Saving & Spending Budgeting & Expenses

10 Bills Middle Class Americans Shouldn't Put on Autopay

Learn which payments require a hands-on approach to protect your budget and avoid hidden costs.

By Kristin Hitchcock

Edited by Andrea Basse

Updated Nov. 18, 2025

If you're working to build your wealth, it may feel smart to let bills slide quietly into autopay. After all, setting it and forgetting it seems efficient, and fewer late fees sound like a win. But sometimes the convenience of autopay can undermine control and cost middle class Americans more than they expect.

Below are several types of bills that deserve a manual review instead of full autopay mode.

Get instant access to hundreds of discounts

Over 50? Join AARP today— because if you’re not a member you could be missing out on huge perks like discounts on travel, dining, and even prescriptions.

Get 25% off membership — just $15 for your first year with auto-renewal — and a free gift if you join today.

Become an AARP member now

Credit card minimum payments

When you set a credit card to autopay, it's often set to pay the minimum amount due. That might prevent a late fee, but it doesn't stop interest from accumulating. Variable bills, including credit cards, are among those that should not automatically be debited without oversight.

By staying on top of your monthly statement and intentionally paying more than the minimum, you'll likely reduce interest costs and keep better control of balances.

Who really has the cheapest auto insurance in your area? Check your zip code here.

Bills with variable amounts

Recurring bills that fluctuate (think: utilities, water, gas, or even streaming services with roaming data usage) are riskier on autopay. As noted by PNC Bank, when you automate payments for amounts you're not regularly reviewing, you might miss spikes or extra fees.

That means autopay can mask cost increases or surprise charges before you catch them. Manually checking gives you the chance to spot big shifts and question them.

Subscription services you rarely use

We all sign up for streaming, memberships, freebies, and trial periods. When you set autopay and "out of sight, out of mind" takes over, you might keep paying for services you're no longer using. The State Farm advice page highlights this as a downside of autopay: the "easy to forget" trap.

To put your money where it matters, consider keeping subscriptions manually paid (or on autopay with alerts) so you stay aware of active services and cancel as needed.

Resolve $10,000 or more of your debt

National Debt Relief could help you resolve your credit card debt with an affordable plan that works for you. Just tell them your situation, then find out your debt relief options.¹ <p>Clients who are able to stay with the program and get all their debt settled realize approximate savings of 45% before fees, or 20% including our fees, over 12 to 48 months. All claims are based on enrolled debts. Not all debts are eligible for enrollment. Not all clients complete our program for various reasons, including their ability to save sufficient funds. Estimates based on prior results, which will vary based on specific circumstances. We do not guarantee that your debts will be lowered by a specific amount or percentage or that you will be debt-free within a specific period of time. We do not assume consumer debt, make monthly payments to creditors or provide tax, bankruptcy, accounting or legal advice or credit repair services. Not available in all states. Please contact a tax professional to discuss tax consequences of settlement. Please consult with a bankruptcy attorney for more information on bankruptcy. Depending on your state, we may be available to recommend a local tax professional and/or bankruptcy attorney. Read and understand all program materials prior to enrollment, including potential adverse impact on credit rating.</p>

Bills when your income or cash-flow varies

If your paycheck or cash‐flow fluctuates (maybe seasonal work, commission, side hustle income), autopay could set you up for overdrafts or missed payments. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reminds us that automatic debits can incur NSF (insufficient funds) or stop-payment fees if you don't have enough balance.

In these cases, manual payment or scheduling just after your payday may give you more control and fewer surprises.

Services from providers with known billing or rate-change issues

Some providers are known to increase rates, tack on new fees, or have confusing billing practices. Autopay makes it easier for those changes to slip by. Before setting autopay for any service, review the provider's history for rate hikes, surcharges, or billing quirks, so you're not locked in and unknowingly paying more.

Loans or payments you're trying to accelerate paying off

If you're aggressively trying to pay down a loan (auto loan, student loan, personal loan), autopay might hinder your flexibility. Because it usually triggers a standard payment each period, it limits your ability to make extra principal payments or pause payments temporarily if needed. Automatic payments create a false sense of security.

When your goal is to reduce debt faster, manual oversight helps you decide when to send extra or adjust strategy.

Make Money: 8 things to do if you're barely scraping by financially

Insurance premiums

Auto, renters, and life insurance premiums can change annually, and some policies automatically renew at higher rates. When payments are on autopay, those increases might slip by unnoticed. Reviewing your renewal documents before paying helps you compare rates or negotiate better terms.

Policyholders often miss opportunities to switch or re-shop coverage simply because autopay hides price hikes.

Medical bills

Healthcare billing errors are surprisingly common. Studies have found that as many as 80% medical bills contain mistakes. If you set autopay before verifying charges or waiting for insurance adjustments, you could end up overpaying.

Always confirm that your insurer processed the claim correctly and that you're only paying what you truly owe. Once the bill is confirmed, you can then make a one-time payment confidently.

Cell phone and internet bills

Phone and internet providers frequently adjust fees, tack on small surcharges, or increase rates after promotional periods end. With autopay enabled, those changes might go unnoticed for months.

Manual payment (or at least a monthly review) gives you the chance to challenge new charges, renegotiate plans, or switch providers before costs creep up.

Earn $200 cash rewards bonus with this incredible card

The Wells Fargo Active Cash^® Card (Rates and fees) has no annual fee and you can earn $200 cash rewards bonus after spending $500 in purchases in the first 3 months.

Cardholders can also earn unlimited 2% cash rewards on purchases.

The best part? There's no annual fee.

Click here to apply now.

Gym memberships and fitness apps

Gym and fitness memberships are among the most common money leaks for middle class households. Once you stop going regularly, that monthly fee keeps draining your account.

Rather than letting autopay renew indefinitely, opt for manual payments or short-term memberships that require active renewal. You'll stay aware of how often you're using the service, and what it's really worth to you.

Bottom line

Autopay can be a useful tool for managing fixed, predictable bills, but it's not ideal for payments that fluctuate, require verification, or involve services you might cancel. Taking a hands-on approach to these bills helps you maintain control, avoid unexpected charges, and make smarter financial decisions.

Interestingly, a recent survey by the Federal Reserve found that nearly 40% of adults would struggle to cover a $400 emergency expense, highlighting the importance of reviewing bills manually. Staying engaged with your payments can help you prepare yourself financially.

More from FinanceBuzz:

Benefits

Card Details

$0 annual fee
Intro APR on purchases and balance transfers
Apply Now

INTRO OFFER: Unlimited Cashback Match for all new cardmembers–only from Discover. Discover will automatically match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year! There’s no minimum spending or maximum rewards. You could turn $150 cash back into $300.
Earn 5% cash back on everyday purchases at different places you shop each quarter like grocery stores, restaurants, gas stations, and more, up to the quarterly maximum when you activate. Plus, earn unlimited 1% cash back on all other purchases.
Redeem cash back for any amount
Apply now and you could get a decision in as little as 90 seconds. No annual fee.
Start shopping and earning rewards in minutes with your virtual card, before your physical card arrives in the mail, if eligible.
Get a 0% intro APR for 15 months on purchases. Then 17.74% to 26.74% Standard Variable Purchase APR applies, based on credit worthiness.
Terms and conditions apply.

Discover <span class='whitespace-nowrap'>it<sup>®</sup></span> Cash Back

4.7

Apply Now

on Discover’s secure website

Read Card Review

Intro Offer

Discover will match all the cash back you’ve earned at the end of your first year.

Annual Fee

Why we like it