.

For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.

Get a free quote

Inflated pricing

amixstudio/Adobe Flea market with vintage objects

In recent years, you might notice more and more thrift stores and antique malls overcharging for vintage finds. Just because something is nostalgic does not make it worth a fortune. 

Many Redditors believe it is because of the increase in popularity of thrifting. Others understand the increasing cost of running a brick-and-mortar can take a toll on prices.

Thrift store volunteers mention they are instructed to look up current prices for quality or new versions of the products instead of pricing items to sell.

Resellers cornering the market

okrasiuk/Adobe woman taking clothes pictures for donating

If you are looking for a cheap find, it might not be an option. While thrift stores are actively trying to price resellers out of finding quality items at their shops, they still seem to be buying every good item to sell online, at pop-ups, or in boutiques.

Many people mention getting huge hauls from thrift stores and then posting those items for sale online for major increases.

Items are priced higher than they were brand new

Daisy Daisy/Adobe Interior Of Charity Shop

Even if you aren't shopping with individual resellers, a lot of thrift shops have been pricing their used items higher than you could ever purchase them new. Products that are recent releases but no longer available are sold like they were limited edition runs. Mugs and accessories purchased at the dollar store are often sold for two and three times the price, at minimum.

Overcrowding (items)

Kim/Adobe Retro dresses in flea market

Are the clothes jam-packed on the racks so tightly you can't see anything? Is it super crowded? Are items piled willy-nilly on the shelves or in the bins, making it impossible to find anything?

Thrift shop owners usually do what they can to make older, less convenient spaces more efficient, but hyper-consumerism means more inventory. Unfortunately, that often makes racks difficult to sort and navigate, resulting in a subpar experience.

Overcrowding (people)

AnnaStills/Adobe customers shopping at vintage store

One of the joys of thrifting used to be that you could take your time and leisurely consider an array of items from years past. 

These days, thrift shops can be so crowded that you can't even think straight long enough to make a decision on items you found, let alone enjoy the experience.

Store layout

catalyseur7/Adobe retro decoration pieces at flea market

Many thrift shops and secondhand stores do not invest in optimizing their store layouts, updating their spaces, or even making sure the hangers aren't broken. 

This could be because they go through so much inventory so quickly that it almost doesn't make sense to develop more structure.

Most secondhand stores just feel like mazes aimed at being physical manifestations of treasure troves.

Fast fashion is everywhere

qunica.com/Adobe woman browsing clothes at thrift store

The time has come… fast fashion is now in thrift stores across the United States. While looking for sturdy, well-made items, you will now have to dig through piles of thin, fraying H&M dresses, Forever 21 leggings, and SHEIN t-shirts for anything of worth.

Clothing items sometimes seem unwashed

cabecademarmore/Adobe Racks of winter clothing and coats

Clothing items aren't always taken care of correctly. If the store is understaffed or lacks the resources, they are likely to skip washing any donations before putting them on the sales floor.

Items that are not cleaned or washed make a negative impression on shoppers, and experiencing it can turn people off from purchasing from your store completely.

Some stores only let you scrape the bottom of the barrel

Stanisic Vladimir/Adobe woman shopping from eshop using tablet

Goodwill now sells hauls online, as do other vintage storefronts. So, it is safe to say that anything they deem worthy of making an actual chunk of change will be pulled aside for digital sales and even auctions.

If you walk into one of their stores, you are working with what is leftover, and even those items are often overpriced.

Amazon Prime members: get a $250 Amazon Gift Card!

If you're an Amazon Prime member, apply for the Prime Visa(Rates and fees) credit card here and you can get a $250 Amazon Gift Card instantly loaded into your Amazon account's Gift Card Balance upon approval (get an instant decision within 15 seconds).1

This is the perfect card to do some last minute holiday shopping, especially with the instant decision on application. There is no extra work or spending requirement and no annual fee! 

The Prime Visa credit card also lets you earn unlimited 5% back at Amazon.com, Amazon Fresh, Whole Foods Market, and on Chase Travel purchases with an eligible Prime membership, unlimited 2% back at gas stations, restaurants, and on local transit and commuting (including rideshare), and unlimited 1% on all other purchases.

If you spend a good amount on Amazon this card could be worth $100s in cash back every year. Don't delay — apply today!

Good or excellent credit (typically 670 or higher) is recommended.

Click here to apply for the Prime Visa credit card today and get an instant decision in 15 seconds

Some shops aren't transparent

Drazen/Adobe woman packing clothes for donation

When you donate your items to a thrift shop or secondhand storefront, you want to know that they are being used and put toward a good cause. Only about 10-30% of the clothes donated to thrift stores will be put on the sales floor.

While some thrift shops promise to recycle un-marketable clothing and fibers and do what they can to re-purpose damaged items, many don't go to the trouble. You often won't be able to tell which is which.

Bottom line

AnnaStills/Adobe Smiling man browsing clothes in thrift store

While thrifting can be a great way to save some cash, lately, it's taken a turn to the dark side — gentrification. 

This is the idea that thrifting is fashionable rather than a way to save money, which often leads to spikes in pricing and items that are not accessible to people who actually need them, instead going to shoppers who are just jumping on the thrifting bandwagon because it's trendy.

Avoid wasting money and help lower demand — and pricing — on thrifted items by working through hand-me-downs and yard sales before buying from a new seller or thrift shop.

Earn Easy Cash Rewards at Amazon.com

Benefits

Card Details

  • $0 annual fee and no foreign transaction fees
  • Eligible for Chase travel and purchase protections
  • Cashback rewards can be redeemed as soon as the next day
  • Apply Now
  • Limited-Time Offer: Get a $250 Amazon Gift Card instantly upon approval exclusively for Prime members
  • Best Amazon Gift Card offer for Prime Visa
  • Earn unlimited 5% back at Amazon.com, Amazon Fresh, Whole Foods Market and on Chase Travel purchases with an eligible Prime membership
  • Prime Card Bonus: Earn 10% back or more on a rotating selection of items and categories on Amazon.com with an eligible Prime membership
  • Earn unlimited 2% back at gas stations, restaurants, and on local transit and commuting (including rideshare)
  • Earn unlimited 1% back on all other purchases
  • No annual credit card fee
  • No more waiting. Redeem daily rewards at Amazon.com as soon as the next day
  • Member FDIC
Prime Visa
4.9
info

on Chase’s secure website

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

Limited-Time Offer: Get a $250 Amazon Gift Card instantly upon approval exclusively for Prime members

Annual Fee

$0

+

Why we like it


Financebuzz logo

Thanks for subscribing!

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.