7 Reasons Crumbl Cookies Are Totally Not Worth It

Consider keeping your money in your wallet instead of overspending on an overpriced Crumbl cookie
Updated May 7, 2024
Fact checked
Beaverton crumbl cookies

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

If Crumbl stores are starting to crop up in your area, we can’t blame you for being intrigued. If its colorful pink boxes aren’t enough to draw you in, the fresh cookie aroma should be enough to get you in the doors.

But Crumbl cookies aren’t exactly cheap, and you might be left wondering if these oversized cookies are really worth the cost or if you’d be better off avoiding wasting money on them.

Below, we list seven top reasons why you might want to consider skipping Crumbl’s cookies in favor of cheaper, tastier alternatives.

Earn cash back on everyday purchases with this rare account

Want to earn cash back on your everyday purchases without using a credit card? With the Discover®️ Cashback Debit Checking account (member FDIC), you can earn 1% cash back on up to $3,000 in debit card purchases each month!1

With no credit check to apply and no monthly fees to worry about, you can earn nearly passive income on purchases you’re making anyway — up to an extra $360 a year!

This rare checking account has other great perks too, like access to your paycheck up to 2 days early with Early Pay, no minimum deposit or monthly balance requirements, over 60K fee-free ATMs, and the ability to add cash to your account at Walmart stores nationwide.

Don’t leave money on the table — it only takes minutes to apply and it won’t impact your credit score.

Apply for a Discover Cashback Checking account today

One cookie can set you back $4 or more

Farknot Architect/Adobe asian woman eating piece of cookie

If you put aside flavor and stick solely to cost, it’s easy to see that Crumbl cookies just aren’t worth it. An individual Crumbl cookie goes for a minimum of $4, not accounting for additional taxes and franchise fees.

While the cookie’s size helps justify the cost, it’s hard to make the case that a single cookie is worth as much as a $5 box of a dozen chocolate chip cookies from your local grocery store.

They’re too sweet for some

seanlockephotography/Adobe Girl eating Chocolate Chip Cookie

How sugary do you like your cookies? If your answer is “as sweet as possible and then some,” Crumbl’s sugary cookies and extravagantly sweet frosting could make the high cost worth it for you. 

On the flip side, if you prefer your cookies unfrosted and with just enough sugar to make them delectable, Crumbl’s cookies really aren’t for you.

They’re absolutely massive

Nate/Adobe freshly baked chocolate chip cookies

Crumbl cookies are big enough that plenty of customers recommend cutting them into quarters to avoid a sugar-induced headache. Of course, you’ll have to store however much of the cookie you don’t finish. 

If it goes stale, you won’t be throwing out a few wasted cents — tossing even a quarter of an unfinished cookie is the equivalent of throwing a few dollars in the trash.

Get a protection plan on all your appliances

Did you know if your air conditioner stops working, your homeowner’s insurance won’t cover it? Same with plumbing, electrical issues, appliances, and more.

Whether or not you’re a new homeowner, a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty could pick up the slack where insurance falls short and protect you against surprise expenses. If a covered system in your home breaks, you can call their hotline 24/7 to get it repaired.

For a limited time, you can get your first month free with a Single Payment home warranty plan.

Get a free quote

The texture isn’t for everyone

Chris/Adobe chocolate chip cookies on plate

People can be picky about cookie textures. If you like thick, chewy, almost cake-like cookies, then Crumbl could be your new favorite dessert shop. 

However, if you want a cookie with some crunch, Crumbl definitely won’t suit your tastes. And if you do decide to try a Crumbl cookie, just know that you’ll be biting into something more like a brownie or a pound cake than a traditional cookie.

They don’t actually pair well with milk

fahrwasser/Adobe Homemade chocolate chip cookies with milk

There’s nothing more classic than cookies and milk, and most Crumbl stores sell bottles of milk alongside their boxes of cookies. But all that frosting — not to mention the cake-like texture and super-thick cookie base — makes a Crumbl cookie remarkably hard to dip.

If you like nibbling on cookies in between taking an occasional swig of milk, you might enjoy a Crumbl cookie. But you’ll have to settle for drinking your milk on the side because Crumbl cookies just aren’t easy to dip.

You’ll pay more than $30 for a dozen cookies

ReneLa/Peopleimages - AI/Adobe cookies on parchment paper

A box of cookies can be a nice shareable treat to lay out on the table during a casual get-together. But hosts often opt for cookies because they’re affordable — which makes Crumbl cookies a no-go for thrifty households.

If you’re planning to split each cookie in half to distribute among guests, paying over $30 for a box of 12 cookies might be worth it. But a box of donuts or a store-bought cake costs far less than a dozen Crumbl cookies, and you won’t have to do any awkward slicing or divvying up portions before your party starts.

DoorDash fees in your area could make Crumbl inaccessible

piter2121/Adobe DoorDash logo on smartphone screen

DoorDashing yourself some dessert is a fun way to round out an evening, but the treat isn’t always worth the exorbitant fees that get tacked on to some brands, including Crumbl.

The exact fees you’ll pay to order cookies from home differ depending on where you live, what app you’re using, and how much you tip. However, you shouldn’t be surprised if prices are more than double online than they are in stores: A box of four cookies costs over $22, a six-pack more than $31, and a 12-pack nearly $60.

Bottom line

Felix Mizioznikov/Adobe Tower Shops outdoor mall Davie Florida

If Crumbl cookies are your thing, who are we to talk you out of them? Just be sure to budget for this craveable habit — because, unlike some popular foodie trends, Crumbl cookies don’t go easy on your bank account.

And if you haven’t hopped on the Crumbl cookie train quite yet, your wallet is one good reason to stay away. Keep more cash in the bank and stick with more affordable homemade treats, or else grab a box of freshly made treats from a budget-friendly store like Costco or Walmart, where you don’t have to exchange affordability for flavor.

Discover®️ Cashback Debit Benefits

  • Earn 1% cash back on up to $3,000 in debit card purchases each month1
  • No minimum deposit, no minimum balance, and no account fees
  • Access your paycheck up to 2 days early with Early Pay
  • 60K+ fee-free ATMs and make cash deposits at Walmart stores nationwide

Author Details

Michelle Smith Michelle Smith has spent a decade writing for and about small businesses. She specializes in all things finance and has written for publications like G2 and SmallBizDaily. When she's not writing for work at her desk, you can usually find her writing for pleasure near large bodies of water.

Want to learn how to make an extra $200?

Get proven ways to earn extra cash from your phone, computer, & more with Extra.

You will receive emails from FinanceBuzz.com. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy

  • Vetted side hustles
  • Exclusive offers to save money daily
  • Expert tips to help manage and escape debt